Rambus Seeks To Block NVIDIA Products

According to Rambus, like every single memory technology since SDR that any company uses has infringed on their works. Did ATI already settle with them? They've been on with Nvidia for five six years or smth.

I'm not sure if ATI did, but AMD is the parent company of ATI and AMD has a license to the Rambus portfolio (for which they paid $75M if I recall), so ATI is probably covered.

It would not appear that Rambus could get an injunction in District Court in light of the Supreme Court's decision in eBay, as direct competition is a major factor and Rambus doesn't make competing silicon. It's truly an odd situation that the ITC can, more or less, provide an equitable remedy directly in conflict with the Supreme Court's ruling.
 
Ha. Welcome to the HardOCP mob mentality vs.Rambus. Rambus is collecting royalties on any ddr tech put out so, considering the DDR companies are infringing on their technology, they have every right under the law to do what they are doing. You all really just have a mob mentality hatefest vs. rambus. Eventually DDR will run out of steam. You can only throw so many pins at it.
 
Ha. Welcome to the HardOCP mob mentality vs.Rambus. Rambus is collecting royalties on any ddr tech put out so, considering the DDR companies are infringing on their technology, they have every right under the law to do what they are doing. You all really just have a mob mentality hatefest vs. rambus. Eventually DDR will run out of steam. You can only throw so many pins at it.

Rambus patented technology that was not only public knowledge but already publicly used by their competitors, without existing patents by anyone. They patented the tech after a JEDEC meeting where they were shown the technology.

They now profit from this underhanded, back-stabbing, total-bastard, waste-of-skin, abuse of patent rights. There are new laws prohibiting others from doing what Rambus did, it is just too bad they are not retro-active.

Rambus hate is WELL deserved. For holding back the entire industry, and hence further invention and overall human benefit from computers, PERIOD.

I hope the new administration does something to curb this garbage... like make the new applicable laws retroactive to current markets.
 
Rambus patented technology that was not only public knowledge but already publicly used by their competitors, without existing patents by anyone. They patented the tech after a JEDEC meeting where they were shown the technology.

They now profit from this underhanded, back-stabbing, total-bastard, waste-of-skin, abuse of patent rights. There are new laws prohibiting others from doing what Rambus did, it is just too bad they are not retro-active.

Rambus hate is WELL deserved. For holding back the entire industry, and hence further invention and overall human benefit from computers, PERIOD.

I hope the new administration does something to curb this garbage... like make the new applicable laws retroactive to current markets.

I can agree with that. Except for making the laws retroactive. That is not going to happen. Read the Constitution and Bill of Rights to figure out why. :D

Also, as a consequence of RAMBUS's past and continuing actions, you can bet that many other tech companies are going to try to avoid RAMBUS's tech when possible. Which means RAMBUS needs to eek as much out of their current patents as possible.

Overly litigious companies like RAMBUS are also part of the reason we see so many, often idiotic, patent applications from damn near every tech company out there. You now have to try and patent every little thing, no matter how small or insignificant, so you can use it in court to defend against the likes of RAMBUS when they sue you.
 
Rambus patented technology that was not only public knowledge but already publicly used by their competitors, without existing patents by anyone. They patented the tech after a JEDEC meeting where they were shown the technology.

They now profit from this underhanded, back-stabbing, total-bastard, waste-of-skin, abuse of patent rights. There are new laws prohibiting others from doing what Rambus did, it is just too bad they are not retro-active.

Rambus hate is WELL deserved. For holding back the entire industry, and hence further invention and overall human benefit from computers, PERIOD.

I hope the new administration does something to curb this garbage... like make the new applicable laws retroactive to current markets.

This is actually incorrect. You're basing your opinion on incorrect knowlege.
 
Read what you want. If you feel better posting FUD about something you don't care to research, be my guest.
 
I Rambus were to die then someone else would buy the patent and the whole thing would start up again. Picture AMD/ATI or Intel acquiring and using it to sue Nvidia back to the stone age, both companies have a beef with Nvidia.
 
