The 457 are great movie cans since they're rather dark. They have bloated bass, but it's alright if you're a bass head. Even if you're not, the highs aren't too harsh and the mids aren't so recessed that you would dislike them.
The EH150 sound like almost every other cheaply made closed headphone. Bloated, harsh highs, and recessed mids. Not a recommendation for anything.
If you really do want to choose between those two, then go for the 457. If you want to be open to ideas, go with kamal's suggestion for the KSC75. Cheap, better than what you currently have, and only ~ $20.