possibly building this week... am I missing anything?

TeleFragger

[H]ard|Gawd
Joined
Nov 10, 2005
Messages
1,297
Ok another budget builder here...
I did some OT at work and hopefully can build a machine...

My only concern is my power supply...
I already have a antec 480p (modular design)
I believe it will do 1 video card but not sli which is not a problem at this moment.

so this is what im looking at...

$300 ASUS Striker Extreme LGA 775 NVIDIA nForce 680i SLI ATX The Ultimate Gaming Motherboard - Retail

$96 (ar) GeIL Ultra 2GB (2 x 1GB) 240-Pin DDR2 SDRAM DDR2 1066 (PC2 8500) Dual Channel Kit Desktop Memory

$339 XFX PVT80GTHF9 GeForce 8800GTS 640MB 320-bit GDDR3 PCI Express x16 Video Card

$225 Intel Core 2 Duo E6600 Conroe 2.4GHz 4M shared L2 Cache LGA 775 Processor

$30 LITE-ON Black 20X DVD+R 8X DVD

other than that I have a case, powersupply, drives and all

think it will fly for now?
in the future... add second video card and new power supply to support sli and should be good to go???
 
It's a good motherboard, just expensive for what you get.

well then here is my q on that.... other than expense.... is it worth it overall with features?

What my goal is, is a computer that in a year or 2 all I need to do is
A. Add memory
B. Add second video card to SLI
C. overclock cpu


I want a long return on this machine..... i have a xbox 360 for most of my games but want a good computer for video editing, scanning (not like it requires alot), games and whatever I want to throw at it....
 
guy at work has it and loves it so far... what is the waste of $$$??
trust me that would be nice to cut that corner... :D

You said a budget build? There is no way you can have a $300 mobo in a budget build, lol. But I would agree, drop the mobo to a cheaper 680i board or a P35 board.
 
If I were budget building,

e4300
Gigabyte DS3
8800gts
Scythe Cooler (forgot the model no)
Corsair 520w
2gb of cheap brand name RAM

= Cheap + 3ghz CPU.
 
If you're set on a 680i board, get the EVGA A1, not the Striker Extreme. The A1, while still pricey, is usually cheaper than the Striker, and comes with better support and warranty service. It's also the most popular 680i board, so you'll have a better support and OC community out there. Lastly, EVGA has confirmed that their 680i boards will fully support upcoming 45NM Penryn chips with a BIOS update.

However, if a) you're not gaming on a resolution at 1920x1200 or above, and b) you aren't prepared to get a GTX card now, then get a cheaper P35 board and forget about SLI. In fact with the money saved by dropping a Striker Extreme in favor of a P5K or DS3R, you can probably upgrade to a GTX, which will be much more worthwhile.

As for SLI, Adding a second GTS card isn't worth it. In two years time, or whenever you're ready to add the second card, there will likely be a single card solution for a very reasonable price that will kick the ass of two GTS cards working in tandem. SLI is only a worthwhile investment if a) you're gaming on a big monitor at native res, and b) you're prepared to drop major cash on getting two of the fastest cards available (excluding the Ultra.) Otherwise, the extra complexity (and heat output) of two cards isn't worth it.

Good luck with the build,

Mark.
 
If I were budget building,

e4300
Gigabyte DS3
8800gts
Scythe Cooler (forgot the model no)
Corsair 520w
2gb of cheap brand name RAM

= Cheap + 3ghz CPU.

Similar to the $1k rig I am planning out for after the July 22nd price cuts

E6420
7900GS (But I'll re-evaluate at the time)
2gb G.Skill
P35 Board
Corsair 520W
Antec P180
Seagate 320GB
 
If you're set on a 680i board, get the EVGA A1, not the Striker Extreme. The A1, while still pricey, is usually cheaper than the Striker, and comes with better support and warranty service. It's also the most popular 680i board, so you'll have a better support and OC community out there. Lastly, EVGA has confirmed that their 680i boards will fully support upcoming 45NM Penryn chips with a BIOS update.

However, if a) you're not gaming on a resolution at 1920x1200 or above, and b) you aren't prepared to get a GTX card now, then get a cheaper P35 board and forget about SLI. In fact with the money saved by dropping a Striker Extreme in favor of a P5K or DS3R, you can probably upgrade to a GTX, which will be much more worthwhile.