OK guys - get your facts straight :)

Rambus invented the technology that made SDRAM and DDR possible LONG before JEDEC did. They shared their technology with several memory manufacturers BEFORE joining JEDEC.

There was a memo from Siemens I believe called "The Deadly Menace" memo - which basically shows Rambus as a threat to the entire industry since they had an idea that outshined anything JEDEC was working on. You can google it, it's out there.

If you read Willie Meyer's own words, he says in the memo "Some day all computers will need to be built like this, but hopefully without royalties going to Rambus." In other words, they intended to steal Rambus' IP.

Rambus was invited to join JEDEC. JEDEC is *NOT* opposed to paying royalties if they feel the design fits the specification - the only provision is that JEDEC members are given "RAND" royalty rates (Reasonable and Non-Disciminatory). Rambus went into the JEDEC meetings thinking they would be allowed to present their technology for consideration.

In the entire history of JEDEC, only ONE company has ever been barred from presenting - that company? Rambus. They asked several times to present, but were told no. Instead, every other company in JEDEC presented their technology. Rambus saw that these companies were all including technology in their presentations that belonged to them. How did they know it was their technology? Simple - they shared it with those companies under non-disclosure when they wanted 'em to manufacture RDRAM.

So - why didn't Rambus speak up and warn people regarding their infringement? They couldn't. The patent laws of the time prevented you from revealing patent applications. They were legally bound to remain silent until the patents were actually granted.

However, that doesn't make their patents or applications 100% valid.

The bottom line: JEDEC knew what it was doing. If they couldn't get it for free, they were going to steal it. They knew they had NOTHING that would compete with that technology and they knew that they weren't the first to develop it. They had NO CHOICE but to steal it or pay royalties.

Now that some time has gone by and Rambus was able to win a few lawsuits, this move should come as no suprise. SDRAM, DDR and GDDR all fall under the same patents that Rambus filed for long before JEDEC tried to steal it. Rambus is fully within their right to be compensated for their invention.
 
Rambus are still alive?

I know they died when Intel dropped them, then I heard they were coming back, now they are trying to pull a patent lawsuit on a company using DDR 5?

Did I miss something, did Rambus invent a GPU or a processor similar to how the majority of GPU's work?
 
Damn no edit buttons

Just noticed the second from previous post...Surely the IP lawsuit lies with JEDEC then if that is where Nvidia get there memory from?
 
It all stems from the same place.

Rambus filed for the patent for their technology in the late 80's
JEDEC tried to cherry-pick their patents in the early 90's when they were still pending
It covers SDRAM, DDR, GDDR technologies.

Rambus didn't start suing until their patents were approved. All the companies sued attempted to claim prior art, but all were unsuccessful in doing so. Rambus was truly the first company (then 3 people) to dream up today's memory technology.

XDR, on the other hand, is a completely different animal. And as such, it's loads faster than any of the junk we're using today.

Honestly, the whole tale is kind of sad from a technology standpoint. Had JEDEC not tried to steal, we'd all have faster memory - it wouldn't be limited to just PS3's and Cell blades.
 
my memory might be a bit hazy, so feel free to correct me, but wasn't SD and DDR ram around *before* rambus and RD?
 
They still have two openenings for leagal (patend counsel and IP development) and one for egnineering if anyone's interested.

They have 566 patents listed on their site. Some seem quite sweeping patents that could cover future technology. I noticed they have several memory interface patents. With AMD and Intel placing memory interface on the CPU, I wonder what this means for licnesing and potential suits in the future.
 
With any luck, Rambus will make JEDEC obsolete. I've never been a fan of "Technology by Committee" anyway, unless it came out of DARPA :)

AMD and Intel don't have to worry about Rambus as they both are Rambus licensees. The only ones who have to worry are companies who are selling SD, DDR or GDDR without a license.

NVIDIA will likely settle and become a licensee.

