iPhone 5 Rated 5th In User Satisfaction

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
How can the iPhone 5 be 5th in user satisfaction? Obviously this survey is flawed and they are just trying to make Apple look bad.

Conducted by mobile research firm OnDevice Research, the poll asked 320,000 smartphone and tablet users in six countries how satisfied they were with their devices. Among the 93,825 people surveyed in the U.S., Motorola's Atrix HD came out on top, followed by Motorola's Droid Razr M, HTC's Rezound 4G, and Samsung's Galaxy Note 2, leaving the iPhone 5 in fifth place.
 
Other then the battery life (with WiFi on) I have am satisfied with it. Although I think its greatest features are when you have other Apple products. If I didn't use iTunes extensivly or have an AppleTV at home it would not be as "cool" to me.

Though personally I prefer the "bland" tiles as opposed to widgets, widgets kind of remind me of all the animated GIF's that use to be on sites like Geocities and Angelfire.

Also the lightning connector is awsome. I do think that the non-keyed feature will pick up steam in other connectors eventually.
 
Actually one thing I really like about the iPhone is that it doesn't come with all the carrier specific software preinstalled.
 
Wow color me surprised. The atrix hd is a terrible phone. It's slow and has terrible battery life. All my uncle does is complain about it. The rezound is equally as bad. I am surprised the s3 and one x aren't tops.
 
iPhone 5 had many QC problems, a lot of them came with big scratch and dent right out of the box. I bought one and the battery was lose inside. Took them about a week to replace it, the guy at apple store said it was a well known problem. The camera also have a purple flare when pointing at a strong light source.
 
The iPhone 5 is my 3rd iPhone and I've had 10x the issues with it that I had with my 3G and 4. If I could do it again I would've never bought one.
 
Actually one thing I really like about the iPhone is that it doesn't come with all the carrier specific software preinstalled.

That is also one of the beautiful things about Windows Phones as it can all be uninstalled upon first boot. Android OTOH, makes is painfully difficult to do so and requires root.
 
iPhone 5 is too tall. It can't be conveniently used with one hand anymore. The new iOS version also ditched Google maps which reduced functionality by 80% as far as location services go.

It's fast, fluid and kinda annoying. Despite the fact I didn't pay one cent for it.
 
I’ve actually been lucky that the maps isn’t too horrible in Denver. For me it has come down to technical problems. Whenever I go in and out of an LTE area, my service drops and wont’ come back without toggling cellular data settings. A few firmwares ago made it so I no longer get wi-fi in half my house. Lots of issues with coverage and getting “fake” connections with no data.
Plus, iTunes 11 is an absolute abortion, and the iPhone 5 screens are too warm-colored with no real way to fix it, too.
I absolutely loved my 3G and 4, and figured I was pretty much on the Apple mobile device path for the foreseeable future. Right now I think there’s pretty much no way I get another one.
 
From the little time I've had with it, it seemed really nice (used it for a week for work - I went with 4S for me, but others have been getting the 5). I really had no issues with it. Even the 4S is a damn nice phone.

For personal use, I have an HTC 8X (Windows Phone 8). Sadly, as much of a Microsoft whore I am, I like the iPhone better for a lot of things. It's made for dumb folks, so it's easy to use. Not as much information, not as full featured as the 8X, but it's dead simple. It's like using a toddler toy vs. an adult machine. It's a guarded sandbox compared to a big play ground. Android is like the open world, with pedos out there. Tons of power and stuff to do, but there is also more risk (crashing, fragmentation, malware).

Android has a great UI, and great user experience. But, I'm actually surprised that the iPhone isn't higher. Maybe people are wanting more from their smartphones these days, and just a simple iPhone isn't cutting it anymore.
 
non hd atrix user, from what I remember there isn't much difference between the two phones and I'm still living the phone.
 
I'm a 4S user, coming from a 3Gs and I'm quite happy with my iPhone. Plethora of apps and when jailbroken, very customize-able.

I've heard of a couple of complaints with the 5. An employee tells me her signal drops more often than her 3Gs which she upgraded from. But other than that she likes her new iPhone.
 
