Kentucky Senate: Computer Programming Satisfies Foreign-Language Requirement

Can't speak for Kentucky but since most schools around here only offer Spanish in high school I'm 100% for something like this. Now if there were actually useful choices such as Mandarin, Russian or even Hindi I might feel differently.

My high school offered Latin, French, Spanish, Russian, Mandarin, German and Arabic. Sadly we did not offer any programming classes...
 
In reality, all this does is let nerds get out of the language requirement. It will do nothing to increase the number of programmers Kentucky produces.

The only kids interested in this option were going to learn programming anyway.
 
In reality, all this does is let nerds get out of the language requirement. It will do nothing to increase the number of programmers Kentucky produces.
.
I don't know, take a class where you can get a computer (hey I know how to do that I facebook all day long!) vs. taking a class of a language that isn't 'mericun! Might see more people taking computer programming.

For the average person computer programming probably is about as useful as a foreign language so why the fuck not. The upside if you take computer programming you might be less of a retard when it comes to using a computer in general, and then in a generation or two time there will be no children or grandchildren who are the ones who have to help out their "noob" relatives with tech support!
 
we aren't talking about spanish speakers learning english but rather english speakers learning a second language.

and claiming that spanish as a second language in the current US climate is useless if an idiotic statement, at best.
Interesting how you're proven wrong, then completely misrepresent the other side, while totally moving the original bar. Bravo.

To recap: I was referencing a mostly bilingual segment of the population that speaks Spanish (and English), and specifically addressed your claim regarding the great economic return on speaking Spanish... the Spanish speakers represent one of the lowest economic brackets in the country, so clearly there is no direct relationship there to conclude Spanish is going to make you a lot of money (a big difference from "useless"). For the record, I took 3-years of Spanish, but then dropped it for Mandarin. Plus, asian girls > *. Its science.
 
Interesting how you're proven wrong, then completely misrepresent the other side, while totally moving the original bar. Bravo.

To recap: I was referencing a mostly bilingual segment of the population that speaks Spanish (and English), and specifically addressed your claim regarding the great economic return on speaking Spanish... the Spanish speakers represent one of the lowest economic brackets in the country, so clearly there is no direct relationship there to conclude Spanish is going to make you a lot of money (a big difference from "useless"). For the record, I took 3-years of Spanish, but then dropped it for Mandarin. Plus, asian girls > *. Its science.
seriously? no one is moving the bar. you just don't make much sense with your points...or at least aren't making them as clearly as you think you are.

you posted, for some unknown and irrelevant reason, a bar graph displaying income of various ethnic groups. you then tried to construct an argument from that data saying look at how little money spanish speakers make, therefore you won't make much money if you speak their language. that's a non-sequitor.

when we're talking about english speaking students learning a second language (that's not moving the bar, bud, that's the thread topic of what our US population should or should not be learning in US high schools...) and discussing economic relevance of a second language the criteria isn't how much various ethnic groups *earn* but rather job opportunities that would require a job seeker to speak the language.

that is, it doesn't matter how little or how much spanish speakers earn or how little or how much asian americans earn. what matters is what kinds of job opportunities are available to *serve* or *interact* with those communities. Unless, of course, you think the only opportunities are working directly *for* those ethnic groups.

Your argument boils down to asians are wealthier, on average, than mexicans (or hispanics) so therefore you should learn mandarin! I don't know if you're being intentionally silly but that is a ridiculous argument.

if you want to work in a hospital, or mental health, or a school district, or any government office nearly anywhere in the US, having spanish as a second language will be either a strong benefit or requirement. Speaking mandarin will come in useful if you want to work in international business...and that's it. if you work in welfare you can list on your application that you are fluent in mandarin but it won't get you hired instead of the person listing spanish on their resume.

your argument is a continuation of the equally silly argument that primarily Spanish speaking countries aren't economic powerhouses so who cares about Spanish as a second language.

That's why I pointed out to that person that I can't imagine where he or she lives that would enable him to ignore the fact that if you want a job, damn near any job interacting with our population, you will be greatly benefitted by the ability to speak Spanish.

So you learned mandarin? that's great. instead of posting irrelevant graphs about relative wealth by ethnic groups try explaining to us how many jobs you've gotten on the basis that you can understand mandarin. do a quick search in your job sector and post the results here of the listings asking for Mandarin speaking applicants. then do yourself a favor and do the same search for job listing asking for spanish speakers.

as I said, unless you are talking about international business or law, mandarin as a second language will be a better option than spanish exactly never.
 
Speaking mandarin will come in useful if you want to work in international business...and that's it. if you work in welfare you can list on your application that you are fluent in mandarin but it won't get you hired instead of the person listing spanish on their resume.
Well, we seem to agree actually. Yes, if you want to work in welfare then sure you can put that you speak Ebonics and Spanish and have all your bases covered. I think there's more money in international business though. :p

But back on topic, programming is probably better than either option.
 
Well, we seem to agree actually. Yes, if you want to work in welfare then sure you can put that you speak Ebonics and Spanish and have all your bases covered. I think there's more money in international business though. :p

But back on topic, programming is probably better than either option.
the problem is that jobs related to those two fields: programming and business, are shrinking in this country. service jobs are growing. so if we're talking about things like teaching someone how to think in procedural terms then we would prioritize computer programming. but if we were prioritizing vocational applicability (not which job pays the most even though only a few jobs exist, but rather which skillset has the broadest applicability in order to best safeguard a job *at all* post-graduation) then we'd say foreign languages...and spanish would be the first choice. unless, as I stated earlier, you have a very specific goal in mind. if you want to work for the feds you'd want to learn arabic. business/international law mandarin (keeping in mind it wouldn't be mandatory because anyone at that level speaks english anyway), and for any kind of social welfare career, any kind of blue collar criminal job path, and that's what's available to most of our high school graduates, is going to benefit by having spanish over mandarin, any other language, and programming.
 
*any kind of blue collar or criminal justice job path
 
While I agree that computer programming would be a good class to be required, I think a larger focus to get all students prepared to take calculus their first semester of college. If the student can do more, great. Instead of teaching computer programming, instead teaching logic and algorithm problem solving that is less connected to any one single programming language.
 
Back
Top