Man Charged In 'Virtual Porn' Case

Again, how was anyone harmed by what he was doing?


How were children harmed by what he was doing?

A drawing or photoshopped image of this sort is disgusting, but no one was harmed by its creation.



We're defending justice, freedom of speech, privacy, and rationality.

You're defending some undefinable sense of moral superiority.

It's not a sense of moral superiority. If you don't see how allowing someone to create imitation child pornography is bad, wrong, immoral and harmful to minors I can't help you. Good luck with these arguments in regular society- as in outside quasi-intellectual college circles and internet chat rooms.
 
Are you serious? Like, seriously- are you f@#$ing serious?!? Did you just reduce this debate to a poorly-argued sarcastic comment trying to tie people that hate gays with people that don't like child pornography?

No. I actually don't like gays. I think it's a disgusting practice. Is it illegal to be gay? No. Is it illegal to be a pedophile? No.

So what is illegal?
Owning child pornography.
Why?
Because it supports the child pornography industry when you buy it. (Although I don't see much wrong with it if it is gotten by without spending money. The law disagrees but whatever.)

Having sex with a child.
Why?
Even if it is wanted by both parties and no physical harm is done to the child, it isn't good for the child's developed and hence is illegal.

It sickens me that there are perverts on here justifying a man photoshopping a minor's face on to a nude body. It's wrong- its disgusting and its perverted- it means the guy is fantasizing or advocating the idea of having sex with minors! Are you people for real?
There's more perverted stuff out there. Also, are you suggesting video games advocate violence as well? Also, you remember Rapelay right? The game was out for 2 years and sold in several online retailers(you could get it off amazon.com). Then some feminazi came along, started crying("RAPE IS WRONG!!"), and amazon and the rest took the game off its shelves. The game was a 3d sex (or rape if you want to call it that)simulator that allowed you to have sex with a woman and her 2 daughters. One of the daughters was something like 12 years old.

If the man was allowed to do that legally, it would mean law enforcement would now have to determine what was real and what was not- meaning there would be an increased possibility of legitimate child porn not being detected in this process. And that would hurt children.
No, I don't think it would mean anything. It doesn't even look like child pornography, he was shopping faces onto adult bodies. I'm all for protecting the children but being some sort of frenzied zealot and arresting people that arn't even harming children isn't the way to do it. It's downright evil to arrest innocent people.
 
It's not a sense of moral superiority. If you don't see how allowing someone to create imitation child pornography is bad, wrong, immoral and harmful to minors I can't help you. Good luck with these arguments in regular society- as in outside quasi-intellectual college circles and internet chat rooms.

bad, wrong, immoral != criminal.

And again, how was what this guy was doing privately harmful to minors?
 
It's not a sense of moral superiority. If you don't see how allowing someone to create imitation child pornography is bad, wrong, immoral and harmful to minors I can't help you. Good luck with these arguments in regular society- as in outside quasi-intellectual college circles and internet chat rooms.

So basically from your logic:
A 12 year old head on a nude 70 body is child pornography


What about a 12 year old head on the body of a dog licking it's ball sac?

Fucked up and immoral? Definitely.
Illegal? Not a chance.
 
It's not a victimless crime you dolt!
The children in question were never photographed nude, nor were they taken advantage of. The photos that were used were average, every day, normal pictures. No victim there.

The adult bodies were taken from photos of women of consenting age. Obviously, no victim there either.

So you have two completely legal photos, but when you cut out the head from one and paste it on the other, the children are victims? How were they harmed exactly?
 
Normally I don't chime in just to say someone is wrong, but iansilv you are dead wrong in every point you half attempted to make.

and dolt ..... really you are going to actively use dolt. Are you fing kidding me.
 
No. I actually don't like gays. I think it's a disgusting practice. Is it illegal to be gay? No. Is it illegal to be a pedophile? No.

So what is illegal?
Owning child pornography.
Why?
Because it supports the child pornography industry when you buy it. (Although I don't see much wrong with it if it is gotten by without spending money. The law disagrees but whatever.)

Having sex with a child.
Why?
Even if it is wanted by both parties and no physical harm is done to the child, it isn't good for the child's developed and hence is illegal.


