John Adams stated, "Our Constitution was made only for a moral and religious people. It is wholly inadequate to the government of any other."
Now before someone jumps on the "religious" part, keep this in perspective. A religious person that is honest in their belief - and that's the key here - believes they have to answer to a higher authority for their own behavior. This puts them subject to another authority, and (ideally) keeps them from seeing themselves as the highest authority as government. "Better not steal that, better not take that bribe because God is watching," as it were. It is this kind of internal restraint that Adams was speaking of. The same with the moral part. Morality is simply keeping to a code of behavior and not violating it, wherever that code of behavior originates. Without it, anything goes.
While I tend to agree with the basic idea of what you're saying here, I think the John Adams statement would be just as (if not more) accurate if it just said for moral people.
You have to remember a lot of the elected officials right now are serious bible thumpers. The guy who wrote SOPA, Lamar Smith, is especially religious. It doesn't prevent them from being shitty people who do shitty things.
I'm a fairly religious person and I tend to vote Republican simply because I like the idea of a smaller government, but seriously if a Republican is capable of authoring something like SOPA while maintaining a straight face - then all hope for a small government is lost.
Nobody worth a damn will ever even be considered for president because all the crooked bastards are flush with cash and connections. Even if a decent person did become president, it would take one hell of a man to not instantly sell out.
In my opinion, our best bet is to try and limit the power of the government as much as possible (or as much as is reasonable) and take it upon ourselves to be the moral citizens that are worth a damn, and handle the things that the government no longer would. That will never happen either, though.