As for SLI, Adding a second GTS card isn't worth it. In two years time, or whenever you're ready to add the second card, there will likely be a single card solution for a very reasonable price that will kick the ass of two GTS cards working in tandem. SLI is only a worthwhile investment if a) you're gaming on a big monitor at native res, and b) you're prepared to drop major cash on getting two of the fastest cards available (excluding the Ultra.) Otherwise, the extra complexity (and heat output) of two cards isn't worth it.

Good luck with the build,

Mark.


good points taken....

appreciate it...

ok so which p5k board are we talking?
If I get the ASUS P5K-V LGA 775 Intel G33 ATX Intel Motherboard - Retail it is only $144
but the ASUS P5K DELUXE/WIFI-AP LGA 775 Intel P35 ATX Intel Motherboard - Retail is $225....
with that if I went with the first I would save $164 but if I went with the second then I save less..... is the deluxe that much better? or is it the fact that it has more options that I will not use like wifi, remote for mp3's, etc......

$560 - BFG Tech BFGR88768GTXOCE GeForce 8800GTX 768MB GDDR3 PCI Express x16 OC HDCP Video Card - Retail


all in all....yeah I guess in 2 years one would want to upgrade the entire machine... however last year was my first year even owning a p4 in general..... game consoles have kept me in the non need for upgrades.... however the need for a office computer is where I am at now...


I also bought the asus p5k deluxe with wifi for my bro in law and he loves it...
add the geforce 8800gtx and guess I would be set.... :D

so new plans are

$225 ASUS P5K DELUXE/WIFI-AP LGA 775 Intel P35 ATX Intel Motherboard
$96 (ar) GeIL Ultra 2GB (2 x 1GB) 240-Pin DDR2 SDRAM DDR2 1066 (PC2 8500) Dual Channel Kit Desktop Memory
$560 BFG Tech BFGR88768GTXOCE GeForce 8800GTX 768MB GDDR3 PCI Express x16
$225 Intel Core 2 Duo E6600 Conroe 2.4GHz 4M shared L2 Cache LGA 775 Processor
$30 LITE-ON Black 20X DVD+R 8X DVD

or the other MB to save $80 ish dollars... not sure..
 
The P5K is a nice board. I think that is a solid choice.

If you are going to get that video card and everything else and want to OC, I would suggest getting a nice 600ishW PSU. You are going to need it.
 
well then here is my q on that.... other than expense.... is it worth it overall with features?

What my goal is, is a computer that in a year or 2 all I need to do is
A. Add memory
B. Add second video card to SLI
C. overclock cpu


I want a long return on this machine..... i have a xbox 360 for most of my games but want a good computer for video editing, scanning (not like it requires alot), games and whatever I want to throw at it....

Just because a board is $300 doesnt mean it'll last longer than a board thats $150. As Mark mentioned, you only need SLI for high resolution gaming/3d rendering (w/ 24" or larger LCD). If you don't have one, or don't plan on getting one, then don't bother with SLI. If you do have one, go with the A1 eVGA instead. No, the Striker is not worth the money. There are plenty of boards out there that can OC. In fact, the 680i can't reach that high of an FSB. Though, with an E6600, you don't need to reach that high of an FSB unless you plan to lower the multiplier.

You don't need DDR2-1066 RAM with an E6600. No board can reach 533mhz, therefore there really is no need for DDR2-1066 ram. The typical max OC on good air cooling with a good E6600 is around 3.6Ghz. As you can see below, you only need a good set of DDR2-800. FYI, the latest batch of E6600's arent OC'ing as well as they used to. I'd go for an E6420 instead.
E6600: 9 * 266 = 2.4Ghz, DDR2-533 << Stock
E6600: 9 * 333 = 3.0Ghz, DDR2-667 << Easy OC
E6600: 9 * 400 = 3.6Ghz, DDR2-800 << Good OC

E6420: 8 * 266 = 2.1Ghz, DDR2-533 << Stock
E6420: 8 * 400 = 3.2Ghz, DDR2-800 << Easy OC
E6420: 8 * 450 = 3.6Ghz, DDR2-900 << Good OC (DDR2-1000 or DDR2-1066)
 
You don't need DDR2-1066 RAM with an E6600. No board can reach 533mhz, therefore there really is no need for DDR2-1066 ram.

I'd go for an E6420 instead.