That is also one of the beautiful things about Windows Phones as it can all be uninstalled upon first boot. Android OTOH, makes is painfully difficult to do so and requires root.

I've rooted every Android phone I've ever had and none of them were what I would call "painfully difficult". In fact the latest Android phone I looked at gave you the ability to uninstall all of the added "crapware" apps out of the box. I expect we'll see more of that going forward.
 
Apple moving from a 3.5 to a 4" screen was a waste of everyone's time.

It will take a 5" Retina screen and some other nice updates to get it back on track.

A price reduction wouldn't hurt.

I'm also surprised the GSIII didn't beat it.
 
and no windows phones at all? Kind of flies in the face of most user reviews. No there aren't nearly as many out there, but the people that do have them give them VERY high ratings.

This whole "study" just doesn't pass the sniff test...for anyone.
 
We just got iPhones because my wife wanted one and we had some paid apps from having an iPad. My phone is fine, it's just a little boring. If I had been buying myself I would have gone Android but my wife wanted us to have the same phones. I normally make all the tech decisions so I let her have this one.
 
Apple moving from a 3.5 to a 4" screen was a waste of everyone's time.

It will take a 5" Retina screen and some other nice updates to get it back on track.

A price reduction wouldn't hurt.

I'm also surprised the GSIII didn't beat it.

I agree, I would have liked a 5" screen. I also would have liked NFC.
 
Meh nothing to see... move one. Finally other smart phones caught up. iPhone had its run... step aside, move along.
 
I've rooted every Android phone I've ever had and none of them were what I would call "painfully difficult". In fact the latest Android phone I looked at gave you the ability to uninstall all of the added "crapware" apps out of the box. I expect we'll see more of that going forward.

I rooted and remove a Kindle Fire ROM in favor of Android 4.2 and I have to say it was the most painful experience in the world. I probably shouldn't fault the device for being difficult to root. When running the rooting script after installing the composite Android USB driver, Windows' Device Manager decided to drop the device in the middle of the TWRP installation, causing my Fire to be bricked.

Took me several weeks to figure out what happened and to get the Kindle working again.

I didn't let that deter me though. I tried a second time with a different Android USB driver (from the Android SDK this time) and I was able to install TWRP this time, and afterwards, the stock 4.2 ROM.

It was a fun learning experience for sure!

My iPhone and iPad has always been consistently easy to jailbreak. It's a very straightforward process and since iOS is consistently the same on every device, online help is always easy to find if you even run into issues (though I haven't).
 
and no windows phones at all? Kind of flies in the face of most user reviews. No there aren't nearly as many out there, but the people that do have them give them VERY high ratings.

This whole "study" just doesn't pass the sniff test...for anyone.

This looks like a survey from only Verizon users. The Lumia range has very good reviews. 3 people in my family and 2 friends have the Lumia 920. They just work well. Wireless charging is also the coolest thing yet. I can't remember the last time I plugged my phone in.
 
I've liked my last few phones (all Android), but I've never liked them enough to give them high scores for satisfaction. There's always some problems with them. Of course, the phones I've picked (Motorola Cliq, MyTouch 4G and the HTC One S) always seem to attract more problems than the average Android phone. I should put up a blog and tell people what phone I'm excited about and buy so they can steer clear of them.
 
#1 The Apple maps fiasco probably was a bad start for iPhone 5.

#2 Even though on paper iPhone 5 lasts for a very long time, but in reality it's plagued by battery drain. Especially after 6.02. Probably worse with 6.1. Experience tends to vary.

#3 Jailbreak took far longer to come out then people expected. And yes, people want Jailbreak.

#4 Camera fucking blows. Probably worse then iPhone 4S. Purple coloring issue.

#5 New power adapter screws up everything. Have to buy new wires or adapters, and it doesn't offer anything new over the old connector.
 
I've liked my last few phones (all Android), but I've never liked them enough to give them high scores for satisfaction. There's always some problems with them. Of course, the phones I've picked (Motorola Cliq, MyTouch 4G and the HTC One S) always seem to attract more problems than the average Android phone. I should put up a blog and tell people what phone I'm excited about and buy so they can steer clear of them.

