MacBook Pro Gets Back Its Firewire Port

Terry Olaes

I Used to be the [H] News Guy
2FA
Joined
Nov 27, 2006
Messages
4,646
Apple fans that lamented the removal of their beloved Firewire port will be happy to know that the upcoming MacBook Pro, revealed at WWDC this week, will bring the port back. Not only is the port back but it’s faster too, having been upgraded from FW400 to FW800. Huzzah!

When it killed FireWire on the 13-inch MacBook last year it made lots of folks very angry, but Steve Jobs himself apparently thought it was not a big deal. And so did I. In fact, I thought that other Macs would begin to lose their FireWire. I was wrong.
 
Battery life on the new 15" is what really has me interested. According to Anand, Apple was actually being a little conservative with the 7 hour claims on their website: http://anandtech.com/mac/showdoc.aspx?i=3580&p=4

This is all on top of the already superior battery life the MBP already had before: http://www.anandtech.com/mobile/showdoc.aspx?i=3540&p=10

There’s no other way to say this. If you care about battery life and portability at all, buy the new MacBook Pro. Go to the Apple store and buy one. While I only tested the 15” model, I’m guessing the 13” model should leave a similar lasting impression.

Ever since I first looked at the power consumption specs of Nehalem I thought it didn’t make any sense to buy a new, expensive notebook before Arrandale’s launch in Q4 2009/Q1 2010. While performance will definitely increase considerably with Arrandale, Apple just threw a huge wrench in my recommendation. The new MacBook Pro is near perfect today. If you need a new laptop now, thanks to its incredible battery life, I have no qualms recommending the new MBP.

All that said, I like holding onto my hardware for at least two years. My MBP is blazing fast in OS X and if I do boot into Windows 7 for gaming it runs TF2 and L4D great. I'll hold off until Allendale hits next year, maybe even a little longer, but if we're talking about the lowered price point with the same battery life and greater performance, my next MBP will be a beast (well, unless I decide to get a MBA instead :) ).
 
Yeah, it never made sense to me why they initially ditched Firewire in the 13" Macbook, partly because FW is better than USB 2.0, and partly because FW is Apple's own standard. IMO they made several big mistakes with the 13" aluminum Macbook launch in January.

- No Firewire (duh)

- An inferior LCD panel compared to the same size Macbook Air. It looked terrible compared to the other aluminum body Macbook Pro and Air models.

- Entry level price that was way above the previous entry level "Macbook". There was entry level 13" aluminum body Macbook with this huge price/feature/performance gap between it and the white plastic Macbook. It didn't fit the pro market because it was missing features like FW and had this crummy screen, and at the same time it was too expensive for the consumer market because of the enclosure, the trackpad, the trackpad, etc.

It was neither here nor there, terrible, I couldn't recommend it over the 15" MBP or MBA to anybody.

Now it has Firewire, the better 13" LCD panel from the MBA (IMO this finally makes the 13" model an actual alternative to the 15" MBP for pro users), and a much lower entry level price with all of the MBP level features included (multitouch trackpad, blacklit keyboard, ambient light sensor, uber battery, etc etc).

They're now calling it a "Macbook Pro" but the price fits much more in line with what Macbooks traditionally were, pretty cool. It'll be even cooler when they eventually drop in price again and completely eliminate the white plastic model.
 
You say what everyone is thinking. ;)

The funny thing is that many cheap $300-$400 hackbook clones have always had firewire.

Firewire 800?

Heh, eSata is actually better ...

But with only two USB ports the firewire was definitely nice to have for that video camera or external hard drive. I'm glad it's back, and now a la 800 speed. Still, it would've been more forward thinking to do eSata instead. So many new hard disk and flash memory camcorders simply use USB only these days. Putting firewire back on caters to a much smaller audience now - people with older (or cheaper) MiniDV camcorders with the firewire interface, and these people will be less likely to actually buy the new Macbooks one: because they are cheap and bought the cheapest camcorder or are keeping their old one as long as possible, or two: they have high end stuff and already have a higher end computer for doing their editing - higher end than any of the new cheaper Macbooks.

I see more mainstream hard drives going out with the eSata interface. So many desktops and laptops already have eSata, and the performance is still better than firewire 800, obviously. The SATA controller also better matches your internal components. It just seems more useful and universal.

Still, I complained when they took it off and replaced it with nothing! At least it's back now, and improved. I just don't see people buying that many externals with firewire now, or as time goes on.

