Microsoft Makes $2B A Year From Android Patents

I'll stick with the OED definition:



Also, don't tell me what to fucking do. It's my opinion and it happens to align nicely with the real meaning of the word. Unlike some people I actually work to achieve a goal to better mankind, not to roll around in money. Seriously, you piss me the fuck off telling me how to think, and it is uncalled for.

I'm going to go back to using my computer, electricity, etc. to support folding, spending my own money to help others, and donating to charity. Greed is evil and unethical.

Wow , someone piss in your Wheaties or something? How about instead of hoping onto the high horse you propose an intelligent counter argument that doesn't involve your unneeded aggression towards an topic based on opinion?

Its an Internet forum , not a rage management class.
 
Wow , someone piss in your Wheaties or something? How about instead of hoping onto the high horse you propose an intelligent counter argument that doesn't involve your unneeded aggression towards an topic based on opinion?

Its an Internet forum , not a rage management class.

How about you stop telling me what to fucking do. Here is some logic: A forum is for open discussion about opinions, not ordering people around. And since we are telling people what to do, stop quoting or responding to me. /topic
 
Patents are not a valid concept. They are legalized state-sanctioned robbery.

Microsoft can't compete with Android so they resort to theft instead.

Why did we know the anarchist was going to say something like this.
 
They're not state-sanctioned robbery, they're a state-sanctioned monopoly. Big difference.

Also worth mentioning that it's a monopoly that's only temporary, requires fully disclose the details of your invention to get, and requires compliance with a bunch of requirements to get and keep.

Microsoft has disclosed nothing. You aren't allowed to know what "patents" you are even violating.

A state-sanctioned monopoly is just as illegitimate.
 
Of course patents are a valid concept, otherwise people could just copy and reverse engineer any work of others and sell it as their own. In a capitalistic society their has to be some type of patent system, otherwise it would not only be government that one would have to fear confiscating their property, but the welfare class as well who many around here claim are only interested in stealing the wealth of others. How better than to steal it at the source.

As for Microsoft being able to compete against Android, could you compete against someone stealing all of your wealth?

Hmm, I think I've seen this done before :
*cough*
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/CP/M
*cough*
 
How about you stop telling me what to fucking do. Here is some logic: A forum is for open discussion about opinions, not ordering people around. And since we are telling people what to do, stop quoting or responding to me. /topic

And I openly discussed my opinion that I disagreed with you. But hey let's not even bother with the whole discussion aspect of a public forum concerning me and you since your hostility seemingly is getting the better of you.

Welcome to ignore , your request has been accepted.

/topic
 
This thread just shows that some of you hate Microsoft more than you like Android. The patents are valid. If you don't like that, make your own proprietary software and hardware interfaces. That simple.
 
And Microsoft never steals...
Just like how they hired their NT head programmers from Digital Media and made their new OS so similar to VMS MS settled out of court and forked over millions in the process.
Or how they bought, not developed DOS.
Then again, Apple isn't any better. They charge for a free OS and rip off all their design ideas from existing products while trying to patent everything that hasn't been yet, and some things that already have.
Then Again, BOTH companies stole their "revolutionary" ideas from Xerox, without whom we'd never have a mouse or GUI. could you imagine if Xerox had patented the GUI and mouse?
 
And Microsoft never steals...
Just like how they hired their NT head programmers from Digital Media and made their new OS so similar to VMS MS settled out of court and forked over millions in the process.
Or how they bought, not developed DOS.
Then again, Apple isn't any better. They charge for a free OS and rip off all their design ideas from existing products while trying to patent everything that hasn't been yet, and some things that already have.
Then Again, BOTH companies stole their "revolutionary" ideas from Xerox, without whom we'd never have a mouse or GUI. could you imagine if Xerox had patented the GUI and mouse?

lol most of this is true but it is completely wrong to make claims as ridiculous as we would never have a mouse or a GUI if not for Xerox. It is possible that the windows style scheme may have never developed in fact it could have been something more like windows 8 that developed. But someone would have developed a GUI within the next couple years for sure. I would even venture that the mouse would have come sooner or later as well. After all the Xerox guys thought of it. It is a ridiculous as stating that FPS games would have never developed if not for id or whoever did it first. Its just one of those things people will aspire too sooner or later.
 
