Microsoft Disputes Poor MSE Grade

If important data was backed up, is the worst case scenario of damage from a virus is to remove and replace the OS drive? That seems cheap compared to yearly AV prices.

Or even without backup could the user boot into linux after the fact and move files to a USB drive or something similar, then format the infected drive and reinstall Windows? $0 cost, then.

I'm definitely not paying for antivirus, long live MSE.

I just recently learned about this software called Deep Freeze ($35 a year though).

As best as I can understand the way it works is you install everything you want and then lock that "image" in place. The Deep Freeze software then acts as a middle-man between the harddrive and the OS and makes the OS think its writing data to the harddrive when in fact its going to a temp area. Thus everytime you reboot the computer its boots up from that fresh image. You can of course temporarily unlock the image so as to install new software, plus you can set aside unlocked areas like User folders so they save documents and stuff.

What I think is cool is that you can essentially completely hose the system to the point of blue screen and simply reboot it and your back in business. I would like something like this on our PC's at home, but $35 a year (and I guess thats per PC) seems a little much. I don't care for license models.
 
On a sidenote I will give a round of applause to Windows 8 here.

Yesterday I was handed a new Windows 8 machine that a buddy of mine said had been hit by the ransomeware that tell you your PC is locked and demands £100 to unlock it.

Basically he was browsing and 'bang' the message popped up and he couldnt do anythnig. So he just switched it off and handed it to me.

Now usually this one is a nasty one to get rid off and most times needs a AV boot disk to really get rid of it.

However, out of curiousity I plugged it in and booted it up. Instead of the usual black screen and then the ransom demand it went straigh to the Start Screen and Defender popped up saying it was deleteing a malicious file. After that the PC worked fine. I then did a full sweep with Defender and it rounded up a couple more sub files and that was it. Further scans with other products found nothing.

So the new setup with 8 loading the AV before anything else seems to work as intended.
 
Say what you will, but I have yet to see an infected Windows 8 computer where I work. We check in upwards of 20 computers per day, mostly for malware removal. Either MSE/WD is doing a good job, NOBODY is using 8, or 8 is super secure. I'd say the first option.
 
I literally just uninstalled McAfee and about 3 other anti-malware programs on a friend's XP machine today and then installed MSE. Sounds like money exchanging hands tbh.
People think it's "more likely" that someone at AV-TEST.ORG is getting paid off, than it is that MSE just isn't as good as paid for products that are made by companies who are dedicated exclusively to antivirus?

Get real...
 
Panda Cloud
AVG
Avast
Avira

All certified

All free

So much for the "they are getting paid off because it's free" comments.
 
We use Symantec Endpoint Protection for most of our business clients, and have used MSE for businesses smaller than 10 users.

I'm not very impressed with either of them, really.

Does anyone have any opinions on Kaspersky for business/enterprise?
I don't know about Kaspersky, but at my job we weighed several options and ended up going with Vipre Business for our workstations. We're still in the process of deploying it with W7, but it's been flawless so far and already had one experience where it completely stopped infection on an XP box it was installed on.
 
Panda Cloud
AVG
Avast
Avira

All certified

All free

So much for the "they are getting paid off because it's free" comments.
I think mse is getting flack from this because it's heuristics to catch 0-day stuff, isn't as aggressive which is true for the most part mse uses strong dictionaries to catch and clean up things. But it brings up a whole lot less false positives and it's a light weight scan because of that and people like that.
 
So far MSE have serve me well. All 3 PC here in my home are using it. As others have mentioned, its light and has never gave me any trouble with false positive or interrupting program installation.
 
I look at free porn all the time . No problems yet.

I installed MSE on my parents computers years ago. No problems since(shocking).

I'll be sticking with MSE.
 
I just recently learned about this software called Deep Freeze ($35 a year though).