There's more perverted stuff out there. Also, are you suggesting video games advocate violence as well? Also, you remember Rapelay right? The game was out for 2 years and sold in several online retailers(you could get it off amazon.com). Then some feminazi came along, started crying("RAPE IS WRONG!!"), and amazon and the rest took the game off its shelves. The game was a 3d sex (or rape if you want to call it that)simulator that allowed you to have sex with a woman and her 2 daughters. One of the daughters was something like 12 years old.


No, I don't think it would mean anything. It doesn't even look like child pornography, he was shopping faces onto adult bodies. I'm all for protecting the children but being some sort of frenzied zealot and arresting people that arn't even harming children isn't the way to do it. It's downright evil to arrest innocent people.

Fair enough. You make some good points- but I add Production of Child Pornography to the above two points you mention or obvious reasons. And the difference I make with most of the viewpoints here is that the production of simulated child pornography is the same because the intent of the law is to protect children- and any sort of expression of the perverted need to produce child pornography cannot be tolerated for a range of reasons from a slippery slope argument to the argument that it actively promotes the endangerment of children.
 
Fair enough. You make some good points- but I add Production of Child Pornography to the above two points you mention or obvious reasons. And the difference I make with most of the viewpoints here is that the production of simulated child pornography is the same because the intent of the law is to protect children- and any sort of expression of the perverted need to produce child pornography cannot be tolerated for a range of reasons from a slippery slope argument to the argument that it actively promotes the endangerment of children.

You can reverse the slippery slope arguement and talk about the erosion of freedoms, too, you know. In order to live in a free society, you have to be able to talerate some injustice and moral abiguity. In my opinion, this case is too much like an Orwellian thought crime. He hasn't harmed anyone.

If you fantasize about killing someone you hate, is that a crime? NO. If you photoshop their face on a murdered corpse, is that a crime? NO.

/discussion.
 
You can reverse the slippery slope arguement and talk about the erosion of freedoms, too, you know. In order to live in a free society, you have to be able to talerate some injustice and moral abiguity. In my opinion, this case is too much like an Orwellian thought crime. He hasn't harmed anyone.

If you fantasize about killing someone you hate, is that a crime? NO. If you photoshop their face on a murdered corpse, is that a crime? NO.

/discussion.

you and your logic can go fornicate yourself with a soldering iron.

this is the interbutts, there's no logic allowed here.











































p.s. nature is amoral, which automatically nullifies anything you mention in regards to morality. considering morality is a creation of society.
 
you and your logic can go fornicate yourself with a soldering iron.

this is the interbutts, there's no logic allowed here.

p.s. nature is amoral, which automatically nullifies anything you mention in regards to morality. considering morality is a creation of society.

LOL. Nice. I agree morality is a creation of society, but that just affirms that in order to maintain a free country, you must tolerate at least some "morally questionable" behavior.

And to cut off the god-freaks before they bite my head off: It doesn't matter where morality comes from, in order to maintain a truly libertarian state, the state cannot, by definition, be allowed to enforce every moral tresspass. There have to be limits.
 
OK- so you're arguing that photoshopping is easy to spot and pedophiles have discriminating tastes. Yeah- right- FALSE Dietrich, and not even worth addressing.

I am not arguing that pedophiles have discriminating tastes, I'm arguing that they are pedophiles. Adult nudity isn't something that works for them. That's the very definition of their mental illness. Pedophiles would find a child's head glued on an adult body repulsive. That's just a simple fact. Whoever gets off on that sort of stuff is a freak, but not a pedophile, and it certainly isn't illegal.

It's not a sense of moral superiority. If you don't see how allowing someone to create imitation child pornography is bad, wrong, immoral and harmful to minors I can't help you. Good luck with these arguments in regular society- as in outside quasi-intellectual college circles and internet chat rooms.

In other words "Good luck with those arguments amongst the ignorant masses."

I don't care what the ignorant and reactionary religious masses think. I'm not going to stand by silently while the freedom to express ourselves is eroded away one thing at a time. Sure, this time it's just some freak making weird porn, but every time they get more strict the line moves a little further. Maybe in 10 years porn won't be allowed at all. Then maybe violence won't be allowed to be depicted at all.

