Intel KD925XCVLK or D915PBLL

dangfx

Gawd
Joined
May 2, 2001
Messages
707
Hey all,

I was just looking at new mobos to upgrade my system (just for the time being until i spring for a dual xeon -- but thats about 1-2 years away). But right now I'm working on a dual PIII 1ghz, so i'm feeling a bit behind in the times.

Does anyone know about these motherboards? More importantly, does anyone know the difference between them? they seem VERY similar (besides chipset, of course). Are they good? I have had trouble finding good reviews or info about them. Are they very new?

Also, will i see a noticable speed difference between my current dual P3 1ghz setup compared to a single P4 (HT'd) setup? I'm going from dual to single processor, and i know its hyperthreaded, but.... Will it be worth the money for about 2 yrs until i get my dual xeon?

thanks for any info!!

:)
 
addendum:

i forgot to mention, does anyone know if there's a big difference between DDR2 533 and DDR2 667? I know what the benchmarks say, but has anyone had real world experience? Also, i've heard of issues of stability, not working as it should, etc., with DDR2 in general. Is this true? anyone working with DDR2 right now? good experiences? bad? (also, are the two types, 533 and 667, interchangable on motherboards?).

:)
 
Sadly, Intel has been having problems of their own. They've been having trouble controlling the current leakage of their current Prescott processors, causing those CPUs to put out much more heat than they should be in the first place. Secondly, they've cancelled the next-generation successor to the P4/Xeon line (the P4 version was code-named Tejas), causing them to go backwards a generation or two of CPU as their next desktop CPU release (the next-generation Intel desktop CPUs will be based on the notebook Pentium-M CPUs, which are based on modified PIII-era technology, and as such have incomplete support of SSE2, and lack any SSE3 support at all whatsoever). Third, the PCI-e/DDR2 chipsets represent a step downwards in overall performance from their AGP/DDR1 predecessors, in their current implementation.
 
Yes they are very new.

From what we know so far, most DDR2-533 will run 667MHZ fairly easily. (overclocking the memory)

As E4g1e said, the very latest from Intel is not very appealing, a 865/875 chipset with a Northwood (P4C) processor is really a better setup (even though it is "end of life") than a new not yet perfected system.

Here is a good article explaining why what E4g1e is talking about is happening: http://www.overclockers.com/tips00632/

==>Lazn
 
yes... i've just been reading more about it... and it seems like the DDR2 route is not a smart way to go right now.

how about a 865 solution (like the intel PERLK) plus a Prescott CPU? i realize about the heat issue, but i'm not going to be doing any overclocking, and i figure with a nice Zalman, things will be ok. for new mobo + ram + CPU (say 3.2ghz) it will run me around $700.
what do you think?

also, will this outperform my current duallie setup? (see above)
 
dangfx said:
yes... i've just been reading more about it... and it seems like the DDR2 route is not a smart way to go right now.

how about a 865 solution (like the intel PERLK) plus a Prescott CPU? i realize about the heat issue, but i'm not going to be doing any overclocking, and i figure with a nice Zalman, things will be ok. for new mobo + ram + CPU (say 3.2ghz) it will run me around $700.
what do you think?

also, will this outperform my current duallie setup? (see above)

Well at 3.2GHZ with no overclocking a Northwood (3.2C) would be faster than a Prescott (3.2E) because the Northwood has a 20 stage pipeline and the Prescott has a 31 stage pipeline. (both are Hyperthreading processors) Not to mention cooler.

The PERLK is a socket 478 MB it will run either CPU (Northwood or Prescott) but not future LGA775 CPU's like the 64bit Prescotts.

If you are bound and determined to run a Prescott for some reason, I think a LGA775, 865 chipset MB like the ABIT AS8 is the way to go, as you get to stick with the 865 chipset and hopefully will be able to run IA32e (64bit) Prescotts in the future. http://www.abit-usa.com/products/mb/products.php?categories=1&model=191

Will a 3.2C or 3.2E be faster than your Dual 1Ghz P3? Yes in most tasks.

==>Lazn
 
but Prescott's are basically the same price as Northwoods (at the same clock speed). surely, there must be an advantage of the newer chip.... after all, pipeline length doesn't solely dictate speed.

as for 64bit, i'm not worried about it for right now. i will definately wait until my next big upgrade (perhaps in 1 to 2 years, like i said above) before I get into that... i want to wait til it matures and, hell, there are some 64bit apps out.
 
dangfx said:
but Prescott's are basically the same price as Northwoods (at the same clock speed). surely, there must be an advantage of the newer chip.... after all, pipeline length doesn't solely dictate speed.

as for 64bit, i'm not worried about it for right now. i will definately wait until my next big upgrade (perhaps in 1 to 2 years, like i said above) before I get into that... i want to wait til it matures and, hell, there are some 64bit apps out.

Yes the Prescotts have the advantage of being slower for the same money, hotter for the same money, use more electricity for the same money, and generally not as good for the same money.

I must admit they do have one thing that the Northwoods do not. They have SSE3 instructions. So if you run programs that can use SSE3, then they can be better for those specific tasks.

Otherwise clock for clock, they are significantly slower.
see: http://www.lostcircuits.com/cpu/prescott34/

In some tests a 2.8ghz Northwood is faster than a 3.4ghz Prescott.


==>Lazn
 
Back
Top