I read a rumor somewhere (I think it might have been at the inq) that "Larrabee" was going to use Rambus XDR... Now THAT would make things interesting. But take that with a grain of salt (especially if it came from the inquirer).
 
They are still around... I guess their business is based around making other businesses go thru hell.
 
when you're on the bleeding edge, there's not much you can do about that.

If you build a car that's "too good", the auto industry will bury you. This is no different.
 
Ya the fud is from a company that present tech to board that was supposed to be open tech without mentioning it was pattening tech that was prior art the problem is IBM did not step forward and mention that some of the tech rambus was transitioning from chipset and controller tech to memory because they had their hands full with three other legal battles at the time. The did have a few really ideas they had no cool how to turn into hardware and if you look a the meeting notes they did speak on their tech several times fully knowing the purpose of the jedec. Any one saying they did not get the present is full of it, I still have some of notes from one of them which if I can figure out who to send it to at nvidia I will. rdram when it was used in the 90's was edo soft prom tech nothing at all like the rdram that was used on intel p4s they only connection between the two is the programmable interface. What someone needs to do is sew them for defrauding the jedec and the consumer forced to pay for all the licensing costs.
 
im going to goto wikipedia and look up what rambus actually is since ive read about it before but was totally not interested at the time. maybe someone would be kind enough to clarify what rambus is before i goto wikipedia to get myself totally confused.
 
Read what you want. If you feel better posting FUD about something you don't care to research, be my guest.

And on http://microsoft.com, they clearly say they were never a monopoly nor ever engaged in embrace, extend and extinguish tactics! I BELIEVE THEM.

You are clearly a troll. Thankfully there are ignore lists on here.
 
Ya the fud is from a company that present tech to board that was supposed to be open tech without mentioning it

The company was invited to JEDEC by the very companies they shared their technology with under NDA. Hmmm. Gee. Why would they do that?

Rambus was not ALLOWED to divulge their patent status as part of an open standards forum because of patent law - and if they discussed the technology they use, it would make it public domain. Rambus was there under the guise that they would be presenting their technology for consideration of standardization.

So here are the steps the memory manufacturers took, in order:

Rambus invents a technology in the late 80's.

They share this technology under NDA in the early 90's with several memory manufacturers - including Siemens/Infineon, Hyunday/Hynix and Micron.

These memory manufacturers circulate memos saying "Holy crap, everything is eventually going to have to be made this way! But we don't want to pay royalties! Let's see if we can steal it by making them open their mouths at a JEDEC conference - that will make it public domain!"

Rambus joins JEDEC under the guise that they will be presenting their technology for consideration of standardization with RAND royalty rates.

Whenever they ask to present, JEDEC prevents them from doing so, while all the other companies cherry pick their patents while rambus says nothing - because BY LAW they can't say that the technology is patent pending in an open standards committee - even though everyone KNEW about their technology under NDA...

Yeah. JEDEC was TOTALLY being a good, honest open standards committee. And if you actually believe that, would you mind if I sold you a bridge?

was pattening tech that was prior art the problem is IBM did not step forward and mention that some of the tech rambus was transitioning from chipset and controller tech to memory because they had their hands full with three other legal battles at the time.

There was no prior art. The courts have decided that.

The did have a few really ideas they had no cool how to turn into hardware and if you look a the meeting notes they did speak on their tech several times fully knowing the purpose of the jedec. Any one saying they did not get the present is full of it, I still have some of notes from one of them which if I can figure out who to send it to at nvidia I will. rdram when it was used in the 90's was edo soft prom tech nothing at all like the rdram that was used on intel p4s they only connection between the two is the programmable interface. What someone needs to do is sew them for defrauding the jedec and the consumer forced to pay for all the licensing costs.

Such is life. The licensing costs would have been far less if JEDEC didn't try to steal it. But they did.

Don't blame the property owner. Blame the thief.
 
