NVIDIA SLI & ATI CrossFire - Experiences & Opinions

kuyaglen said:
I dont have to reboot windows when I enable/disable SLI. Maybe you should use driver cleaner Kyle. Its been real time saver, especially with tweedling with graphic what-sa-ma-hu-sits in BF2 and other non-sli-profile games

He is running multiple monitors, are you?
 
kuyaglen said:
I dont have to reboot windows when I enable/disable SLI. Maybe you should use driver cleaner Kyle. Its been real time saver, especially with tweedling with graphic what-sa-ma-hu-sits in BF2 and other non-sli-profile games

Yeah, well, I have been through this issues with NVIDIA's engineers as well. I wish it was that simple.
 
Another point about crossfire setup, according to the article you have to have the cards in specific slots in order for crossfire to work, according to people on dfi forums however this isnt the case with the cfx 3200ddr mobo. The master card can be in any of the 2 slots and crossfire will stil work.


The one thing i totally agree with though is this bullshit of not being able to edit profiles and instead people have to balls around renaming exe files, i dunno why ati keep this hidden, to me its pretty dumb and they would be better off having some sort of app that let you select a rendering mode for a specific game.

Id love to see an ati rep haul ass in here and answer some questions as to why we can't make our own profiles, nvidia stepped up and let profiles be user made, time for ati to do the same.
 
Chris_B said:
Another point about crossfire setup, according to the article you have to have the cards in specific slots in order for crossfire to work, according to people on dfi forums however this isnt the case with the cfx 3200ddr mobo. The master card can be in any of the 2 slots and crossfire will stil work.


The one thing i totally agree with though is this bullshit of not being able to edit profiles and instead people have to balls around renaming exe files, i dunno why ati keep this hidden, to me its pretty dumb and they would be better off having some sort of app that let you select a rendering mode for a specific game.

Id love to see an ati rep haul ass in here and answer some questions as to why we can't make our own profiles, nvidia stepped up and let profiles be user made, time for ati to do the same.

I totally agree -- however, simply renaming GRAW to AFR-friendlyd3d is not a big deal. Did it and it works flawlessly. Wish I didn't have to do it, but not a big deal.

I think this article is pretty noobish. Hope [H] doesn't go the way of Tom's Hardware...
If you have concerns over the composition chip, why not ask ATI about it? Have them give you some numbers.

Otherwise it becomes unintended FUD
 
Anyone else remember the glory days of ATI PR flacks prepping the market for Crossfire, when they banged the drum about SLI needing profiles and CF would "work right out of the box with any game on the market"? Egad...
 
Commander Suzdal said:
Anyone else remember the glory days of ATI PR flacks prepping the market for Crossfire, when they banged the drum about SLI needing profiles and CF would "work right out of the box with any game on the market"? Egad...

Yup :)
It's kinda like "ATI is better becuse they release drivers on a fixed interval" ;)
That one turned out to be not so straigth forward too...

Terra...
 
gersson said:
I think this article is pretty noobish. Hope [H] doesn't go the way of Tom's Hardware...


Uh, well, this article was written exactly for people who have no experience with SLI or CrossFire.....not the expereienced user.
 
^ yeah and it helped alot! Maybe in a year or two i'll go cf with my soon to be rig. Quick question for cf, If i have a crossfire intel motherboard and i have conroe e6600, could i buy like the high end ati dx 10 card then buy the high end dx 10 mastercard edition?
 
My only thoughts after another fine Brent article is what his thoughts are with the nforce5. I know that if using SLI with 7900gtx or better, there is supposed to be an automatic bandwidth boost and on paper it doesn't look to add anything. I haven't seen anything from user experience yet. Kyle, you need to hook up Brent with some AM2 sli gaming so we can see what benefits it has over the old NF4 if any. I'm curious to see if that extra bandwidth helps green kick up the image quality a little bit more. And Brent, keep those articles comin!
 
gigantorebirdie said:
My only thoughts after another fine Brent article is what his thoughts are with the nforce5. I know that if using SLI with 7900gtx or better, there is supposed to be an automatic bandwidth boost and on paper it doesn't look to add anything. I haven't seen anything from user experience yet. Kyle, you need to hook up Brent with some AM2 sli gaming so we can see what benefits it has over the old NF4 if any. I'm curious to see if that extra bandwidth helps green kick up the image quality a little bit more. And Brent, keep those articles comin!