As best as I can understand the way it works is you install everything you want and then lock that "image" in place. The Deep Freeze software then acts as a middle-man between the harddrive and the OS and makes the OS think its writing data to the harddrive when in fact its going to a temp area. Thus everytime you reboot the computer its boots up from that fresh image. You can of course temporarily unlock the image so as to install new software, plus you can set aside unlocked areas like User folders so they save documents and stuff.

What I think is cool is that you can essentially completely hose the system to the point of blue screen and simply reboot it and your back in business. I would like something like this on our PC's at home, but $35 a year (and I guess thats per PC) seems a little much. I don't care for license models.

Just create restore points. Setup your PC the way you want, create a restore point. If something happens, restore it back. If you can't boot into Windows, press F8 while booting, then restore at that time.

Restore doesn't mess with user documents/files. So if you caught a virus, restore, then clean it out with whatever anti-malware scanner you have.

I started doing this with my sister's PC, as she lets her kids have a field day on that thing and it ends up with malware in no time. I just wrote out steps on how to perform a restore in Windows and also during the boot-up phase.

Course, I feel I'll be fixing a PC when I get back home. I gave my parents a PC and didn't set any of that up, as they don't connect to the internet. Only video encoding/subbing work. Then my sister jacked that machine from my parents.
 
I just recently learned about this software called Deep Freeze ($35 a year though).

As best as I can understand the way it works is you install everything you want and then lock that "image" in place. The Deep Freeze software then acts as a middle-man between the harddrive and the OS and makes the OS think its writing data to the harddrive when in fact its going to a temp area. Thus everytime you reboot the computer its boots up from that fresh image. You can of course temporarily unlock the image so as to install new software, plus you can set aside unlocked areas like User folders so they save documents and stuff.

What I think is cool is that you can essentially completely hose the system to the point of blue screen and simply reboot it and your back in business. I would like something like this on our PC's at home, but $35 a year (and I guess thats per PC) seems a little much. I don't care for license models.


What I do is just sandbox software I don't trust until I have a chance to see what it does. I love Sandboxie! It's worked well for me that's for sure.
 
I haven't even seen a infection detected or cleaned in like forever under Windows, but I'm not the typical warez-monkey/porn addict/britneyspears.jpg.exe.vbs link clicker who seem to constantly get infected. :p

I look at free porn all the time . No problems yet.

I installed MSE on my parents computers years ago. No problems since(shocking).

I'll be sticking with MSE.

Problem with both of the above quotes is that a lot of the more serious malware nowadays hides itself so that you don't notice it, so it can collect info or use your system in a botnet, without you knowing. You don't have to go to "bad" sites to get infected, though you have a greater chance of infection from those types of sites. I've gotten infected from tech sites, when doing research on Google for work, etc. It happens and watching where you surf is no longer a valid way to avoid risk of infection.

Just create restore points. Setup your PC the way you want, create a restore point. If something happens, restore it back. If you can't boot into Windows, press F8 while booting, then restore at that time.

Restore doesn't mess with user documents/files. So if you caught a virus, restore, then clean it out with whatever anti-malware scanner you have.

Not 100% sure, but I thought I've read articles on malware that can get deep enough in your system that a restore doesn't get rid of it.

The main problem with AV is the more popular it gets the less effective it gets.

The crime gangs will work on beating the top five AV programs and that would give them a break in to probably 75% of machines for 24 hours. MSE is really popular and you can bet its one of the first they test their code against.

You need to find one of the lesser known ones and hope they do enough work to keep it effective.

Me? I use MSE still but bolstered with EMET3.0 on max to help against the zero day stuff.

EMET 3.0 and/or some common sense setup on your computer can help as much or more as AV, though I don't recommend not using AV. Harden your system, it's not hard. Turn off services you don't need, keep your OS and applications patched, turn on the firewall, don't use an admin account as your normal account, etc. You can look up USGCB settings, CIS benchmarks and others to get an idea of settings that can be locked down. You don't have to go as far as some of those recommendations, but especially keeping your OS and apps up to date is the best way to go. I've also removed everything Adobe from my system and I've removed Java as well. Too many issues to keep that crap on my systems.
 
