samsung HD753LJ problems

chrcoluk

[H]ard|Gawd
Joined
Jul 7, 2008
Messages
1,274
Got this new samsung 750gig drives after some sites gave it good reviews, put a swap partition at the start of it and then formatted the rest as one large ntfs partition.

Problems started almost right away.

1 - copying some files of older drive with write cache enabled, was fast but then frequently stalled for sometimes many minutes, in diskmon during the stall it showed extreme slow writes.
2 - disabling write cache the stalls eventually clear up and it can write with no stalls but the write speeds are horrific slower than the oldest drive in my machine.
3 - upgraded the ICH7R drivers to latest, tried again with write cache, this time no stalls so think its fixed, however after a hour or so, this time the entire disk seem to crash and because the swap was on it the system was more or less frozen stuck trying to page, hard resetted the pc. ON next bootup in the event logs was a iastor timeout error and loads of errors cannot write to the pagefile on the disk.
4 - downgraded to older ich7R drivers I had used for years and no such stall problems, things seemed much better, these older drivers force write caching off tho so performance poor on the system, however 10 minutes ago the system stalled for 2 minutes, sure enough in the event log iastor timed out and cannot write to page disk.

I did at first blame the intel controller and its drivers (ICH7R) but now I dont think its the problem.

Googling shows this drive has issues on nforce boards and disabling NCQ fixes the issues, so I suspect it may be it messing up on NCQ and if I ran the ICH7 in ide mode it would be fine.

Before I put the drive in I had no iastor timeouts at all with 3 other drives using it.
Even with the errors the event log is showing no timeout errors on the other 3 drives.

My board is a asus p5wdh deluxe with the ICH7R controller in RAID mode using raid drivers in windows xp.

Anyone else had problems with this drive? and does this problem sound like a drive or controller error to you?
 
I'm running eight of those exact same drives in RAID, and I've had no problems so far, so I suspect you might either have chipset issues or your particular drive may be defective.
 
an update, this was fixed by moving the drive to the jmicron controller, no stuttering, no weird freezes and better all round.
 
There is known issues with Samsungs and a lot of controllers out there. It's no surprise to me that it's a compatibility issue.
 
I am also having some misfortunes with this drive. Now that I think about, it could have had problems since I got it but I am not a pc guru so I just took it for granted.

Sometimes, I would restart the PC and it would just hang, I would have to hit the Reset button to make it boot up. Some other times, right from a cold start it would hang and I had to hit the reset button.

A couple of weeks ago I was updating my nForce drivers on my EVGA 680i mobo when the thing just froze on the Windows splash screen and didn't move from there. My first thought was that the new drivers botched the mobo some how, then, little by little I found out that one of my modules had gone bad, took it out, tried again but to no avail. So far, I am trying to recover my data from the samsung but it is getting harder and harder to do.

Last night I tried to format and install a fresh copy of windows on the first partitition (2nd partitition was purely for back-up data) to see if I could recover the data easily but it wouldn't even format.

I loved the drive, it was very fast but I have never had so many problems with a drive as I did with this one and it is not even 6 months old.

Sorry to crap on your thread, I was just venting my frustation with it I guess.
 
Back
Top