Shuttle Successor Fails Test

It is funny how all the best engineers are punting it on a hardware forum and not designing the shuttle's replacement no?

I agree Paul, maybe if Congress gets serious, and NASA gets a budget and they decide to start hiring for a major effort, we can put some of those estimated 600,000 US citizen engineers out of work at the moment.... TO WORK!!!! :eek::rolleyes::p
 
It is funny how all the best engineers are punting it on a hardware forum and not designing the shuttle's replacement no?

I agree Paul, maybe if Congress gets serious, and NASA gets a budget and they decide to start hiring for a major effort, we can put some of those estimated 600,000 US citizen engineers out of work at the moment.... TO WORK!!!! :eek::rolleyes::p

Well if they are going to start hiring from these ranks people are going to have to take time off from the patent law practice as well.
 
There's hopes and dreams, and there is reality. The engineers at NASA (and everywhere else) have to work in the latter, not the former. You can have all the visionary leadership you want, but the simple fact is nasa won't be getting that kind of funding. Hell, the "visionary" obama has already said he's willing to push back the shuttle replacement program by 5 years to pay for healthcare. In the eyes of the people, space flight is unfortunately not a priority anymore. The choice is then: try to go big and end up getting nowhere, or design a system that can accomplish the mission requested, (service ISS, get to the moon, get to mars) that fits the budgetary requirements.

A very good example is where NASA is heading with the Ares rockets. They currently have funding to build Ares-1 and Orion (to the tune of about 15 billion dollars). This gives us a rocket of launching the base Orion capsule to LEO to service the ISS. This rocket is also currently experiencing severe performance problems that keep eating away at its capabilities, and adding to its cost. To fufill the rest of the mission requirement, a second rocket, the Ares-V also needs to be developed (to the tune of another 15 billion). This rocket would launch all the heavy cargo while the crews were launched on ares-1.

The problem is, there is no gaurantee that Ares-V will be funded. Which leaves us stuck in LEO with ares-1. Alternate solutions, like direct, use shuttle program derived components to build a common core rocket that adds an extra motor and upper stage for cargo launches, and deletes them for crew launches. One development program that solves both problems.

The tradeoff is some extra capacity on the LEO/ISS mission profile (which, coincidentally, could be filled with fuel for an orbital tug) and a tiny bit less capacity on the cargo launches, but the base cost is a bit higher for the LEO/ISS launches. Overall, the program is 15 Billion cheaper (only design and test one rocket with common parts/engines).

The DIRECT proposal lays this all out much easier than I can explain it. You end up with more mass capacity at a cheaper cost-per-pound (even if you have to do it with multiple launches) with a sane system instead of the massive effort to build the biggest rocket ever.

Engineering unfortunately is about compromise. You never get your cake and eat it all, but sometimes you can eat a bit more.

Saying "Screw it, go big and hope we have funding to finish" is irresponsible. Nobody can predict the socio-economic climate 10 years down the road.

None of this changes the fact that the same 200 billion you want to spend on shuttles could buy twice or three times as much capacity on a new, sane, launch system that leverages components and experience from the shuttle program to build an efficient end-to-end system that is compatible with current launch infrastructure. Even if that 200 billion was freed up tomorrow, the public would have the head of any president/congress that gave it all to NASA. Reality sucks, but we have to live with it. I agree with you that the bean counters shouldn't be in charge of development (the DIRECT proposal is the work of moonlighting engineers who are displeased with the current program), but economic considerations have to be accounted for or we end up watching china conquer the moon for the glorious revolution on cnn.
 
Yeah you would think after the first 2 or 3 Apollo's blew up, there might be something wrong, they got it figured out by number 7 or 8 though, this one is going to be no different...maybe they will fix the parachute issue before they start blowing up the astronauts on the launch pad like the Apollo missions?
 
Which apollo flights are you talking about? The only major issues from apollo was the fire on apollo 1 (not related to the rocket, failure was in the command module) and apollo 13, which was also a command module problem.

And again, as was stated before, the actual recovery system didn't fail the test, a pre-test parachute to set up the right conditions for the test failed.
 
Back
Top