The addition of the SD card is so characteristically un-Apple. Even though SD has been the mainstream memory card standard for years now, Apple generally takes the "efff the effing customer" stance, best quoted in the Disney movie Cars:

"You don't know what you want, [Apple] know what you want! SD card readers blend into all the other laptops, but NO card reader and lots of shiny metal says here I am. Look at me. LOVE me!!!"

Apple has been doing that routine for so long. Still we get no HDMI and no eSata. Why do they purposefully remain so uncompatible? I mean, making them nicer - great! Making them look awesome? Great! Making them run really well? That's always important ... but why not make them as usable as possible? They went all out on making the stupid and ridiculously cheap iPod touch way more usable than I expected (with the single exception of no flash support.) When it was released it seriously ran circles around the competition offering more memory, a smoother quicker interface, wi-fi, email and other great features and performance, at the same or lower cost than anything out at the time that would be able to pull of those same tasks (and with much less fluidity.)

Why not do that with their computers? Oh well. This is a HUGE improvement. They are bringing some real competition to the table. People can quote raw hardware specs and price compare, but $1200 for a 2.24GHz 45nm C2D, LED screen (a really nice one now), SEVEN hours of battery life (holy CRAP), backlit keyboard, bluetooth, dvd burner, wireless n, full aluminum and very slim chassis, the 9400GT .... these features for $1200 in such a nice package definitely stick it to the competition on just an overall feel and presentation. We'll see how they turn out reliability wise her in the next few ...
 
I actually had a man ask me for a firewire cable at work today, and he stated it was for his brand new mac. I'm pretty sure I gave him a funny look when he asked for the cable lol.
 
The addition of the SD card is so characteristically un-Apple. Even though SD has been the mainstream memory card standard for years now.

I agree, it was very nice to see. The other cool thing about the SD card slot is that you can use it as a drive to boot off an OS off of. Now there's speculation that Apple is using this as a first step to kill off distributing their own software on DVD, much like they did with floppies over ten years ago. Crazy speculation and it would take a while for a complete conversion, but it would be cool if it happened. You'd have huge amounts of storage space on a very common format for very little money, and it would continue to reduce the already low size, weight, and power consumption of their notebooks.

This is a HUGE improvement. They are bringing some real competition to the table. People can quote raw hardware specs and price compare, but $1200 for a 2.24GHz 45nm C2D, LED screen (a really nice one now), SEVEN hours of battery life (holy CRAP), backlit keyboard, bluetooth, dvd burner, wireless n, full aluminum and very slim chassis, the 9400GT .... these features for $1200 in such a nice package definitely stick it to the competition on just an overall feel and presentation. We'll see how they turn out reliability wise her in the next few ...

You forgot the best trackpad out there. :)

I've always felt that Macbook Pros have been worth the price of entry for their keyboards, displays, and multitouch trackpads. Even if I was only running Windows I would still use a Macbook since the Boot Camp drivers support most multitouch functions on it. The fact that all of those features are now available at that price (plus all that battery life) makes them beyond a no-brainer for me.
 
It was silly to ditch FW back then. Even though there really aren't that much of use for it, because there are usually also other alternatives. But the thing is that at those new prices, compared with the hardware, features and the whole package, you actually get a really nice deal.
 
yep its uber baddass plus you can get a free printer and ipod touch aftere rebate and get a $100 off via student discount!
looks like i mite be trading up my macbook air
 
Our blatant "haters" are surprisingly quiet on this thread. Come on guys, it's actually kind of eerie. ... :(

Anyways, I didn't forget the trackpad, as it was on the first gen aluminum 13" books. I actually am not quite as sold on it as I used to. I like the gestures, and I was most impressed by the integrated clicking ability, but after using one for a long time, I noticed it took more effort to click than regular trackpad or mouse buttons. I wish it was a little easier to push, even at the increased risk of accidental clicks. Regardless, the gestures are awesome. That's how zooming and scrolling should be done on every trackpad. Dang patents, anyways ...
 
Our blatant "haters" are surprisingly quiet on this thread. Come on guys, it's actually kind of eerie. ... :(

Its hard to hate in a thread that gives you no ammunition. No, they're still complaining about cut/copy/paste on the iPhone (which lots of people are using right now and everyone else will be getting in a few days), some random security plug that periodically pops up and promptly gets plugged (just like every other OS out there), or some random story that was made irrelevant ages ago but is still incontrovertible proof that Apple = evil.

