You are giing examples of this day and that day, but how about they get the password database on day 92, and they take 7 days, they'd still have tons of time left to cause chaos. It sounds good but ultimately flawed at the end of the day. With a 15 second delay, it'd take much longer to brute force a password. Any 10 character password would take ages to try to brute force through. if the password file is stolen, hopefully the admin wasn't dumb enough to have it as plain txt but encrypted, which would still take a long time even if there was no limit. But you're right, it won't help if someone manages to get through, but how often do people really change their passwords? They usually add a 1 or change a number. Has that really helped?