The Cliq was sorta like a copy cat of the HTC G1, but community support was surprising high for the Cliq. Cliq 2 though was a huge disappointment. I should know I have one.

I also have a MyTouch 4G slide, and love the thing. Expect the part where in order to SOFF the phone I need to do the special wire trick. Which is why everyone hates HTC now, cause they're going to far with their security.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=u7tPcQU5bWU

Friend has a HTC One S and has never had problems with it, but that person never tried to install a custom om onto it either. Plenty of people I know with Galaxy SIII and can't get enough of it. Also, custom roms for that is just stupid easy. Especially compared to HTC and Motorola devices.
 
Apple moving from a 3.5 to a 4" screen was a waste of everyone's time.

It will take a 5" Retina screen and some other nice updates to get it back on track.

A price reduction wouldn't hurt.

I'm also surprised the GSIII didn't beat it.

Nah.

My past two phones were android phones.

My criteria for a phone are as follows (most important to least):
  • Screen Size and resolution: I want a smallish phone. I consider a monstrous 4.8" screen too large. I want high pixel density in the 3.3"-4.0" size range.
  • Speed: I want a top end chip in the phone. I don't want something that's going to bog down when I want a program to load.
  • Battery life: Longer is obviously better, but I'm flexible on this if the top two can be met.

The iPhone was the only one that really met my criteria this time in.
 
#1 The Apple maps fiasco probably was a bad start for iPhone 5.

#2 Even though on paper iPhone 5 lasts for a very long time, but in reality it's plagued by battery drain. Especially after 6.02. Probably worse with 6.1. Experience tends to vary.

#3 Jailbreak took far longer to come out then people expected. And yes, people want Jailbreak.

#4 Camera fucking blows. Probably worse then iPhone 4S. Purple coloring issue.

#5 New power adapter screws up everything. Have to buy new wires or adapters, and it doesn't offer anything new over the old connector.
#6 The "study" doesn't actually give any indication of what questions were asked, how they were weighted, how they define "satisfaction" and all in all is pretty meaningless.
 
Did anyone even read that article? It states that the Motorola Atrix HD has the highest user satisfaction rating in the US. Really? Motorola Android phones are a joke. This OnDevice Research poll is complete garbage. They polled 320,000 people and the only Samsung device on the list is the Galaxy Note 2? I smell BS.
 
stopped reading when I saw top 2 devices were made by Motorola, I guarantee if you dig deeper they are in some way affiliated with them or whole "pol" was bought/paid for....
 
They make it into the top 5 and this is still somehow a disgrace? What's this tabloid bullshit?
The usual thread crappers saw Apple in the title, clicked on the thread and right on cue, typed the same thing about Apple being finished/iPhone is a failure/Android is perfect/etc... and left.

Heh...if the iPhone 5 is a disgrace at 5th, the Galaxy S3 must be a complete failure for not even making it on the list.
 
stopped reading when I saw top 2 devices were made by Motorola, I guarantee if you dig deeper they are in some way affiliated with them or whole "pol" was bought/paid for....

I stopped reading at Atrix HD. Crappy phone overall. IMO.
 
and no windows phones at all? Kind of flies in the face of most user reviews. No there aren't nearly as many out there, but the people that do have them give them VERY high ratings.

This whole "study" just doesn't pass the sniff test...for anyone.

They're not looking for high ratings, they're looking for satisfaction. Satisfaction is measured on a linear curve so the fact that the Atrix HD is a cheap improves its chances considerably. The people who buy it aren't smartphone enthusiasts and for many it might be one of their first and they don't have very high demands, so it's easy to satisfy them. Furthermore, satisfying someone doesn't mean impressing them.

That said, the methodology and questions were stupid. "Please rate your satisfaction from 1-10" is a poorly designed question because everyone has a different rating scale and it doesn't account for the things I mentioned. I can guarantee you most of those Atrix HD users would prefer an iPhone 5 to their current phone, but that doesn't come up in the survey. Stick a question in about "Which device would you rather own?" and the iPhone, Note 2 and S3 get a huge bump.
 
Back
Top