A few things I have learnt over the past few years doing virus cleaning.

1. Viruses hide in System Restore files. Using it can just bring back a world of hurt.

2. You cant clean a XP/Vista/7 PC by just using itself. As mentioned earlier the viruses stealth themselves before the AV loads and wont find them. You have to remove the drive and scan it on another PC. Windows 8 does seem to mitigate that somewhat.

3. Malwarebytes isn't as good as a lot of folks think. Really it isn't. Hasn't been for some time. Doesn't find an awful lot these days. Needs a new engine.

4. As most of the nasty stuff is written daily you pretty much have an even chance of getting hit no matter what AV you use. It's all about the other steps you take to harden your system that often saves you.
 
Screw these reviews...

When I built my first WIn 7 rig, I loaded our 'corporate' McAfee. Within days it started running like shit. I installed MSE, it found two viruses McAfee missed, so I uninstalled McAfee and the PC started to run perfectly. I then reloaded that OS and included MSE and never had a problem with it again.
 
Screw these reviews...

When I built my first WIn 7 rig, I loaded our 'corporate' McAfee. Within days it started running like shit. I installed MSE, it found two viruses McAfee missed, so I uninstalled McAfee and the PC started to run perfectly. I then reloaded that OS and included MSE and never had a problem with it again.

That's not so much because mse is so great it's because McAfee is so terrible. I use mse personally and its been fine for me but for those family members that feel the need to click every banner ad and don't seem to listen when I tell them to stop installing wallpapers, fancy cursors and stupid themes that come as an exe they pay for better (nod 32 or Kaspersky usually).

I would rather get the annoying call that "my stupid antivirus" won't let them install their new screensaver than hear that the machine is running like shit and crashing.

In that scenario the good paid programs have served me much better.
 
I just recently learned about this software called Deep Freeze ($35 a year though).

As best as I can understand the way it works is you install everything you want and then lock that "image" in place. The Deep Freeze software then acts as a middle-man between the harddrive and the OS and makes the OS think its writing data to the harddrive when in fact its going to a temp area. Thus everytime you reboot the computer its boots up from that fresh image. You can of course temporarily unlock the image so as to install new software, plus you can set aside unlocked areas like User folders so they save documents and stuff.

What I think is cool is that you can essentially completely hose the system to the point of blue screen and simply reboot it and your back in business. I would like something like this on our PC's at home, but $35 a year (and I guess thats per PC) seems a little much. I don't care for license models.

Yup DeepFreeze works wonders but only in certain situations. We tried using it at our work for training room machines... What a pain, you have to unlock/reboot to do almost anything which gets tiresome, given monthly updates etc etc.

Could work at home better, and I know the enterprise version could probably be useful since it can automate unlock/updates etc. We found ultimately it was easier to just reimage problem computers.

MS system restore??? Man I swear that has only helped me 5% of the time. Usually restores fail or do nothing to solve the problem at least in my limit experience. As a matter of fact in a corporate environment where apps and imaging is managed, its faster to just reimage.
 
Anti-virus is such an antiquated concept.

In the UNIX world, we just mount the file system for the home directory as noexec and then users cannot execute anything that they download, no matter how malicious.
 
Anti-virus is such an antiquated concept.

In the UNIX world, we just mount the file system for the home directory as noexec and then users cannot execute anything that they download, no matter how malicious.

How does that stop malware from exploiting potential 0day flaws in the OS Kernel or it's components though? :p
 
I just recently learned about this software called Deep Freeze ($35 a year though).

As best as I can understand the way it works is you install everything you want and then lock that "image" in place. The Deep Freeze software then acts as a middle-man between the harddrive and the OS and makes the OS think its writing data to the harddrive when in fact its going to a temp area. Thus everytime you reboot the computer its boots up from that fresh image. You can of course temporarily unlock the image so as to install new software, plus you can set aside unlocked areas like User folders so they save documents and stuff.