Thanks for the suggestions.

The answer is it gives no real gameplay advantages, but might give you a bigger e-penis.
 
Don't forget Super AA... Crossfire allows to use of Super AA modes with little to no performance hit.

This is thanks to the Mastercard config but will still be in the R600 series since those cards will have the necessary components built into the VPU.
 
gersson said:
I totally agree -- however, simply renaming GRAW to AFR-friendlyd3d is not a big deal. Did it and it works flawlessly. Wish I didn't have to do it, but not a big deal.

I think this article is pretty noobish. Hope [H] doesn't go the way of Tom's Hardware...
If you have concerns over the composition chip, why not ask ATI about it? Have them give you some numbers.

Otherwise it becomes unintended FUD

Without articles like this, we would remain noobs forever.

Toms Hardware started scewing reviews for money. The comparison doesnt hold water here.
 
vexter said:
Without articles like this, we would remain noobs forever.

Toms Hardware started scewing reviews for money. The comparison doesnt hold water here.

QFT!

Terra...
 
Terra said:
Yup :)
It's kinda like "ATI is better becuse they release drivers on a fixed interval" ;)
That one turned out to be not so straigth forward too...

Having an official driver every month is better than ever several months. Unless you like playing with betas, and their bugs.
 
fallguy said:
Having an official driver every month is better than ever several months. Unless you like playing with betas, and their bugs.

So every new driver release is better than the one before?

Terra - Make a driver if there is a reason...not just to make one :rolleyes:
 
Terra said:
So every new driver release is better than the one before?

Terra - Make a driver if there is a reason...not just to make one :rolleyes:

Yes, every driver fixes bugs. So yes, in that part it is better. Dont pretend NV couldnt fix bugs if they released a new driver every month.
 
fallguy said:
Yes, every driver fixes bugs. So yes, in that part it is better. Dont pretend NV couldnt fix bugs if they released a new driver every month.

So why do people complain over eg. 6.6 and roll back to 6.3(I think that is the popular pick)..remember..I am talking about people...that dosn't mean that YOUR personal experience is Alfa-Omega...

I prefer a driver, when there is the need, instaad of a deadline-driver, that has nothing to do with the amount of fixes(and bugs) made...

Terra...
 
Terra said:
So why do people complain over eg. 6.6 and roll back to 6.3(I think that is the popular pick)..remember..I am talking about people...that dosn't mean that YOUR personal experience is Alfa-Omega...

Same reason that nvidia users dont always prefer the latest drivers probably, just take a look at the thread about nv's latest whql drivers.

I prefer a driver, when there is the need, instaad of a deadline-driver, that has nothing to do with the amount of fixes(and bugs) made...
Terra...

Just cause ATI have over 12 whql driver releases a year and a few betas, dont mean you have to download them all.
 
Terra said:
So why do people complain over eg. 6.6 and roll back to 6.3(I think that is the popular pick)..remember..I am talking about people...that dosn't mean that YOUR personal experience is Alfa-Omega...

I prefer a driver, when there is the need, instaad of a deadline-driver, that has nothing to do with the amount of fixes(and bugs) made...

Spank answered that pretty well. Some people just like certain drivers, for one reason or another. Personally, I always use the latest, except when the Chuck patch was only out for one driver. I dont have any problems with the 6.4's, 6.5's, or with the 6.6's now. [H] said the 6.6's would be out in July for some reason, that would be the 6.7's.

Looking at the release notes, 6.6's have about 27 fixes. Several new features, and a pretty large performance increase in F.E.A.R. Why wouldnt I want ATi to release this driver? If you dont think NV "needs" a driver right now, then thats your opinion. People who have bugs that they would like fixes, would disagree. So would people who want performance increases, and new features. There are always things that can be fixed, and I welcome a driver as often as ATi puts out for that reason, among others.
 
