Pending upgrade - advice welcome

Joined
Jun 28, 2007
Messages
3
Hiya, its about high time for my trusty computer to go to surgery for a makeover, however its been awhile and I'm out of the loop. I've been using this site and its forums for years (ever since stumbling over the ratpad) and couldn't think of a better place to get input and opinions.
With that out of the way, some tidbits before I get to the fun part:

-My budget is roughly 1200 bucks.
-I'm primarily a gamer and meddle with graphics on and off.
-Typically my machine is on 24/7 so quality, power preservation and noise level are important.
-I don't know how wise overclocking would be, keeping the above point in mind but am not opposed to it if I won't fry the system over time. Input welcome.
-I can't afford full makeovers every few months so prefer choices that can last awhile.
-I rather spend 20bucks more and have quality than wait for a carcrash to happen, so to speak.
Ok, with all said and done:

CPU
I've long favored amd, but nowadays intel's just looking better. Keeping the pricecuts in mind (I'll hold off the purchase until then), I've looked at the E6750, perhaps the 6850 variant. Going along with this, I honestly don't know which heatsink to pick for the chip.

Motherboard
I favor Asus boards but quite honestly have no real clue which to go for. I do not intent to use sli, however I'd like to keep it an option for the future. Plus, changing mb's is a royal pain. I intent to recycle my hard drive even though its cranky ide style will probably be the new systems weakness and eventually make room for a sata, but I believe most boards these days support both anyway?

Vidcard
Again I favor Asus models and have looked at the 8600gts top, but is the innate overclocked speed of the card really worth it? The 8800 models are pretty expensive, yet the 320m model is not too far off in price.

Memory
Corsair is my ram of choice, 2gigs are plenty. The 8500C5D (dominator) series looks nice and shiny but do I really need that, or would the 6400C4D (dominator) suffice? I figure the higher mhz rating only really comes to play with overclocking?

Power
As stated, I run my comp nonstop and this thing makes or breaks it. I've been using enermax with mixed results in the past (good ratings, quiet..but one blew up on me after a year). Currently I'm partial to the new corsair psu's as many seem to favor 'em and I wager its for good reason. Plus from what I read, the efficiency, quality and noise all seem great.
However, how much power do I really need? With all the above, I run a hd, cd/dvd drive and anywhere from 2 to 5 case fans in my cm stacker. I used to run all, but scaled down after my first psu blow up (hastility bought replacement didn't have enough connectors).
I don't have or need a lightshow inside my case, it just has to run, keep cool and quiet;)
I'm more the type that leans towards efficiency over flashiness. Drawing too much power would just drive up my electricity bill and thats high enough really..so, I don't know where the line between "overkill", "needed" and "needed plus comfort zone" is.

Phew, alot of writing, thanks for lasting through it. Everything I left out will be recycled as it is either fairly fresh, or still good enough. I probably busted my budget with some of my thoughts but..yea, any help advice or suggestion is welcome!
 
CPU
I've long favored amd, but nowadays intel's just looking better. Keeping the pricecuts in mind (I'll hold off the purchase until then), I've looked at the E6750, perhaps the 6850 variant. Going along with this, I honestly don't know which heatsink to pick for the chip.

I suggest a Q6600 (Quad core), near the end of this month; They will have a big price drop down to about $265. Pretty impressive. I suggest a thermalright Ultra120 + a Yate Loon D12SL12 fan. It's very quiet, the fan is cheap, and they'll keep the processor cool.

Motherboard
I favor Asus boards but quite honestly have no real clue which to go for. I do not intent to use sli, however I'd like to keep it an option for the future. Plus, changing mb's is a royal pain. I intent to recycle my hard drive even though its cranky ide style will probably be the new systems weakness and eventually make room for a sata, but I believe most boards these days support both anyway?

I suggest a P35 based board, like the P5K, P5K Deluxe, P35DS3, etc.. There's a nice roundup on the [H] main page, something to have a look at. I don't recommend SLI.
Pretty much all motherboards support both IDE and SATA, but the newest boards only have one IDE header. I recommend picking up a SATA hard drive, and an SATA DVD burner. It makes life so much easier.

Vidcard
Again I favor Asus models and have looked at the 8600gts top, but is the innate overclocked speed of the card really worth it? The 8800 models are pretty expensive, yet the 320m model is not too far off in price.
I don't suggest the 8800GTS top; If you can afford a bit extra, the 8800 320mb is the one to have. They're much faster.

Memory
Corsair is my ram of choice, 2gigs are plenty. The 8500C5D (dominator) series looks nice and shiny but do I really need that, or would the 6400C4D (dominator) suffice? I figure the higher mhz rating only really comes to play with overclocking?

If you don't intend on overclocking, the 8500C5D AND 6400C4D are not for you. You can get by just fine with some value DDR2 667 or 800.
Power
As stated, I run my comp nonstop and this thing makes or breaks it. I've been using enermax with mixed results in the past (good ratings, quiet..but one blew up on me after a year). Currently I'm partial to the new corsair psu's as many seem to favor 'em and I wager its for good reason. Plus from what I read, the efficiency, quality and noise all seem great.
However, how much power do I really need? With all the above, I run a hd, cd/dvd drive and anywhere from 2 to 5 case fans in my cm stacker. I used to run all, but scaled down after my first psu blow up (hastility bought replacement didn't have enough connectors).
I don't have or need a lightshow inside my case, it just has to run, keep cool and quiet;)
I'm more the type that leans towards efficiency over flashiness. Drawing too much power would just drive up my electricity bill and thats high enough really..so, I don't know where the line between "overkill", "needed" and "needed plus comfort zone" is.

You'll be fine with an HX 520. A Silverstone OP650 is also a nice choice, but it's not modular.
 
