Screw sizes

DanNeely

Supreme [H]ardness
Joined
Aug 26, 2005
Messages
4,854
This is mainly an idle curiosity question, but why is there a different size/threading used for floppy/cd screws than for hds, mobos, and case assembly?

I'm also curious about the third size of screw used for fans, although I suspect that may be due to the fans originally having been made for a different market than PCs.
 
This is mainly an idle curiosity question, but why is there a different size/threading used for floppy/cd screws than for hds, mobos, and case assembly?

I'm also curious about the third size of screw used for fans, although I suspect that may be due to the fans originally having been made for a different market than PCs.

fine threading for motherboards, cards, and things like HD's and opticals

more coarse threads for case screws and PSU

ultra coarse, giant threads for fans because they are unthreaded to begin with
 
Both of you appear to've missed the focus of my question. I'm not asking what screws goto what components,. but rather why the use of multiple sizes of screw with all the oops potential it brings instead of a single standard length, diameter, and threading.
 
why the use of multiple sizes of screw with all the oops potential it brings instead of a single standard length, diameter, and threading.

I agree that the different (sometimes subtle) sizes can be a problem - like putting a slightly too small screw into a drive and then having it wiggle out - but there are other reasons for them being different.

If you start with the drive screws, they are limited in length, usually about 5mm. That's so the screw doesn't punch through the drive case or crunch the circuit board. That 5mm length might be too short for other screws.

I do agree that if they all had the same thread that would be good, but that would then allow someone to put a long screw into the drive by mistake. If every screw could be 5mm or if drive makers would allow slightly longer, we could probably standardize on a single screw size.

OTOH, there are good reasons to say that we can get rid of a lot of screws in a computer by designing other mounting methods. Standardized rails for drives and similar devices could eliminate screws for those entirely. I've seen cases with clamping systems to hold add-in cards in place (instead of screws holding the L brackets individually). These sorts of things have their adherents and opposers, so unless the industry decides to force us to use them, you'll never get the computer community to demand them in a unified manner.
 
I agree that standardization is unlikely anytime soon. I'm wondering about the historical reasons that resulted in the current menagerie of different sizes.
 
Also agree that the lack of standardization is the answer to the OP's question.

We have to remember that some of these go back a decade or more. Pretty difficult to get the whole industry to
change over something like thread sizes. Heck, takes years for them to decide what form factor to support. :eek:
 
Totally OT, but it seems you've moved up in the world since you're finally able to aford the capital gains tax. Or am I thinking of a different skippy?
 
huh. Small world I guess. What're the odds though, the other 'skippy' was also an 'evil twin'.
 
Back
Top