Fair enough. You make some good points- but I add Production of Child Pornography to the above two points you mention or obvious reasons. And the difference I make with most of the viewpoints here is that the production of simulated child pornography is the same because the intent of the law is to protect children- and any sort of expression of the perverted need to produce child pornography cannot be tolerated for a range of reasons from a slippery slope argument to the argument that it actively promotes the endangerment of children.

It most certainly does not promote the endangerment of children. No child is even involved in the production of the porn. If someone is using a publicly available image of some kid and photoshopping it, they can do whatever they want with it in my opinion.

The fact is, you have no idea what pedophilia is. You prove it with each post. A pedophile would simply not be aroused by the pictures in question. It doesn't promote any real-life action either, because the subject of their arousal DOES NOT EXIST IN REAL LIFE.
 
Are you serious? Like, seriously- are you f@#$ing serious?!? Did you just reduce this debate to a poorly-argued sarcastic comment trying to tie people that hate gays with people that don't like child pornography? CHILD PORNOGRAPHY IS ILLEGAL AND MADE ILLEGAL OUT OF A DESIRE TO PROTECT CHILDREN!

Let me stop you right there: There's nothing in the article that suggests this is child pornography. Naked Children != child pornography (never mind that there are no naked children.

It sickens me that there are perverts on here justifying a man photoshopping a minor's face on to a nude body. It's wrong- its disgusting and its perverted- it means the guy is fantasizing or advocating the idea of having sex with minors! Are you people for real?

Or it could mean the guy thought it was funny. It could be artistic expression. It's by no means pornographic, unless explicit sexual acts are depicted (and the article never said that there were).

I'm going to go ahead and go on record here as saying photoshopping a minor's face on to a nude adult body is child pornography. The intention of the act is to produce the image of a nude child for sexual gratification. And that is illegal. And for the dumbasses on this forum that don't understand complex concepts like legal intent- here it is for you spelled out:

So you also believe that if I Photoshop a beagles head on the body of a naked man or a woman I'm promoting bestiality? Sounds like a leap.
 
It's not a sense of moral superiority. If you don't see how allowing someone to create imitation child pornography is bad, wrong, immoral and harmful to minors I can't help you. Good luck with these arguments in regular society- as in outside quasi-intellectual college circles and internet chat rooms.

And if you can't understand that what you want fundamentally violates the first amendment, then you can't be helped.

Pictures of nude children are not in and of themselves illegal, whether they have tits and pubes or not.
 
I am not arguing that pedophiles have discriminating tastes, I'm arguing that they are pedophiles. Adult nudity isn't something that works for them. That's the very definition of their mental illness. Pedophiles would find a child's head glued on an adult body repulsive. That's just a simple fact. Whoever gets off on that sort of stuff is a freak, but not a pedophile, and it certainly isn't illegal.

Man, I hope everyone finds that repulsive... seriously... that would probably seem so disproportionate that...... just ugh.

Anyway, if they do this, what next? Arrest an actor playing a rape scene because the female character didn't want it?
 
I am not arguing that pedophiles have discriminating tastes, I'm arguing that they are pedophiles. Adult nudity isn't something that works for them. That's the very definition of their mental illness. Pedophiles would find a child's head glued on an adult body repulsive. That's just a simple fact. Whoever gets off on that sort of stuff is a freak, but not a pedophile, and it certainly isn't illegal.

From what I understand most pedophiles like both children and adults.
 
Man, I hope everyone finds that repulsive... seriously... that would probably seem so disproportionate that...... just ugh.

Anyway, if they do this, what next? Arrest an actor playing a rape scene because the female character didn't want it?

you sir, have 100 internets. :D
 
The only thing I feel he should be jailed for is getting hard over Miley Cyrus.

This is Fact. Next to her singing her face is her worst feature ruining good porn with it should be outlawed.

And 16 is legal enough if she is hot and looks 18 so they are probably just concerned about the other little girls.
 
Wow. You can go to jail for drawing a picture? Ok.
If you draw a naked girl, draw her ID proving she is 18. If the thought police can prove the ID is a fake, they have to arrest the drawing. It's a minor with a fake ID. or at the least, write her a ticket.
Then the universe explodes to the sound of a greasy fart.
The End.
 
Back
Top