Silicon Knights versus Epic: Round 151

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
Can someone just get a court date for these two already? Also (without taking sides), I just want to point out that "Too Human" sucking had nothing to do with the game engine it was made on...that game just sucked. :eek:

In 2007, Silicon Knights sued Epic Games for failure to "provide a working game engine" for Too Human, causing the Ontario based game developer to "experience considerable losses." Silicon Knights' suit alleged that Epic was "sabotaging" Unreal Engine 3 licensees, withholding an improved version of that game engine while also using licensing fees to fund development of Gears of War, not to improve the Unreal Engine. In short, Silicon Knights said it didn't get what it was promised by Epic and it wants a cut of those Gears of War profits as compensation.
 
Wow, now that is one convulted argument. I'd like to see Silicon Knights point to where in the licensing contract it obligates Epic to spend licensing fees improving the engine. :rolleyes:
 
Wow, now that is one convulted argument. I'd like to see Silicon Knights point to where in the licensing contract it obligates Epic to spend licensing fees improving the engine. :rolleyes:

Also, the engine was being worked on alongside Gears of War, and the two were pretty intertwined. What good is working on a game engine if there's no game being made with it to test and work with the code?
 
Um yea, GOW and UT are the test bed games that Epic uses to develop the Unreal platform.

If they can't build a good game with the UT3 game engine it is because they are idiots.
 
Yeah, I'd have to see the contact.....but that just looks like a fucking retarded argument on the surface.
 
Plenty of other games are being run on the Unreal Engine and doing just fine.
 
And here I thought Too Human was a pretty decent game for the 360.

Granted I didn't pick it up until it hit 10 dollars on a black Friday weekend sale, but still...
 
I remember reading about this when it started. I think they claimed that they had other developers that agreed with them or something. Really it all just sounds like an excuse so that don't have to admit that all of the game's problems were theirs and that Microsoft wasted the 100 million dollars (rumored) they spent on the franchise.
 
haha... yeah, cause it was Epic's fault the game sucked. The reasons that game failed had nothing to do with what engine they used. At no point when playing that game did i think, "damn, this UT3 engine ruined this game!"
 
The funny thing about the claim is that the longer they wait, the more stupid they look. "Oh Epic deliberately crippled UE3!" Really? So that's why there's about 200+ games out that use it, including some of the best sellers out there? Kinda hard to talk about how badly "crippled" it is when every 3rd game seems to use it, and Epic keeps showing off new features.

Like it or no UE3 is a very solid engine with top flight dev tools, and hence it gets used all the time.

This is pure BS and whining.
 
And here I thought Too Human was a pretty decent game for the 360.

Granted I didn't pick it up until it hit 10 dollars on a black Friday weekend sale, but still...

Same here, I waited till it was $25 and thought it was a decently fun game, held my attention long enough to finish it at least.
 
Never heard of this game. It is clearly Epic's fault for not sending someone from marketing to my house to tell me all about it.
 
It's a decent game, although I also grabbed it while on sale. I'm also a tad bias as their office is in my town. I always think when I drive by their office building, "Hey those guys are up there that made the Legacy of Kain games...they still around? That's been years ago now"
 
Maybe it had something to do with game having controls that were crap and a story that was convoluted and a rip off of viking lore with technology added. The games fighting system was crap and the previews were 1000% better than actual game visuals, that is not the fault of the engine.
 
Other game makers were able to use UE3. It's probably true that UE3 caused problems for SK, but it's not like they got a special "make-a-lame-game-using-it" edition.
 
It's a decent game, although I also grabbed it while on sale. I'm also a tad bias as their office is in my town. I always think when I drive by their office building, "Hey those guys are up there that made the Legacy of Kain games...they still around? That's been years ago now"

Actually they only made Blood Omen. Every other game in the series was done by Crystal Dynamics.
 
I don't know why everyone jumps to Epic's defense, SK aren't trying to blame Epic for the game sucking, they're accusing them of withholding features and support which SK believe they had paid for, in order to give GoW an unfair advantage. I can absolutely believe that happened.
But I never played Too Human, and I'll never touch another GoW, so I don't care either way.
 
Can someone just get a court date for these two already? Also (without taking sides), I just want to point out that "Too Human" sucking had nothing to do with the game engine it was made on...that game just sucked. :eek:


Wait so all of the games like Splinter Cell: Chaos Theory (and the other two sequels), Batman Arkham Asylum, Brothers In Arms, Bullet Storm, and Mass Effect 1& 2, were supposed to be crap then?

Quick call a lawyer, these games shouldn't have won awards!
 
Back
Top