With any luck, Rambus will make JEDEC obsolete. I've never been a fan of "Technology by Committee" anyway, unless it came out of DARPA :)

Indeed, because if we can get rid of standards committees, then we'll be able to enjoy many different and incompatible electronic standards. Just imagine...it'll be like the good old days of ISA vs PCI vs MCA vs EISA. Just the thing. Or, I guess, Rambus will, like a virtuous Samaritan, come to our rescue with a low priced, technologically superior memory product...along with every other product that JEDEC standardizes.

(Disclosure: I participate in a couple of JEDEC standards committees. They are, in fact, painfully slow and notoriously picky and occasionally stubborn, but, like most everybody else, I kind of like the idea of a single standard that everybody targets. I did not, however have diddly squat to do with anything involving Rambus.)
 
Indeed, because if we can get rid of standards committees, then we'll be able to enjoy many different and incompatible electronic standards. Just imagine...it'll be like the good old days of ISA vs PCI vs MCA vs EISA. Just the thing. Or, I guess, Rambus will, like a virtuous Samaritan, come to our rescue with a low priced, technologically superior memory product...along with every other product that JEDEC standardizes.

(Disclosure: I participate in a couple of JEDEC standards committees. They are, in fact, painfully slow and notoriously picky and occasionally stubborn, but, like most everybody else, I kind of like the idea of a single standard that everybody targets. I did not, however have diddly squat to do with anything involving Rambus.)

Well, let me clarify - I'm all for open standards - when everyone can agree and when it isn't used to subvert like it was used in the case of Rambus.

The problem with JEDEC is that there were individuals and companies involved which used it as a front to steal a company's Intellectual Property.

Willi Meyer flat out admitted that they were going to try to "kill Rambus" by either buying it or dumping it, or by inviting them to JEDEC to make it public domain. Hynix's Tabrizi(sp) said he was "going back to Rambus killing" by inflating manufacturing costs and making Intel's life miserable by constraining supply. Micron took $500M from Intel to develop Rambus fabs and in the end never did so claiming it was "too expensive".

Even Samsung was guilty, and they were on the record as saying RDRAM didn't cost any more to produce than SDRAM.

In the end, everyone comes up a loser in this one. Rambus has to settle for pennies or no one will want to work with them. JEDEC loses because the players now have to pay for more in royalties. The consumer loses because we're forced to use slower memory.

If the participants of JEDEC had held true to its word, Rambus would have been able to present its technology for consideration (instead of being the only company in JEDEC's history to be barred from doing so), RDRAM would likely have been used instead of PC66 SDRAM and today we'd all have XDR memory interfaces going to those shiny new i7 procs and not this more-of-the-same DDR3 junk.
 
I'm really just sick of all the FUD posted when people don't even understand fully what's happening. But I'm a troll because I'm not posting 'LOL RAMBUS DIE DIE' Grow up.
 
It doesn't matter. Rambus won't die at this point. They just have to stay ahead of the curve and keep Toshiba & IBM happy :)
 
Well, let me clarify - I'm all for open standards - when everyone can agree and when it isn't used to subvert like it was used in the case of Rambus.

The problem with JEDEC is that there were individuals and companies involved which used it as a front to steal a company's Intellectual Property.

Willi Meyer flat out admitted that they were going to try to "kill Rambus" by either buying it or dumping it, or by inviting them to JEDEC to make it public domain. Hynix's Tabrizi(sp) said he was "going back to Rambus killing" by inflating manufacturing costs and making Intel's life miserable by constraining supply. Micron took $500M from Intel to develop Rambus fabs and in the end never did so claiming it was "too expensive".

Even Samsung was guilty, and they were on the record as saying RDRAM didn't cost any more to produce than SDRAM.

In the end, everyone comes up a loser in this one. Rambus has to settle for pennies or no one will want to work with them. JEDEC loses because the players now have to pay for more in royalties. The consumer loses because we're forced to use slower memory.

