Megaupload Users Should Sue Megaupload

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
I'm not a legal expert but, according to the law, isn't this the way things are normally done in these situations? Wouldn't the customer have to take action against the business owner? Any legal experts out there know what the procedure is for something like this?

The U.S. Government says it’s in no way responsible for the millions of Megaupload users who have lost access to their files due to the criminal proceedings against the file-sharing site. Responding to a motion from one of the site’s users, the Government explains that no “irreparable harm” has been done. Instead of targeting the Government, disadvantaged users should sue Megaupload or its hosting company Carpathia for damages.
 
"What's that? You want your that was invested into this ponzi scheme? Well too bad it's evidence now and you can't have it."

10 years later..

"We are proud to announce that the jury has found the defendant guilty on all counts. The money will be released to all victims shortly."

5 more years later..

"What money?"

imagesarc-covenant-crates-01-small.jpg

Good 'ol US Justice.
 
Raiders of the Lost Ark lol well done.

This is not a surprise. The US Government says one thing and does another. Welcome to the era of the endless Patriot Act fellow Citizens :(
 
except....megauploads and carpathia did it under legal orders from the US govt....and we've yet again, come full-circle...oh...gotta love legal musical chairs.

anyone remember that fiasco about AT&T and wiretapping under NSA orders?
 
Actually, by law, the users are supposed to sue MegaUpload because the agreement for holding their content was made with them, not the US Government. MegaUpload is supposed to then sue the US government itself to reclaim the money it lost from the user's lawsuit.

It's to prevent the "Passing the Buck" strategy many companies have used in the past to keep lawsuits in limbo.
 
True story:

Some jackass stole the stereo out of my wife's truck in our driveway. He then sells it at the local shady pawn shop. Pawn shop eventually busted for knowingly buying stolen goods. Cops call us, let us know they have our stereo....


....BUT.....


...wait for it....

...it was evidence so we couldn't get it back until the case was resolved.

I know this is the case many times when it comes to someone else busted with your belongings so I was just wondering if the Megaupload case was the same.
 
True story:

Some jackass stole the stereo out of my wife's truck in our driveway. He then sells it at the local shady pawn shop. Pawn shop eventually busted for knowingly buying stolen goods. Cops call us, let us know they have our stereo....


....BUT.....


...wait for it....

...it was evidence so we couldn't get it back until the case was resolved.

I know this is the case many times when it comes to someone else busted with your belongings so I was just wondering if the Megaupload case was the same.

When the courts remand your stereo back to you they no longer have that evidence. In the case of digital property the court can retain a full bit for bit copy of your data to use as evidence should they need to. It's as simple as copy/paste.

It's harder to make an identical copy of hardware.
 
When the courts remand your stereo back to you they no longer have that evidence. In the case of digital property the court can retain a full bit for bit copy of your data to use as evidence should they need to. It's as simple as copy/paste.

It's harder to make an identical copy of hardware.

This.
 
When the courts remand your stereo back to you they no longer have that evidence. In the case of digital property the court can retain a full bit for bit copy of your data to use as evidence should they need to. It's as simple as copy/paste.

It's harder to make an identical copy of hardware.

This goes beyond duplicating, the DOJ just doesn't want to be in hotter waters if most of the media released is copywrited material. It really just means they are too lazy to go through all of it and they rather seal away all the data in a box and keep it under lock and key for the next 15 years until it's sent to archives and then incinerated 25 years later.
 
Well, with all the time I wasted downloading .rar.part1 files only to find that .rar.part3 was taken down before I could download it, there's the argument that my time could have been spent downloading pr0n from a website that doesn't leave it's non-paying un-registered users hanging. Not to mention the time my employer paid me to waste downloading said .rar parts.
 
My question is; could those who had legitimate data on Megauploads sue the gov for copyright infringement? They didnt just take the hard drives but made a duplicate copy of the data. depending on what the warrent said......
 
My question is; could those who had legitimate data on Megauploads sue the gov for copyright infringement? They didnt just take the hard drives but made a duplicate copy of the data. depending on what the warrent said......

The Gov't isn't making a profit, so that wouldn't apply.
 
Something tells me this may hurt the future trillion dollar cloud storage industry, unless somehow justice is done and the gov learns its lesson.
 
And now no doubt a rich @$$h013. I'm sure the pocket he lives in is nice and comfy.

Of course. Doesn't make him any less of an asshole though. However we all got to watch as the most important Bill of his career failed spectacularly thanks to the public movement against it.

Made my year really :D
 
Yeah because I'm sure that'd be practical :p

Oh trust me, DOJ employees get paid to do things much more tedious than that. Most can be weeded out easily with software to at least get the bulk of it. Wouldn't be hard to just give all users access back to their files and then screen IP's for illegal material. I doubt most people will come back to download a 40 split rar of some movie from 2010.
 
Back
Top