Memtest86 no longer valid for ASUS?

pbj75

Limp Gawd
Joined
Sep 30, 2003
Messages
208
I posted a while ago about my dead MB. During the course of troubleshooting, I talked with ASUS technical support. According to them, Memtest86 is no longer a recommended troubleshooting tool to check for memory failures with ASUS MBs. According to ASUS, Memtest86 has a high false error reporting rate. When I asked for alternatives, they had none. The tech said they have "something" in Taiwan, but not elsewhere.

Naturally, my next question was how is someone with an ASUS MB going to check for memory failures? His answer : "Yeah, it's a problem".

I apologize if this topic has already been raised, but since search is off, I couldn't check.

Anyone else run across this?
How are ASUS MB owners supposed to troubleshoot memory problems?
 
I have 3 Asus motherboards that I've used Memtest86 on and never had any issues at all. No false errors and no related issues to having bad RAM not caught by Memtest. That guy could have just had a personal grudge against it and it may not have been Asus' official stance on the program.
 
Thanks for the MS pointer. Will have to check it out.

tdg, I had used memtest86 with my old ASUS A7V with nary a problem. I even used it with the P4C800 when I first built it, just to be sure all was well. Memtest86 has always worked well for me.

The tech was pretty cool. When I said Memtest86 had worked fine when I first built the machine, and now it didn't, he immediately recommended I RMA it.

Nonetheless, he did say this was a new thing and it leaves them in a lurch as far as memory troubleshooting.
 
That decision could have come from someone in the business/marketing area, not an engineer. Maybe they just don't want to officially support a diagnostic tool that they have no control over.
 
First off software memory testers are *NOT* totally accurate anyway. A hardware memory tester is the only way to really check ram conclusively.
 
Back
Top