Did MS ever specify which patents they hold that is actually forcing all the Android manufacturers to cough up? I've been wondering about this for quite a while.
Nope and I think their refusal to even say how they THINK people are infringing without them signing NDAs should be grounds for forcing disclosure or invalidating their patents entirely.

At this point it's just legalized extortion.
Extortion? Microsoft sweetened the pot pretty heavily when "going after" OEM's for infringing on its patents. They didn't really have to twist their arms very hard...

1. Microsoft offered to license the patents rather than simply outright sue the OEMs. +1
2. The OEM would have been sued against all profits made from every single infringement. The license agreement did not demand paying any back-owed funds. +1
3. Microsoft offered that licensing as part of a bundle containing a multitude of patents, not just the ones being infringed. Covers the OEM's asses at no additional cost. +1
4. Every OEM that refused the deal to license Microsoft's patents was sued, forwent the umbrella licensing, forwent not having to pack all back-owed funds,...and I don't recall a single one pulling out a victory.

Somehow "extortion" doesn't really define "offering to cover more than what was being used without permission while ALSO not demanding payment for all the money owed up to that point"
 
Microsoft offered motorola a different way to sync their calendar without infringing on their patent either. But this happened during the buy out.
 
Extortion? Microsoft sweetened the pot pretty heavily when "going after" OEM's for infringing on its patents. They didn't really have to twist their arms very hard...

1. Microsoft offered to license the patents rather than simply outright sue the OEMs. +1
2. The OEM would have been sued against all profits made from every single infringement. The license agreement did not demand paying any back-owed funds. +1
3. Microsoft offered that licensing as part of a bundle containing a multitude of patents, not just the ones being infringed. Covers the OEM's asses at no additional cost. +1
4. Every OEM that refused the deal to license Microsoft's patents was sued, forwent the umbrella licensing, forwent not having to pack all back-owed funds,...and I don't recall a single one pulling out a victory.

Somehow "extortion" doesn't really define "offering to cover more than what was being used without permission while ALSO not demanding payment for all the money owed up to that point"

It is extortion because it is pay up or else when there is no moral or ethical justification for Microsoft using coercion.

Microsoft is a hypocrite of the highest order considering that their entire business empire is built off of stuff that they "copied (e.g. MS-DOS was little more than a second-rate copy of CP/M and its APIs).
 
Most corporations are indeed corrupt. Most people are corrupt.

I love to hear how people complain about "big corporations" and would love to see how these people would feel if you took their smartphone, laptop, free music, dvd/bluray collection, weed, etc etc etc away.

Deep down all of you love your corporate babysitters.
 
Instead of whining about MS and trying to pitch this as something that is horribly wrong with the patent system or tech world why don't people think of it as a good thing for android. 2 Billion in license fees just puts into perspective the massive volume of android devices that are shipping and it is surely the case that the royalties paid to MS are not the only patents they are paying for.
 
Also why do people say that these patents pay for Xbox, lol so MS takes money from android in the form of royalties and applies it to their unrelated home entertainment division lol? Seems more likely that money would be reinvested in windows phone don't you think?
 
Also why do people say that these patents pay for Xbox, lol so MS takes money from android in the form of royalties and applies it to their unrelated home entertainment division lol? Seems more likely that money would be reinvested in windows phone don't you think?

Does it seem like they put $2B/yr into WP8?
 
It is extortion because it is pay up or else when there is no moral or ethical justification for Microsoft using coercion.
Your statement contradicts itself. The justification is that they own patents covering the technology that these OEMs are using.

Microsoft was within their rights to sue, and collect all back-owed profits, but they chose to be nice about it. I'm not seeing what your issue with them is here.

Would you have preferred they behave like Apple and just go lawsuit-happy :rolleyes:
 
Back
Top