If the participants of JEDEC had held true to its word, Rambus would have been able to present its technology for consideration (instead of being the only company in JEDEC's history to be barred from doing so), RDRAM would likely have been used instead of PC66 SDRAM and today we'd all have XDR memory interfaces going to those shiny new i7 procs and not this more-of-the-same DDR3 junk
.

While I understand your reasoning to some degree on this. I find fault with you battling others on their perception of the case on hand. The fact is while its been flip flopping a bit Ranbus has even been brought to court by the FTC for anti-trust violations and has had their royalties capped by the government and are only valid for a period of 3 years. They have lost more cases then they have won, and their only real wins have been stalemates and the appeals on the FTC investigation. The companies that they have sued have payed more for the price fixing they used to get Rambus kicked out of the desktop memory market then they have or will pay Rambus in royalties.

2nd Rambus didn't wait till they got the patents before suing, they waited till their memory became the defacto desktop memory with their agreement with Intel. They waited till Althlon XP with DDR became the faster alternative, they then sued everyone including companies already manufacturing rambus, for manufacturing DDR. They basically where pissed that they may not hold the defacto desktop memory statis for more then 6 months.

Without context on the emails. I find it's hard to judge what they were refering to. and I find it hard to believe that Rambus can patent something (the stuff in SDR), then have the memory people steal it, and get it included their new standards, in three years. Seems to quick.
 
While I understand your reasoning to some degree on this. I find fault with you battling others on their perception of the case on hand. The fact is while its been flip flopping a bit Ranbus has even been brought to court by the FTC for anti-trust violations and has had their royalties capped by the government and are only valid for a period of 3 years. They have lost more cases then they have won, and their only real wins have been stalemates and the appeals on the FTC investigation. The companies that they have sued have payed more for the price fixing they used to get Rambus kicked out of the desktop memory market then they have or will pay Rambus in royalties.

With regards to the FTC lawsuits - did you not notice the pattern? The FTC suits happen, and shortly afterwards the Administrative Law Judges involved with screwing Rambus even further suddenly become partners at the law firms that represent none other than Micron....

Hmmmmmmmmmmmmmm..... No, nothing dirty there! It's all just coincidence :)

2nd Rambus didn't wait till they got the patents before suing, they waited till their memory became the defacto desktop memory with their agreement with Intel. They waited till Althlon XP with DDR became the faster alternative, they then sued everyone including companies already manufacturing rambus, for manufacturing DDR. They basically where pissed that they may not hold the defacto desktop memory statis for more then 6 months.

And they left JEDEC long before that - and on their exit they said they were leaving on advice of legal counsel. They also stated on exit that they were going to pursue royalties on their technology. They didn't leave anything to the imagination. They basically said "Screw you guys. If you use our IP, we'll sue you." JEDEC didn't care since they had a plan to screw them in other ways - obviously one of them including the FTC.

JEDEC could have engineered around Rambus. The SyncLink consortium was one attempt at that. But in the end, the Memory Manufacturers chose theft.

Again, in this situation, everyone loses and it's a shame. The problem is that everyone is saying the memory manufacturers were right and that Rambus was the big ugly gorilla - when the lawsuits clearly shows that they weren't.

But hey, that's business.
 
With regards to the FTC lawsuits - did you not notice the pattern? The FTC suits happen, and shortly afterwards the Administrative Law Judges involved with screwing Rambus even further suddenly become partners at the law firms that represent none other than Micron....

Hmmmmmmmmmmmmmm..... No, nothing dirty there! It's all just coincidence :)

So, how long have you been at Rambus?

Your descriptions of the requirements of Title 35 as it relates to pending applications is inaccurate at best (pre- and post the Nov. 2001 modifications as they relate to publication of pending applications). I'd also watch yourself in flinging about allegations such as the above. As you yourself have noted, all sides in these matters have been highly litigious. Alleging impropriety by then-sitting administrative judges and law firms representing parties before those judges is highly defamatory. I don't think you'd appreciate a crash course in litigation courtesy of the above-referenced parties.

In short, you've made your point, but now you're starting to enter some dangerous territory. It might be prudent to stop.
 