You're right though, it is quiet, same dead silence when they announced OS 10.6 would be launching with massive under-the-hood improvements (OpenCL, Grand Central, 6GB smaller footprint, 64-bit OS from top to bottom) for only $30...
 
Its hard to hate in a thread that gives you no ammunition. No, they're still complaining about cut/copy/paste on the iPhone (which lots of people are using right now and everyone else will be getting in a few days), some random security plug that periodically pops up and promptly gets plugged (just like every other OS out there), or some random story that was made irrelevant ages ago but is still incontrovertible proof that Apple = evil.

You're right though, it is quiet, same dead silence when they announced OS 10.6 would be launching with massive under-the-hood improvements (OpenCL, Grand Central, 6GB smaller footprint, 64-bit OS from top to bottom) for only $30...

There's plenty of ammo. Firewire??? Never used it or had the need to. I've never even owned an external HD, although I am getting close to needing one. I have eSATA for that though.
 
Its hard to hate in a thread that gives you no ammunition. No, they're still complaining about cut/copy/paste on the iPhone (which lots of people are using right now and everyone else will be getting in a few days), some random security plug that periodically pops up and promptly gets plugged (just like every other OS out there), or some random story that was made irrelevant ages ago but is still incontrovertible proof that Apple = evil.

You're right though, it is quiet, same dead silence when they announced OS 10.6 would be launching with massive under-the-hood improvements (OpenCL, Grand Central, 6GB smaller footprint, 64-bit OS from top to bottom) for only $30...

Cheapest price Apple's ever had on a service pack. :D

There's plenty of ammo. Firewire??? Never used it or had the need to. I've never even owned an external HD, although I am getting close to needing one. I have eSATA for that though.

spoke too soon ... knew it! Lolz.
 
Cheapest price Apple's ever had on a service pack. :D

Waka waka waka! :D

I know you're (semi)joking but man does this argument get old. 10.3 to 10.4 and 10.4 to 10.5 were bigger under the hood and UI improvements than the move from XP to Vista or especially the move from Vista to Win7. 10.2 to 10.3 was nice but not nearly as big a move in comparison.

As for 10.6, I'd hardly call a top to bottom application rewrite for 64 bit, easier development for multicore, GPU processing, and a 6GB smaller HD footprint a simple service pack. Its way beyond a bugfix rollup. About the only significant new feature I've ever seen in a Windows service pack was the necessary new security model they added into Windows XP SP2.

Oh, and USB 2 in SP1, that was nice. :rolleyes: :)

spoke too soon ... knew it! Lolz.

I know, they add something back and its a negative! People on the internet will complain about anything.

/me looks over at his four external backup drives. No, I'm not paranoid... :eek:
 
The argument about Windows service packs vs. Apple software updates is a very old one, indeed. I was mostly joking, but keep in mind that the comparison is so subjective, and they really are simply employing two different pricing/update structures, each with its positives and negatives. For example:

Apple way benefits:

Simpler - one version only
Initial cost - lower than all but the most basic or OEM versions of Windows

Windows way benefits:

More sweeping updates for free - there have been a few service backs that added nearly as much performance, stability, features, and compatibility as some of the Apple major paid updates - and definitely if you combine 2 service packs together (which is still free).

Scaleable - versions that fit the user, based on needs, and a price that scales with the included features


Some will argue for one while others will argue for the other. I'm just glad that this new update is only $29. Leopard added a slew of features to the table, several of which I frequently use and love. Those came (at least to my system) at the cost of a noticeable amount of performance and stability. Tiger was so much more rock-like stable than Leopard has ever been, and the performance and stability enhancements that Snow Leopard brings back will definitely be worth the $29 to me!!
 
I know, they add something back and its a negative! People on the internet will complain about anything.

/me looks over at his four external backup drives. No, I'm not paranoid... :eek:

Nah, I wasn't being negative. Just saying I have no use, and never have, for Firewire. My 4 drives are internal and if I do ever get an external it will be eSATA.
 
i'd be about as devastated about losing the firewire port as i'd be losing the floppy port on my motherboard... somewhere between dont give a fuck and couldnt give a shit
 
More sweeping updates for free - there have been a few service backs that added nearly as much performance, stability, features, and compatibility as some of the Apple major paid updates - and definitely if you combine 2 service packs together (which is still free).

