P4P800 Woes

Vs17

Weaksauce
Joined
Sep 24, 2003
Messages
83
About two weeks ago I posted on HardForums with my busted PC...

http://www.hardforum.com/showthread.php?s=&threadid=746252

The problem was suspected to be the processor because the P4P800 Deluxe POST Reported "System Failed CPU Test". So I RMA'd the processor, and just installed the replacement today... and guess what, no go. The EXACT same problem occured. No screen output, no boot sequence, just that annoying little voice that haunts me in the night "System Failed CPU Test". So now I am lost, I have already reset the RTC Memory on the MOBO and am wondering if anybody out there can gimme any help. DO you think its the motherboard or what? Any Tests I should do? Thanks for any help or condolences for a crushed ego... :(
 
Originally posted by Vs17
About two weeks ago I posted on HardForums with my busted PC...

http://www.hardforum.com/showthread.php?s=&threadid=746252

The problem was suspected to be the processor because the P4P800 Deluxe POST Reported "System Failed CPU Test". So I RMA'd the processor, and just installed the replacement today...

Yeah, I sent back my original 2.8 C, which I thought was the problem. And I just recieved a completely new, out of the box 2.8 C from Intel today. I popped the NEW Cpu into the mobo and they same problem happened that ahd occured with my old CPU :(
 
remove everything from mobo, remove the motherboard from the case, pull the battery out, leave it out for an hour, put in cpu and attach heatsink firmly (stock sink for now), plug in the ram (single stick), plug in the video card, hook up powersupply to mobo/components (ie: vid card if you have a 9800, dont install cd drives or harddrive just yet) put battery back in, clear cmos, turn on the "computer" (leave it out of the case for now, you might have to jump start it, either that or hook up the button from the case to the mobo while leaving the mobo out on a cardboard box or something)

see if that boots up and gives you any errors. you're basically starting from scratch. if you get an error with the first stick of ram, try the other, just in case. if it boots up fine, add a hard drive, if that boots up fine, add a cd drive, and so on.

gl man, it sucks not being able to use something you've paid alot of money for.
 
I've tested all of the components in another working PC, the graphics card is fine, so is the RAM, and the hard drives shouldn't be a problem, b/c I get screen output even if they are dead. But I did try starting without any of the IDE's hooked up and that didn't seem to make a difference... Do you think running it out of the case will really make that much of a difference?
 
well, it by chance the board is being shorted out on the case, it could produce such an error depending on where/what was shorting out.

If it works out of the case but not in, you could always insulate the mb tray in the case with liquid electrical tape or some other means of insulation (I mention the LET because it's thin, can be painted wherever you need it, and insulates well)
 
What was the board you tested the ram in? One thing I have found is that memory that works in other boards doesn't necessarily work in the i865 and i875 boards.

Failing or incompatible memory will cause all kinds of damned errors that look like other problems.
 
Originally posted by Sir-Fragalot
What was the board you tested the ram in? One thing I have found is that memory that works in other boards doesn't necessarily work in the i865 and i875 boards.

Failing or incompatible memory will cause all kinds of damned errors that look like other problems.

true, and sometimes depending on the ram, it needs more than the default voltage to work. This happens on some Abit boards as they set default Dimm voltage to 2.5, and many chips (Corsair, Mushkin, etc...basically BH-5 based dimms) need 2.55-2.6v to work correctly.

btw...480GB!!! you have those in a Raid?? Damn sweet man. Noticed you have a Silverado 1500 too...you do the intake mod to it yet? Makes a hella difference (at least it did on mine. I've got a 1999 Sierra 1500 Custom)
 
sometimes its the fan I have read just by switching the fan it stops that error no fan connected will give it to you too
 
Originally posted by kennyc28
or maybe you got 2 bum boards in a row:rolleyes:
that would be my luck

I've gotten two bad boards in a row from Asus. a couple years ago, that would have shocked me...especially from Asus. However, it doesn't surprise me anymore because of all the stories I've heard about them recently. Something must have changed in the company or the parts they use.
 
i hope not 2 bum boards in a row...i just ordered one. it's my first build too :(
 
Usually this could be a result from the tray that the motherboard is attached to in your case. I had the same issue in an abit kg7 motherboard where one of the small screw holders was not being used but it was touching the motherboard and caused a short and the comp would start booting and a cpu failure would occur. After i removed the extra screw holder, the motherboard w/cpu worked fine together for over yr and a half.
 
Hey just wanted to let you guys know that I ended up buying a new P4P800 Deluxe from NewEgg, i believe it is a newer revision than the previous one I had which is now Rv 3 according to the manual. Anyway I popped this baby in and it worked! Everything is back to normal and now I have time to go out and buy FarCry and finally get back to some unreal gameplay
 
I had the exact same problem with my first P4P800. Asus tech support is worthless. The ticket with their helpdesk site is still open (since August) and no responses to comments like:

[8/24/2003 8:33:00 PM - cpm76]
does anyone look at this?


[8/25/2003 2:56:00 PM - cpm76]
I'm not impressed...

[9/6/2003 2:10:00 PM - cpm76]
...

I'd thank you all for the help, but it was nonexistant.

You can close this work order and be happy that you lost another customer with your "customer service" offerings.


[9/20/2003 3:55:00 PM - cpm76]
Wow...pending closure for a week. Its been a month. Thats is amazing support!

Pretty pathetic. Unfortunately, for the money their board was the best in August, so I just had Newegg send me another P4P800. I'll probably never buy another Asus board again. Abit (2nd time I haven't used them) and Gigabyte (built a couple systems with these and they weren't bad).
 
I just sent my P4P800 and 3.0C off to newegg for RMA. Damned Asus and their HUGE voltage fluctuations toasted my 3.0c. The vcore would range from 1.50v all the way up to 1.85v....and this is all when the bios was set to 1.52v.

At first I thought that it may not be a big deal since it wasn't at 1.85 for very long periods of time...however, I was dumb for thinking that b/c now I get random restarts with the 3.0c no matter what machine I put it it.

Bought an Abit AI7 and put my 2.4b in it until I get my new 3.0c back. Will probably sell the Asus. So far, I couldn't be much happier with this Abit Ai7 though...rock stable voltages. Vcore only fluctuates .01v between idle and load...and unlike Asus, the vcore actually increases .01v during load.

*VERY* stable board this AI7 is. Well worth the $109 I spent on it.
 
Back
Top