Go with the build above and just to echo don't buy the 8600gts it is quite frankly crap for gaming. :p
 
What size monitor and what games will you be playing? Your budget seems good enough for the 8800GTS.

If you don't need a quadcore, then don't bother with it for now. You could get a dual core that could be clocked much higher than a quadcore could reach on good air cooling. And, if you go with a P35 board, you should be able to upgrade to a quadcore a year from now with a yorkfield chip. Those chips will be faster than current quadcores, should have more headroom to OC since they're 45nm (run cooler, require less voltage), and should be damn cheap since intel plans on intro'ing them at current dual core prices.

If you want your parts to last long even overclocked, keep voltages near stock settings, especially the CPU voltage.
 
Phew, hectic last days, sorry for a lack of response and thank you for all the input!
To answer one question, I'm running a nice cozy 22" monitor and plan on enjoying quite a few of the newer games..does make me think to find extra money for the 8800.
I don't think I need a quadcore but honestly, I haven't even looked much at them and their possible advantages over duo (aside the obvious). I'll do some reading.
Again, many thanks.
 
Video --- 1650x1080 or similar, you're well in to 8800 GTS 320MB territory. In fact, in some cases with high AA/AF, you may even need the 640MB version to maintain reasonable framerates, but in most cases the 320 MB will suffice. Again, as several others have said, you will be disappointed by the 8600 cards, so avoid them all together. Do not get an ASUS-branded video card. Reasoning: horrible warranty when compared with other vendors, and the other vendors focus primarily on graphics cards. Get eVGA, XFX, or BFG. They're the nVidia "big three" and their support is far superior -- lifetime warranties, better RMA policy, etc. eVGA even warranties overclocking via software like RivaTuner and allows the use of aftermarket cooling so long as the stock HSF is reinstalled if the card is sent in for RMA service. If you get an eVGA branded card remember to register it on their website within 30 days, though, or you warranty drops down to a year, rather than lifetime. XFX may actually have a better warranty policy, but I'm not as familiar with theirs. BFG trails a bit -- I don't think they allow aftermarket cooling -- but even they would be an improvement over ASUS policy.

PSU --- The build you're looking at is a 500-600 watt PSU build; the Corsair 520HX will do fine as it is a very high quality unit. It's also a single rail unit, though it's not advertised as such. This is actually a good thing. 600 watts is including a generous comfort zone, and trying to get load in the 40-60% lowest stress highest efficiency bracket of most PSUs, with the intent being a cooler running, longer lasting PSU and lower electricity bill. Even with my system, which is a bit higher draw, I only see max load of around 360-380 watts at the wall, which assuming 80% efficiency is only 310 watts internally.

Case --- If you want it quiet but don't want to spend a fortune grab an Antec P180/P180B/P182 ($80 after rebate, may be found for less) and 4 120mm Yate Loon fans ($4-5 a piece, $20-25 shipped). I've been very happy with this particular combination.

Heatsink --- a Scythe Ninja Plus Rev B, Sunbeam Tuniq Tower, or Thermalright Ultra 120 Extreme (which will need its own fan, does not come with one) are good options, going from 'enough' to 'arguably the best there is right now' -- and up in price accordingly.

RAM --- No reason to be brand loyal here, really. I've had a lot of different kinds of RAM. It is almost never what fails in a system. If it's not DOA, it's good for a long, long time. This is my experience, anyway. Get the least expensive DDR2-800 with the lowest latency you can find. Right now tht would appear to be a 2GB kit of DDR2-800 Cas 4 for around $80. If you think you'll make use of it, grab 2 kits and a copy of 64bit Vista. 32bit OS's can't address but around 3GB of memory, so otherwise it's a waste.

CPU --- You seem to have the right idea here. Quad is an option, yes, and Epic has made it clear that at least UT3 engine games will benefit from quad cores by splitting physics and other duties between them, but as of right now that and the fact that Supreme Commander will use them is about all we really know with regard to gaming, and as that's the machine's main purpose, that should be your focus.
 
Some fiddling later, I've come up with this:

2gigs of ddr2 800 ram at timings of 4-4-4-12
Thermalright ultra-120 extreme heatsink (plus fan)
Corsair 520hx psu
Evga 320-P2-N817 8800gts/320mb, 588mhz core, 1840mhz memory vidcard
Asus P5K LGA 775 motherboard
Cpu pending, will re-evaluate after pricedrop, good points for quad-now and holding off have been made.

Scanning pricings and reserving cpu cash, the above looks to be leaving room to include a sata hd (probably seagate or wd) and dish out for a new cd/dvd drive or maybe go for the 620 psu after all or contemplate a 640mb vidcard model though I think a sata hd would be better for overall performance balance as opposed to the extra juicy card.
Cheers.
 
OCing should be perfectly fine over a long period so long as you don't push it too hard -- keep full load temps below 55C or so, idle around 30C, and vcore as low as you can while maintaining stability.

Vcore is really the most important part. Intel chips just seem to deal with heat better than their AMD counterparts, it doesn't seem to bother them as much (I've had all AMD stuff before my C2D, though I built a few P4 based machines that made me that much happier I'd gone with an Athlon 64...) Vcore, however, will kill them if you push it too far. Of course, 'too far' seems to be the 1.55-1.60 range, so the 1.4 or so you may have to hit to get a nice stable OC is really nothing to worry about, being a roughly 0.05 v increase over stock.

Quads, as enginurd said, do not OC as well. They get hotter faster, and are thusly much more difficult to keep reasonably cool with air cooling above stock speeds. People regularly OC dual cores 1+Ghz over stock... where as 600Mhz is a good quad core OC on air.
 
Back
Top