I don't work for Rambus. Never have. I'm not even a shareholder.

Also, nothing I've said is new. For anyone to litigate against me is pointless, as It's all been said on other websites that keep an eye on the Rambus debacle.

http://rambus.org/story/#LegalTimeline

There's a legal timeline of the events, including what happened to key people involved in the case against them.

Anyone who's interested in IP law and/or technology would find this entire story fascinating. But there's certainly nothing *I* could say or do that would cause any degree of defamation to anyone involved. I'm a nobody and have no monetary interest in any of the involved companies or individuals.

But I *AM* entitled to my opinions.
 
Blah blah, most of the technology patented by Rambus in these matters were "obvious under the art" at the time.

Anyone using pagemode Drams in system designs in the 80's were contronted by the limitations and many designs and scheme's were developed across the industry to get more performance from the available technology.

I build a Mac accelerator that effectively had effectively implemented DDR2 the hard way eon's before sdram was a public notion. Using individual 60ns Drams as discrete elements in a multi-component memory system who's block diagram would be eerily similar to DDR2's.

We weren't the only ones, countless industrial computer designs had miriad custom innovations no doubt covering every manner you could make use of the Dram technology. Remember, inside every SDRAM/DDR/DDR2/DDR3 is simply the same old Dram concept, with more sophisticated control circuitry surrounding it, to get more speed out of the basic technology.

The shit Rambus "patented" should never have been granted, and NVidia et al should have fought those patents in the firstplace.

Until the industry stands up for itself and puts a foot down over what is true innovation and what is simply the OBVIOUS commited to a patent filing, this type of situtation will always crop up.

Myself, I could go ahead and make all the DDR2 I want and Rambus can kiss my ass, I have the proof of my own prior art to defend myself in court, though it wont help others since the project was cancelled when Apple refused to "approve" us and allow us to sell the board.... they had made an illegal exclusive deal with Daystar at the time. Too bad, we had one SMOKIN 68040 Quadra. :eek::rolleyes::p
 
The shit Rambus "patented" should never have been granted, and NVidia et al should have fought those patents in the firstplace.

Until the industry stands up for itself and puts a foot down over what is true innovation and what is simply the OBVIOUS commited to a patent filing, this type of situtation will always crop up.

Well, now they'll have their chance! :)
 
Also, nothing I've said is new. For anyone to litigate against me is pointless, as It's all been said on other websites that keep an eye on the Rambus debacle.

But there's certainly nothing *I* could say or do that would cause any degree of defamation to anyone involved. I'm a nobody and have no monetary interest in any of the involved companies or individuals.

But I *AM* entitled to my opinions.

1. Republication of defamatory statements is actionable as defamation. "I didn't say it first" isn't going to get you off the hook.

2. There's no requirement that you have a monetary interest in anything for a defamation case.

3. You're entitled to your opinion, yes. Your statements about administrative judges making "dirty" deals on the bench in order to work for law firms that represent parties adverse to Rambus is hardly an opinion. As to entitlement, others are entitled to sue your ass into the ground for a factual statement made which is false and causes them pecuniary loss (which is assumed in most cases). You may think you're a nobody with nothing, but I've seen internet postings become the basis for a defamation suit that resulted in ruinous liability for the poster.

4. I'm not even sure someone else said it first. Reading the link you posted, I see that 2 attorneys from the FTC left the FTC and joined private law firms. In one case, the lead attorney from the FTC case simply re-joined the firm he'd left prior to joining the FTC. I also see that the clerk of a District Court judge, at the conclusion of his clerkship, joined a law firm as a partner.

Where's the administrative judges who joined firms that represented Micron? Did you create that all on your own?
 
Where's the administrative judges who joined firms that represented Micron? Did you create that all on your own?

Actually yes - it was... I confused an ALJ with Payne's clerk. My mistake...

I never made *any* statements about administrative judges making dirty deals - did you create THAT all on your own? :)
 
Back
Top