Let's Play PC Games at 8K Resolution

What are people gaming on these days? 100" monitors? Seriously you don't even remotely benefit from 4k below 60", much less what sits on most desks.

To be fair people do usually sit MUCH closer to their PC monitor than a TV, so the difference does become noticeable at smaller screen sizes than it does on TVs. That being said even with an unlimited budget I would personally pick 1440p @ high refresh rate over 4K @ 60hz for gaming. The extra pixels above 1440p isn't a dramatic difference, but high refresh rate is.
 
Anyone else remember the days when 1280x1024 monitors came out and many people struggled to actually play games at that resolution because the hardware was barely able to (or physically limited to) render at 640x480, 800x600, or 1024x768? :D

Yep, it was 1998 and I was running 2 Voodoo 2's in SLI just to play Quake 2 at 1024x768 on a 100 pound 19" CRT monitor. And it was glorious! But my internet was still on dialup.

This 8K crap is 5 years away at least.
 
I see 8k as a pipe-dream for gaming for a few years yet. Yes, it will produce noticable sharpness, but if there isn't any detail in the textures, assets or effects to merrit the resolution, it would be like rendering N64 games at 1080p: they arguably look worse. Detail-per-pixel and smoothness of motion are far more important than pixel-pitch.
 
You need your eyes checked. :rolleyes:

No I don't. I've had my 24" 1080p 120hz monitor side by side with a 4k. There is a difference, but not large enough to justify the massive hike in computer hardware just to run it smoothly. The difference between my 52" 1080p TV and 65" 4k TV however is absolutely massive. 4k or higher on anything below 55" gets into serious diminishing returns for higher and higher hardware requirements. Running 4k on a sub 30" monitor is basically a waste, 8k would just be complete overkill and really just saying "I have more money than I know what to do with so, fuck it". Honestly there is a bigger picture quality difference between 1080p 30, 60 and 120hz than there is 4k.
 
Last edited:
Is it more detailed then a 1080p live action movie scene? Are the plant sprites better looking then individual foliage in real life?

a live action movie is effectively a downsample from infinity down to 1080p. With a computer game you're not starting at a source with infinite detail. apples and oranges.
 
8K is more about marketing going forward.
AMD will use it to showcase how Vega can do this due to using VRAM+System RAM and how Nvidia is limited while ignoring 8k has no relevence for 99% of consumers or the fact Nvidia does support UMA that is used beyond consumer environment.
TV manufacturers will go out of their way to show one need 8K even though we are still waiting for 4k content yet to become prevalent while ironically pushing HDR+4K as amazing and 'real life'.

I would want a great 4k+HDR over an ok 8K, it becomes a point of diminishing returns across both segments along with real world practicality.
Also games commonon denominator is usually consoles, and we will struggle to even see in the near future decent and implemented thoroughly 4k textures; game studios that added 4k textures afterwards for PCs are only token efforts.
Probably will standardise around 2k mark for awhile with regards to implemented throughout the game.
Cheers
 
Last edited:
I am in NO way saying he had anything to do with it but.... What's keeping people from orchestrating these things themselves? I would imagine his views/subs went up after his home was raided (live).. Going just a little bit bigger does seem like the next step. "hmm, I got away with it at home... I wonder if.." Again, NOT saying he faked/was responsible, but it seems a little too convenient. And if you DIDN'T have anything to do with it, then it may be time to look for another career.

a live action movie is effectively a downsample from infinity down to 1080p. With a computer game you're not starting at a source with infinite detail. apples and oranges.
4x. 4x looks pretty fucking good. We used to have it as a real option with options like TSAA from Nvidia and Adaptive AA from AMD before shaders broke all AA compatibility and replaced everything with spotty coverage from fake AA methods like FXAA and SMAA. So in order to have a pretty clean looking image, our only option now is essentially downsampling. In order to get 4x4 downsampling on a 1080 image, that's basically 8k resolutions. It's not quite that bad though, as you can have some more optimization tricks with native SSAA support, but that's only for the games you can get it running on.
 
The tests from that link are with 0% smoothing. That's going to look like ass using Nvidia's algorithm, mine was done with 20%.
You got me curious as I havent seen a difference in performance when changing the smoothness.
(This must be the reason for your post otherwise it has no point relevant to the discussion)

Yeah, no smoothing applied would make it run better but look terrible.

I ran 3 smoothness tests 3 times with the new TombRaider at 3840x2160 DSR with 1080p native.
They are in this order:
0%, 20%, 100% smoothness.

First run (should probably be discarded but included for completeness)
53.76fps, 53.96fps, 55.2fps

Second run
55.11fps, 54.77fps, 54.84fps

Third run
54.69fps, 55.44fps, 54.86fps

There is no correlation between smoothness and framerate with this game.
What was your method, was it a different game?
 
You got me curious as I havent seen a difference in performance when changing the smoothness.
(This must be the reason for your post otherwise it has no point relevant to the discussion)



I ran 3 smoothness tests 3 times with the new TombRaider at 3840x2160 DSR with 1080p native.
They are in this order:
0%, 20%, 100% smoothness.

First run (should probably be discarded but included for completeness)
53.76fps, 53.96fps, 55.2fps

Second run
55.11fps, 54.77fps, 54.84fps

Third run
54.69fps, 55.44fps, 54.86fps

There is no correlation between smoothness and framerate with this game.
What was your method, was it a different game?
I'm saying I did testing a while back and DSR was absolutely slower than raw downsampling at the same resolution. The smoothness was just a different variable I noticed that could be accounting for the slower performance. I haven't tested it in a while. Here's the full rundown for what it's worth:
-I was testing this back as soon as DSR came out.
-This was done on a Geforce 670 at the time, downsampling from 1440 to 1080.
-I was testing primarily Trackmania 2: Canyon, but also tested Sin: Episodes (I imagine any Source game would substitute)
-Done on Windows 7

It could be that the software is more optimized now or it's the Pascal architecture, or it could just be game dependent. In my experience, DSR was consistently slower, but granted, I haven't tested it recently.
 
That could be the reason.

I havent found a notable change in framerate using DSR vs true res.
And no difference changing smoothing.
Tests were performed on a few system setups over the last year and a bit with Maxwell and Pascal.
Also on Windows 7.
 
a live action movie is effectively a downsample from infinity down to 1080p. With a computer game you're not starting at a source with infinite detail. apples and oranges.

Sure, but how does enlarging the window fix that?

The analogy would be that a 4x6 picture from a camera would need to be 8x10 if done with CGI to be just as detailed.

The example I used was using sprites for grass and leaves in "high resolution" games as opposed to individual polygons. Raising the resolution doesn't fix that.

Is a computer game NOT infinite in source? Outside of higher resolution textures....a game should be able to represent a camera that is looking at something miles away.
 
Back
Top