PCI-X vs PCI

Joined
Oct 1, 2006
Messages
528
I was looking at some SCSI drives and the controller cards, and noticed that most of the controller cards had PCI-X interfaces. A couple questions:
1) Can a PCI-X card be used in a PCI slot?
2) Any noticeable advantage of PCI-X over PCI?

Thank you very much
 
I was looking at some SCSI drives and the controller cards, and noticed that most of the controller cards had PCI-X interfaces. A couple questions:
1) Can a PCI-X card be used in a PCI slot?
2) Any noticeable advantage of PCI-X over PCI?

Thank you very much

Aggiestudd07,

No, PCI-E (I assuming you are talking about PCI-Express, there is such a thing as PCI-X but PCI-E and PCI-X are two different things) cannot be used in regular PCI slots.

The difference between PCI-E and PCI is major to say the least, PCI was before even AGP, so its safe to say PCI-E is definitely faster, plus motherboard manufactures will probably be phasing out PCI soon (why wouldn't they when mobos have more PCI-E x1 slots than PCI?) so getting a PCI-E card would also mean not having to buy another card when PCI is gone completely. As far as it being a noticeable difference, yes definitely a noticeable difference.
 
A PCI-X card cannot be used in a PCI slot. It does have an advantage over regular PCI - more bandwidth. However, most PCI-E form factors are faster, so there's really no point in bothering with it.
 
A PCI-X card cannot be used in a PCI slot. It does have an advantage over regular PCI - more bandwidth. However, most PCI-E form factors are faster, so there's really no point in bothering with it.

Well, that's not always true. The physical layout of PCI-X is that of a 3.3v 64-bit PCI card, which are physically backwards compatible with the 32-bit slots we're used to seeing on desktop motherboards. Whether it will happily down-clock and run at 32bit/33mhz is specific to the card in question.
 
A PCI-X card cannot be used in a PCI slot. It does have an advantage over regular PCI - more bandwidth.....
Not true....in most cases. Part of the PCI-X specification requires backwards compatibility with standard PCI. Keep in mind there were, for a time, 64 bit PCI buses. Some of the legacy products the company I work for still produces are 64 bit PCI-X 133 cards and we test them all the time in 32 bit PCI slots.

Where you'll run into trouble is the I/O voltage. Most PCI slots are "universal" I/O slots which means they signal at 3.3V but can tolerate 5.0V I/O. As such, the slots are coded for "universal" I/O voltage by keying the slot. Some PCI-X devices are not 5V tolerant, and the cards may be keyed such that they won't physically fit in "universal" slots. I'll dig around and try to find a picture that describes what I'm talking about; it's done with the physical gaps in the edge connector. So the answer is a definite "it'll probably work fine"....:D It's very hardware dependent. Pretty easy to ask the card vendor if it's been tested / if it'll work in your specific MoBo.

While we're pretty fast in the enthusiast commuinty to adopt new technology, you may be surprised at how many PCI-X beasts there are, still hammering away in server rooms all over the world. Proven technology isn't thrown out the window by the server guys just because new things come along.....they have to prove the new tech and have a need to replace what's working very well.....:cool:
 
Not true....in most cases. Part of the PCI-X specification requires backwards compatibility with standard PCI. Keep in mind there were, for a time, 64 bit PCI buses. Some of the legacy products the company I work for still produces are 64 bit PCI-X 133 cards and we test them all the time in 32 bit PCI slots.

Where you'll run into trouble is the I/O voltage. Most PCI slots are "universal" I/O slots which means they signal at 3.3V but can tolerate 5.0V I/O. As such, the slots are coded for "universal" I/O voltage by keying the slot. Some PCI-X devices are not 5V tolerant, and the cards may be keyed such that they won't physically fit in "universal" slots. I'll dig around and try to find a picture that describes what I'm talking about; it's done with the physical gaps in the edge connector. So the answer is a definite "it'll probably work fine"....:D It's very hardware dependent. Pretty easy to ask the card vendor if it's been tested / if it'll work in your specific MoBo.

While we're pretty fast in the enthusiast commuinty to adopt new technology, you may be surprised at how many PCI-X beasts there are, still hammering away in server rooms all over the world. Proven technology isn't thrown out the window by the server guys just because new things come along.....they have to prove the new tech and have a need to replace what's working very well.....:cool:

Just to add a couple of things: Many server and workstation motherboards have PCIe, and PCI-X slots on them. I used to have a motherboard with a PCI-X slot on it but I no longer do. I do still have two PCI-X cards though. A 66MHz PCI-X card and a 133MHz PCI-X card. Both are storage controllers. My LSI MegaRAID U320-2 is being used right now on an ASUS P5W DH which only has standard PCI slots and no PCI-X slots. One thing you have to be careful of is some motherboards may not be able to take a PCI-X card because they have components in front of the regular PCI slots that will prevent a PCI-X card which is longer, from fitting correctly. All but one slot on the P5W DH suffers from this issue.
 
1) Can a PCI-X card be used in a PCI slot?
2) Any noticeable advantage of PCI-X over PCI?

1) My desktop's doing it right now, although it depends on the card.
2) Yeah...otherwise what would be the point? But if it's just you using the computer, no, because PCI is already plenty for a drive controller in a desktop setting. Servers, could be a different story depending on how it's used.
 
If you're buying both drives and a card, I'd suggest goin with SAS instead.

Absolutely. That's what I did and I couldn't be happier with my choice. Granted I am only using SATA Raptors with my SAS card, but I now have the infrastructure in place to move to SAS drives in the near future.

1) My desktop's doing it right now, although it depends on the card.
2) Yeah...otherwise what would be the point? But if it's just you using the computer, no, because PCI is already plenty for a drive controller in a desktop setting. Servers, could be a different story depending on how it's used.

Well even though it might be plenty in a desktop setting, and it surely is, why castrate the performance of your card by going with an older outdated interface? If you are buying a used card or you are just going for an economical model sure, but if you intend to spend serious bucks on a SAS or SCSI controller, then I'd suggest going with PCIe instead. It's the most attractive option in my opinion. Granted not always the cheapest.
 
Back
Top