What I think is cool is that you can essentially completely hose the system to the point of blue screen and simply reboot it and your back in business. I would like something like this on our PC's at home, but $35 a year (and I guess thats per PC) seems a little much. I don't care for license models.

You can use MS steady state for free, Does the same thing. It's older now though, doesn't work on windows 7.
 
Microsoft fucking up another program who would have thought it.. Microsoft is really bad at screwing shit up shortly after they have acquired it.
 
Problem with both of the above quotes is that a lot of the more serious malware nowadays hides itself so that you don't notice it, so it can collect info or use your system in a botnet, without you knowing.
lol, infection still requires a vector and botnets/malware infections are problems that often reside between the keyboard and chair. There certainly are exploits which are passive in nature, and people often get very touchy about those when it involves a sacred cow (porn "usage", using software"cracks", Java, FireFox, IE, etc). My usage is pretty typical and I don't get infected. It's that's simple. The difference is that I don't do what causes the infections, or use internet facing software with poor security.

Plus no one really wants to be considered "that n00b" who basically gets infected all the time out of massive ignorance and complete disregard for using even a tiny bit of common sense. :p
 
Microsoft fucking up another program who would have thought it.. Microsoft is really bad at screwing shit up shortly after they have acquired it.

truth.jpg


looks like Facebook might put the final nail in Skype aswell with their new calling feature. Why MS didn't really do anything with Skype, beyond maintaining it, is baffling. It's like they buy up/create tech... feel it's 'good enough' and lets it stagnate. Then another company comes along, does it better and makes MS's product obsolete.

And then you have the flip side where they come up with great ideas/products, release them in a halfassed state and then wonder why it doesn't succeed.

As someone that used to be a MS fanboy... I have a lot of contempt for the company as of late.
 
How does that stop malware from exploiting potential 0day flaws in the OS Kernel or it's components though? :p

It still has to execute code in order to do that. Since there is no place for the user to store files with a +x permission, it would be rather difficult to do. Even if you exploited the browser, for example, any code or malicious files downloaded would be stored in the noexec mounted home partition.

We also don't do stupid things like run network daemons in kernel mode.
 
If you take a look at the documentation from AV-Test, you'll see that MSSE, like all the other products they tested, detected 100% of known viruses. What it "failed" on was in the detection of newly written zero-day exploits (that were not yet in the wild) that AV-Test either found or wrote themselves. Essentially MS's defense boils down to, "by the time these zero-day exploits make it into the wild, we'll have added it to our definitions."

In my opinion, the heuristics engines used by most AV packages are pretty irritating. The constant false positives in some packages (Avast! and Kaspersky were pretty bad, NOD32 was actually the best paid package I've used in this regard) and the system resource hogging most heuristics engines require make me want to just uninstall the AV software and take the risk. For me, MSSE is an almost ideal blend of low system resource usage, low false positives, and "good enough for me" detection.
 
Microsoft doesn't seem too thrilled that it failed to earn certification from the folks at AV-Test. The company made the following statement:

Oh lol thats is lame. AV is supposed to protect you against all threats not the ones you choose. I found MSE misses a lot now compared to the a year go. I prefer avira myself, but in all honesty my sonicwalls do more then any AV.
 
If you take a look at the documentation from AV-Test, you'll see that MSSE, like all the other products they tested, detected 100% of known viruses. What it "failed" on was in the detection of newly written zero-day exploits (that were not yet in the wild) that AV-Test either found or wrote themselves. Essentially MS's defense boils down to, "by the time these zero-day exploits make it into the wild, we'll have added it to our definitions."

In my opinion, the heuristics engines used by most AV packages are pretty irritating. The constant false positives in some packages (Avast! and Kaspersky were pretty bad, NOD32 was actually the best paid package I've used in this regard) and the system resource hogging most heuristics engines require make me want to just uninstall the AV software and take the risk. For me, MSSE is an almost ideal blend of low system resource usage, low false positives, and "good enough for me" detection.