E6600: 9 * 266 = 2.4Ghz, DDR2-533 << Stock
E6600: 9 * 333 = 3.0Ghz, DDR2-667 << Easy OC
E6600: 9 * 400 = 3.6Ghz, DDR2-800 << Good OC

E6420: 8 * 266 = 2.1Ghz, DDR2-533 << Stock
E6420: 8 * 400 = 3.2Ghz, DDR2-800 << Easy OC
E6420: 8 * 450 = 3.6Ghz, DDR2-900 << Good OC (DDR2-1000 or DDR2-1066)


I used to know hardware now there is sooo much out there that I am easily confused..

Ok so I wont get the striker...
save $40 and go with the e6420 cpu.... cool....
now you say tat I dont need 1066 memory... but when I look at the price breaker... pc2 6400 memory.. 2x1gb is about $76 and 2x1gb pc 8500 is $97 after mail in rebate... so to me the best thing is go with the memory on sale... the only problem with newegg is their sales come and go super quick and im not looking to buy until maybe saturday so the memory may change again... but I figure $100 for 2x1gb pc8500 is the best deal....



so now back to motherboards....

so the $144 motherboard will do me fine? all I need this machine for is some gaming.. .and lemme explain gaming..
I just want a dx10 video card as why stick with old when you can go new......

I am only going to play older games on pc... we get together.. tonight as a matter of fact...
games tonight are

Rainbow Six Vegas
Rainbow Six Raven shield
Ghost Recon Advanced Warrior
Unreal Tournament 2004

so I dont need a super huge power house but if gonna buy new.. might as well get something that will last for a bit....

also needs to do home video editing.. so need something half descent...

so it is still difficult on the choice...
what would you do?
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Produ...mpareItemList=N82E16813131184,N82E16813131182
 
You don't need the Deluxe. It's not 'better', just has more stuff that, by your own admission, you won't use. Don't waste the cash. The the standard P5K and a nice heatsink like a Tuniq Tower.

Yes, a single 8800 GTX will do you much better, and if you want it to last, that is pretty much the only way to fly.

You also still need a PSU. The Corsair 620watt is a good choice for that sort of setup. Do not go cheap on your PSU -- clean, stable power is extremely important if you want your system to last. Your Antec will likely run the system for a while, but its lifespan will be severely shortened by that sort of load, and when it goes it could easily take the system with it. Not a worthwhile risk.

Get some G.Skill DDR2-800 and avoid all the mail in rebate bullshit. Timings (lower = better, as in 4-4-4-12 is better than 5-5-5-18, CAS 4 is better than CAS 5) are actually more important than pure rated clock speed. DDR2-800 will do you just fine.

You're also probably going to need at least a new optical drive. Most new motherboards only have one PATA channel, so you get 2 drives on that. Are your existing drives SATA, or at least some of them? If not, you'll likely have to purchase some. 20X SATA DVDRWs run about $35 right now.
 
You don't need the Deluxe. It's not 'better', just has more stuff that, by your own admission, you won't use. Don't waste the cash. The the standard P5K and a nice heatsink like a Tuniq Tower.

Yes, a single 8800 GTX will do you much better, and if you want it to last, that is pretty much the only way to fly.

You also still need a PSU. The Corsair 620watt is a good choice for that sort of setup. Do not go cheap on your PSU -- clean, stable power is extremely important if you want your system to last. Your Antec will likely run the system for a while, but its lifespan will be severely shortened by that sort of load, and when it goes it could easily take the system with it. Not a worthwhile risk.

Get some G.Skill DDR2-800 and avoid all the mail in rebate bullshit. Timings (lower = better, as in 4-4-4-12 is better than 5-5-5-18, CAS 4 is better than CAS 5) are actually more important than pure rated clock speed. DDR2-800 will do you just fine.

You're also probably going to need at least a new optical drive. Most new motherboards only have one PATA channel, so you get 2 drives on that. Are your existing drives SATA, or at least some of them? If not, you'll likely have to purchase some. 20X SATA DVDRWs run about $35 right now.


thanks for the reply...

yeah i think im sold on the cheaper motherboard...
e6420 cpu
8800gxt (although hard to pony $500 for a vid card when I could buy the xbox360 ultra)
I have ide drives so yeah a hard drive and optical drive will be purchased too


Thanks for the definition on the memory.. I never knew what the hell I was looking at with the 5-5-5-18 or whatever... so the lower the better.... cool....


