Saitek Eclipse, Logitech G11, or MS Reclusa?

A Shiny Demon

Limp Gawd
Joined
Oct 18, 2006
Messages
249
I just bought myself a Razer Deathadder for a self-birthday-present, and now I can't stand the sight of my beige $5 Big Lots GE keyboard sitting next to this sleek new piece of sexy pointing device. I've been wondering about getting a Saitek Eclipse (not Eclipse II, I don't like the styling, don't need purple and red, and have heard it has Linux incompatablities). My friend just bought one, and it seems really nice, but he's had it for just over a month and told me just the other day that the paint is already starting to wear off the letters. That would irritate me quite a bit.

I recently did some research, and turned up the Logitech G11: the G15 without the (IMHO) completely useless/gimmicky LCD. However, it's still a little pricey, and I don't need the 18 or 54 or whatever extra buttons. I prefer scripts and whatnot to macros when it comes to CSS anyway, and even without the LCD this keyboard is a bit pricey.

The Microsoft *cough* Razer *cough* Reclusa seems to be the most promising, but unfortunately it's too new right now for any reviews to give any indication as to its durability.

I would get a Deck "The Legend," but for the price I could replace my 3800+ Venice with an Opteron 165 and maybe have enough left over to get an Eclipse...

I'm interested in the opinions of anyone who owns or has used the boards, or any similar. In case you haven't noticed, the key point here isn't "fit as many buttons as possible," it's the blue backlight. I need to be able to see in the dark for Starcraft hotkeys... especially those pesky Protoss hotkeys that are all over the right side of the keyboard. :p
 
I was in the same predicament, but I had narrowed my choices down to the Enermax Aurora or Dell's multimedia keyboard. I never used a slim keyboard before so I wanted to try a cheap one before I put down $60 on the Aurora, and to also make up my mind between the Dell and Aurora. So I bought this: http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16823201015 . Now I prefer the slim-style keyboards to others, and it's so nice I'm not even going to bother getting the Aurora. It takes a while to get used to though, your WPM will go down ~10WPM, but after a while it will be ~10WPM higher than with a regular keyboard.
 
I was in the same predicament, but I had narrowed my choices down to the Enermax Aurora or Dell's multimedia keyboard. I never used a slim keyboard before so I wanted to try a cheap one before I put down $60 on the Aurora, and to also make up my mind between the Dell and Aurora. So I bought this: http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16823201015 . Now I prefer the slim-style keyboards to others, and it's so nice I'm not even going to bother getting the Aurora. It takes a while to get used to though, your WPM will go down ~10WPM, but after a while it will be ~10WPM higher than with a regular keyboard.

I toyed with the idea of a "laptop-style" keyboard for a while, but I'm not sure how well it would work out for gaming and such. I do like the tiny travel distance of that style of keys, though. I might have to reconsider my "blue lights" obsession.
 
I toyed with the idea of a "laptop-style" keyboard for a while, but I'm not sure how well it would work out for gaming and such. I do like the tiny travel distance of that style of keys, though. I might have to reconsider my "blue lights" obsession.

It works extremely well with gaming, just make sure you get a slim keyboard with scissor key action. Think about it, it takes less time for the desired action to occur than with a regular keyboard.
 
I had a G15 (G11 + LCD) for ~6 months. I didn't like the feel - the keys felt like a laptop keyboard and the numpad enter key doesn't work well if you tap the corner instead of hitting it dead-on. (I ended up selling it with my WoW account last August - heh)

I bought the saitek eclipse 2 when it was on Woot last year and I absolutely love it. Great feel, the backlight works well, absolutely no sign of wear (and I do use my PC a lot)...
 
Ive had my Saitek Eclipse for more than a year, and have no wear on the keys at all. I think older versions had the wearing issue, anything produced lately may not have this problem?

Its a great keyborad, I love the look and feel. But the lighting is not very bright, just so you know.
 
These good opinions of the Eclipse and Eclipse II are reassuring. However, as stated above, the Eclipse II appears to be incompatible with Linux, though I'm still trying to figure out how that's possible for a keyboard. Linux is a must. I might get the Eclipse sometime soon; I was hoping people would have high opinions of it, since it's also the cheapest of the three keyboards I'm considering.
 
These good opinions of the Eclipse and Eclipse II are reassuring. However, as stated above, the Eclipse II appears to be incompatible with Linux, though I'm still trying to figure out how that's possible for a keyboard. Linux is a must. I might get the Eclipse sometime soon; I was hoping people would have high opinions of it, since it's also the cheapest of the three keyboards I'm considering.

i have the saitek II and one of the user complaints was that some of the keys started to wear early on - i have the same compaint - the E key on mine is already getting worn out and i've only had it a month :( i have to press it a few times or really hard to get an E to show up, and i dont use my PC for more than a few hours a day.
Dont mean to discourage but facts are facts.:(
I do like the lights though:cool:

I do also have an iRocks blue backlit keyboard thats laptop type that does quite well and got good reviews, but its just a basic keyboard, nothing special.
 
Back
Top