Spank said:
Same reason that nvidia users dont always prefer the latest drivers probably, just take a look at the thread about nv's latest whql drivers.

Just my point...fixed interval releases dosn't mean it will be better.

Just cause ATI have over 12 whql driver releases a year and a few betas, dont mean you have to download them all.

So you are saying that they could do with less? ;) *L*

Terra...
 
Terra said:
So you are saying that they could do with less? ;) *L*

Terra...

Sure, some user dont need to have a driver released every month, other users would want a daily driver drop.
 
Hey, good article. Covered all the bases. I agree with Brent on the dongle issue, though neither camp's hardware connection methods are very elegant. Wasn't nVidia supposed to move to an SLi connector-less solution at some point?

But I have to ask: why no love for Apple's 30" Cinema Display? Too much Dell and not enough Apple, I say, and let it be known!
 
phide said:
But I have to ask: why no love for Apple's 30" Cinema Display? Too much Dell and not enough Apple, I say, and let it be known!

$2199 vs $2499
Longer warranty: 3 years vs 1 year
Less adjustable positioning.

That being said, the Apple *is* a sweet looking monitor.

CNET's face-off between the two favored Apple ever so slightly in gaming and DVD playback, and Dell in day-to-day stuff.
 
pp4 par2 : "ATI can do this to," should read "ATI can do this too,"

pp4 par8 : When we set up ATI CrossFire for our BFGTech 7950 GX2 evaluation we had a lot of trouble getting CrossFire to work.

Maybe I'm out of the loop here, but why would you be setting up CrossFire for the 7950 GX2 ?

Just my $.02 (x2)
 
campey said:
Maybe I'm out of the loop here, but why would you be setting up CrossFire for the 7950 GX2 ?


They were setting it up on another system to see how 2 x1900's in crossfire mode would compare against the dual gpu 7950.
 
I for one have enjoyed my crossfire setup but i would be a neophyte not to say that it wasn't without issues. As in with new technology there is a overwhelming question is it stable and User Friendly. When i first started setting up my new pc i was unsure of what value's to give each field so i started by trial and error and looking threw various forums to find answers. And in the end it worked out for me but alot of users who do not have a technical geeky standpoint such as me would be lost in the woods. As with both green and red's underlying technology there is STILL a learning curve to understand what works and want doesn't. Could you imagine if crossfire/SLI was forced onto everyone all of a sudden...would you want to be at either company's tech support....i for for one wouldn't want to be.

-Chad
 
Wow I just thought the CrossFire dongle was an annoying kludge, I didn't know that it potentially could create problems on the engineering level....nice comprehensive review there. The only concern that has been raised bandwidth-wise with SLI is the speed of the interconnect between the Southbridge and Northbridge. This was commented on in Maximum PC to the effect of "Since nVidia won't cough up the internconnect speed, we assume it to be less than 8GB/sec" where 8GB/sec is the maximum PCI-E thoroughput right now.

Other than that, SLI is, from personal experience, very easy to use. Plug it in and they work. Heck, it even tells you if you forgot (which I have) to put the connector on (d'oh!)
 
I have the vertical lines problem with my x1900 CF setup and a CRT. The FW900. One of the best screens of all time imo. Two vertical lines that scroll up steady during certain parts of Prey most notably. Certainly not tearing. There are usually two lines and they scroll up the screen pretty uniform - remaining parallel. :(
 
That was a very informative article.

I had intended on going the Crossfire upgrade path with a X1800XT because of how ATI cards perform in Oblivion, now you have given me something to think about.

Love your site.
 
biohazard_nz said:
Im not the best at English, but isnt that ... like... wrong?

Kyle - Word left out. Should read "performance LOSS," fixed. Thanks.

I thought it was supposed to read..

"and a delay in this can cost you performance at a critical moment. "
 
Back
Top