I still dont understand one thing... if I go DDR2-800 my machine will run slower than running DDR-1066 right? why would I want to do that when there is no real price difference (if I go mail in rebate way)?
 
You don't need the Deluxe. It's not 'better', just has more stuff that, by your own admission, you won't use. Don't waste the cash. The the standard P5K and a nice heatsink like a Tuniq Tower.

Yes, a single 8800 GTX will do you much better, and if you want it to last, that is pretty much the only way to fly.

You also still need a PSU. The Corsair 620watt is a good choice for that sort of setup. Do not go cheap on your PSU -- clean, stable power is extremely important if you want your system to last. Your Antec will likely run the system for a while, but its lifespan will be severely shortened by that sort of load, and when it goes it could easily take the system with it. Not a worthwhile risk.

Get some G.Skill DDR2-800 and avoid all the mail in rebate bullshit. Timings (lower = better, as in 4-4-4-12 is better than 5-5-5-18, CAS 4 is better than CAS 5) are actually more important than pure rated clock speed. DDR2-800 will do you just fine.

You're also probably going to need at least a new optical drive. Most new motherboards only have one PATA channel, so you get 2 drives on that. Are your existing drives SATA, or at least some of them? If not, you'll likely have to purchase some. 20X SATA DVDRWs run about $35 right now.

I agree, the G.Skill DDR2-800 and Corsair 620W PSU will be nice additions to the rig.
 
I agree, the G.Skill DDR2-800 and Corsair 620W PSU will be nice additions to the rig.

yeah ya guys got me thinking now....
I am assuming everyone is saying the ddr2-800 as in if not overclocking much... as in the oc chart above.. if you go extreme oc then you need higher memory...

hmmmm so other than sucking it up and ponying 5large for a vid card... think I know what I want now..
thanks guys...

e6420 cpu
geforce 8800gtx
ddr2-800 memory (unless a good ddr2-1066 is same price)
500gb sata drive
sata optical
new ps

now gotta get the cash up.... and also need time...
putting hardwood floor in... 420sq ft... living room, dining room, hallway....
 
Thanks for the definition on the memory.. I never knew what the hell I was looking at with the 5-5-5-18 or whatever... so the lower the better.... cool....

I still dont understand one thing... if I go DDR2-800 my machine will run slower than running DDR-1066 right? why would I want to do that when there is no real price difference (if I go mail in rebate way)?

You won't notice any real world performance difference between CAS4 and CAS5. Therefore, the lower timings aren't worth a huge price premium. Though, you decide if that price premium is worth it to you or not (how much cash you have to burn).

Your system will run at whatever settings you set them to. If you buy DDR2-1066 and don't change any settings, it will only run at DDR2-533. Running the ram at a higher ratio other than 1:1 will result in no performance gain on Intel platforms.

FYI: effective fsb = 4 x base fsb // cpu clock speed = cpu multiplier x base fsb // ram speed = 2 x base fsb
So... E6420: 8 * 266 = 2.1Ghz, DDR2-533, 1066Mhz effective FSB << STOCK

now gotta get the cash up.... and also need time...
putting hardwood floor in... 420sq ft... living room, dining room, hallway....

hardwood? psh... thats not [H]ard enough!!! go marble!!! haha, j/k... I prefer carpet, lol.
 
Your system will run at whatever settings you set them to. If you buy DDR2-1066 and don't change any settings, it will only run at DDR2-533. Running the ram at a higher ratio other than 1:1 will result in no performance gain on Intel platforms.

FYI: effective fsb = 4 x base fsb // cpu clock speed = cpu multiplier x base fsb // ram speed = 2 x base fsb
So... E6420: 8 * 266 = 2.1Ghz, DDR2-533, 1066Mhz effective FSB << STOCK

I think this is important and will help out a lot of users confused about DDR2-1066
 
well since the price drop is in 20 days.. guess im gonna wait till then...

will end up getting the q6600 if I can for that 260ish price.....
by then hopefully memory will drop a bit too so I can get 4 x 1 gb ddr2 800
geforce 8800gtx would be nice but not sure if I need that much power.. I have a 360 for gaming... so the gts may suffice my needs for video editing and the norm.....


thanks for all the input guys....
really appreciate it...

the other things on my list for me to look at is I need a new mouse and keyboard..

I was going to get the Logitech G7 mouse but hearing it has a oilly feel to it???
and the Logitech G15 keyboard... I love the look of it... :D
 
Back
Top