Major security updates, patch rollups, support for larger hard drives and USB, .NET updates, these are the main things I associate with Windows service packs. I just can't put them on the same level. If we're talking about major window and workspace management improvements, its been an eight year gap between the standards set in XP and what we're finally seeing in Windows 7 (I love the new function where you drag a title bar to the side of the screen and it resizes the window to take up half the desktop, very very handy).

Some will argue for one while others will argue for the other. I'm just glad that this new update is only $29. Leopard added a slew of features to the table, several of which I frequently use and love. Those came (at least to my system) at the cost of a noticeable amount of performance and stability. Tiger was so much more rock-like stable than Leopard has ever been, and the performance and stability enhancements that Snow Leopard brings back will definitely be worth the $29 to me!!

Its funny, in a way Leopard was like Vista in terms of being a drag on performance for some customers. I didn't experience it at all with either OS since with Vista I upgraded from an Athlon 64 4400+ to my current Core 2 Duo E8400, and with Leopard I upgraded from a dual-1ghz G4 tower to my current 2.8ghz Core 2 Duo Extreme iMac. Whatever performance issues there were with either OS relative to the prior version was far outstripped by the additional horsepower I was using.

My only experience with multiple versions of OS X on the same hardware was with 10.2 through 10.4 on my old G4, and each update yielded a very noticeable boost in performance. Either way, I totally missed the speed issues with those latest OSes (well, aside from Vista's crummy file transfer speed), and I'm also looking forward to 10.6. An even faster computer for only $30? Yes please.
 
Nah, I wasn't being negative. Just saying I have no use, and never have, for Firewire. My 4 drives are internal and if I do ever get an external it will be eSATA.

I see, got it. I've been using external Firewire drives for seven years now, both desktop and portable for my laptop. My Final Cut folders are very important so I like to keep some separate for safe keeping.
 
Hard to hate it when they appear to price the thing competitively. I suppose the resolution seems low for a "professional" laptop....
 
Hard to hate it when they appear to price the thing competitively. I suppose the resolution seems low for a "professional" laptop....

1280x800 is fine on a 13.3 inch. I suppose they could've gone a tad higher on the 15", but some of the nicest 15.6" models "only" have 1600x900, and I believe this Macbook has the same vertical resolution of 900, but it's 16x10 instead of the newly (and hated by most enthusiasts) 16x9 ratio so many are using. 1440x900 is not unexpected, and is higher than most 15 inch widescreen laptops that are 16x10. The 17 inch has full 1920x1200, again the better (in my opinion) 16x10 ratio. Really nothing to complain about. The superior LED backlighting and impressive black screen are what really make it pro. Having used one, I can say the color gamut and black levels are quite impressive.

The more I look at what 1200 now brings, the more I want one .... wow.
 
1280x800 is fine on a 13.3 inch. I suppose they could've gone a tad higher on the 15", but some of the nicest 15.6" models "only" have 1600x900, and I believe this Macbook has the same vertical resolution of 900, but it's 16x10 instead of the newly (and hated by most enthusiasts) 16x9 ratio so many are using. 1440x900 is not unexpected, and is higher than most 15 inch widescreen laptops that are 16x10. The 17 inch has full 1920x1200, again the better (in my opinion) 16x10 ratio. Really nothing to complain about. The superior LED backlighting and impressive black screen are what really make it pro. Having used one, I can say the color gamut and black levels are quite impressive.

The more I look at what 1200 now brings, the more I want one .... wow.

I should have clarified that I was talking about the 15" model. I would have preferred a1680x1050 option for the15" screen, that's what I expect out of a 15". Screen real estate more important than battery life (what the LED backlight offers) to some.
 
Our blatant "haters" are surprisingly quiet on this thread. Come on guys, it's actually kind of eerie. ... :(

I will post the same complaint I always post.

Apple: Please create a desktop and laptop option that fits into the $500 market. And no, the Mac Mini doesn't count :mad:
 
I will post the same complaint I always post.

Apple: Please create a desktop and laptop option that fits into the $500 market. And no, the Mac Mini doesn't count :mad:

Mac Mini = 100% ripoff.

Dell and Asus have faster, much better spec'd, and more universally compatible versions that are just about as small, just as quiet, but have many more features such as built in HDMI, etc. The redeeming feature of the Mac Mini is the 9400GT. Not too many micro PCs in the Window arena offer that option, and the ones that do, likely carry a higher price tag for now like the mac.
 
Back
Top