Hence why I use EMET3.0 as its designed to work against zero day stuff. Works really well with MSSE.
 
lol, infection still requires a vector and botnets/malware infections are problems that often reside between the keyboard and chair. There certainly are exploits which are passive in nature, and people often get very touchy about those when it involves a sacred cow (porn "usage", using software"cracks", Java, FireFox, IE, etc). My usage is pretty typical and I don't get infected. It's that's simple. The difference is that I don't do what causes the infections, or use internet facing software with poor security.

Plus no one really wants to be considered "that n00b" who basically gets infected all the time out of massive ignorance and complete disregard for using even a tiny bit of common sense. :p

I guess I'm not grasping what you're trying to say. I don't use porn on this computer, I don't use cracks or hacks and I don't use file sharing. That said, I got infected about a year ago when I hit Ars Technica, to read some daily tech news. Turns out the ad server that serves the ads on their site was infected, so anyone hitting their site got infected. There is no such thing as "safe surfing habits" nowadays, unless you're saying you're using a sandboxed browser, without plugins like Java or Adobe products. If that is what you're saying, then I agree... ;) I just don't want people reading this thread looking at the information thinking to themselves that if they don't have "bad computer habits" they won't get infected. Like you mentioned, you have to take away the attack vectors, as well as not doing stupid stuff like hitting file sharing sites, clicking on links in emails, etc.

Hence why I use EMET3.0 as its designed to work against zero day stuff. Works really well with MSSE.

Exactly. What most people seem to fail to understand is that if you take away the avenue of infection on your PC (java, adobe products, unpatched OS or other software, adding safeguards like EMET 3.0) then your AV, while still important, becomes nowhere near as important.
 
The thing that really annoys me about MS is that they have lots of security built into Windows.

But......they never switch any of it on by default.

DEP/ASLR/SEHOP/Admin/User accounts etc. etc. All left switched off or set to dangerous defaults.

It's quite bizarre.
 
truth.jpg


looks like Facebook might put the final nail in Skype aswell with their new calling feature. Why MS didn't really do anything with Skype, beyond maintaining it, is baffling. It's like they buy up/create tech... feel it's 'good enough' and lets it stagnate. Then another company comes along, does it better and makes MS's product obsolete.

And then you have the flip side where they come up with great ideas/products, release them in a halfassed state and then wonder why it doesn't succeed.

As someone that used to be a MS fanboy... I have a lot of contempt for the company as of late.
Unlikely, there are plenty of people who use Skype who wouldn't use the Facebook app. Not sure what everyone wants Skype to do that it doesn't currently. It works on nearly every smartphone, allows international calling free, allows small groups to conference seamlessly, has great business features for small business, the list goes on.

Facebook has... requires a Facebook account... yea no thanks.
 
The thing that really annoys me about MS is that they have lots of security built into Windows.

But......they never switch any of it on by default.

DEP/ASLR/SEHOP/Admin/User accounts etc. etc. All left switched off or set to dangerous defaults.

It's quite bizarre.
Remember how much people complained when UAC was introduced? The average Joe, who is MS's bread and butter, doesn''t give a crap about security features. They only care if they get infected, and even then may not notice (if the virus is good enough). You're thinking like a geek, not a businessman.
People think it's "more likely" that someone at AV-TEST.ORG is getting paid off, than it is that MSE just isn't as good as paid for products that are made by companies who are dedicated exclusively to antivirus?

Get real...
Don't get defensive. It's more in the criteria of their testing and how it's presented.
 
Remember how much people complained when UAC was introduced? The average Joe, who is MS's bread and butter, doesn''t give a crap about security features. They only care if they get infected, and even then may not notice (if the virus is good enough). You're thinking like a geek, not a businessman.

Well I don't think that if they switched on DEP/ASLR/SEHOP by default and it stopped some shareware from 1998 from working they should worry about it.

Oh and Mac users seem to be able to handle user privileges okay and they aren't the brightest of users (on the whole).

Time to have some balls in areas that really count other than the UI.
 
Back
Top