MSI NEO4 SLI using the "silicon controller" question?

newls1

Supreme [H]ardness
Joined
Sep 8, 2003
Messages
4,628
I know that when I used the onboard silicon controller with my ASUS A8N-SLI DLX, as soon as you start to OC, you will lose that controller, and no where in the BIOS can you lock the speed of it. The MSI, however has a silicon SATA controller also, but if any of you are OC and using the controller, does the MSI put a "LOCK" on it, so I can still use it, and OC at the same time? The MSI also only has 2 ports on the silicon controller, where the ASUS had 4, does this mean anything? I haven't got the board yet, just asking "PRE assembly" questions, so I know where to connect what. ;)
 
I dont use the sata ports but I've heard that the two sata ports closest to the cpu mount are locked. I belive they may be controlled by the Nforce chipset rather than the sil3132 chip
 
The biggest difference is that the MSI K8N Neo4 Platinum/SLI and Diamond boards use a PCIe SiI 3132 controller that is on the PCIe (PCI Express buss) and not an older SiI controller on the PCI buss.

Since the PCIe buss is locked, unless you specifically choose to change it, you won't loose the SiI 3132 controller during an overclock.

The 3132 controller also is a full SATA II controller that supports NCQ and a number of other enhancements that the SiI controller on the ASUS doesn't offer. May change when the ASUS Premium is released.

I suspect that the PCI buss (not PCIe) doesn't lock on the ASUS board and since SATA is very dependent on it's timing for correct operations is the reason it fails. With the PCIe buss locked on the MSI board you should be set if you are using this board.

The nForce4 SATA II ports still have a slight performance edge over the SiI3132 ports, so make sure to use the nForce ports first.
 
HighTest said:
The biggest difference is that the MSI K8N Neo4 Platinum/SLI and Diamond boards use a PCIe SiI 3132 controller that is on the PCIe (PCI Express buss) and not an older SiI controller on the PCI buss.

Since the PCIe buss is locked, unless you specifically choose to change it, you won't loose the SiI 3132 controller during an overclock.

The 3132 controller also is a full SATA II controller that supports NCQ and a number of other enhancements that the SiI controller on the ASUS doesn't offer. May change when the ASUS Premium is released.

I suspect that the PCI buss (not PCIe) doesn't lock on the ASUS board and since SATA is very dependent on it's timing for correct operations is the reason it fails. With the PCIe buss locked on the MSI board you should be set if you are using this board.

The nForce4 SATA II ports still have a slight performance edge over the SiI3132 ports, so make sure to use the nForce ports first.


Thank you :)
 
newls1 said:
I know that when I used the onboard silicon controller with my ASUS A8N-SLI DLX, as soon as you start to OC, you will lose that controller, and no where in the BIOS can you lock the speed of it. The MSI, however has a silicon SATA controller also, but if any of you are OC and using the controller, does the MSI put a "LOCK" on it, so I can still use it, and OC at the same time? The MSI also only has 2 ports on the silicon controller, where the ASUS had 4, does this mean anything? I haven't got the board yet, just asking "PRE assembly" questions, so I know where to connect what. ;)

On the MSI platinum everything is locked,the PCI,PCI-E,SATA Controllers. I have one with a sound card in the PCI slot and 2 Raptors on SATA 1 and 2 ports and can overclock to 290 HTT.
 
Back
Top