Intel Insider - It's Not DRM

Sandy Bridge CPUs have a GPU which probably needs some sort of 'DRM' measure to play protected movies. I thought AMD/Nvidia GPUs already have a similar concept?
 
Well, no. Not unless paying more money for something you didn't want in the first place (we WILL be the one's paying for this tech), and having yet more control over products by the sellers after we've paid our money for them is beneficial to the consumer.

There isn't shit here that benefits the consumer.

So the Intel Insider is really just a feature designed to improve security and could be used broadly for a variety of purposes that WOULD be beneficial to the general consumer?
 
Screwed how?

Lets say I have a FW900 or a high end CRT projector, can I watch a BluRay on it? Is there some technical limitation of the VGA port that doesn't allow it to carry a 1080p signal? Oh, wait, the only reason that you can't accomplish this is because of HDCP.... Or what if I've bought myself a Hauppauge Colossus (which has an HDMI input), surely I can attach my PS3 to it and record game footage to show my friends? Surely these two device's hardware are capable of such a feat? Oh wait.... :rolleyes:

This is but a SMALL list of examples of people being screwed out of legitimate use of their hardware because some douchebag decided that he wasn't making enough money. Instead they are relegated to using some shit conversion box that degrades the image...
 
But if we're ever going to get legal high quality HD streaming video, secure hardware decryption is a necessary evil.


No it isn't. People can already steal all the high quality HD video they want. How is secure hardware decryption going to change that? Again, the legitimate consumers are going to be punished as pirates LOL at them.
 
well HDCP or the protection in BR disks seems to work so well right now on my TV from an PC (as long as you have anydvd HD installed that is :) )

does nothing to stop HD content from been copied all it does it bother none tech swawy customers (i had 2 that had an beef with sony viao laptops with it not been able to play BR disks due to HDCP not happy with the display drivers and power dvd and the BR disk)

disk says no update powerdvd or i not play update power dvd now says HDCP failed, update drivers ops cant get official updated drivers as its not supported on VIAO laptops (and the driver on the site was older then what was on the system) had to used modified ini Nvidia drivers then it was happy, had to explain its more the issue with HDCP that enforces that every thing is protected and if its not happy it will not play the BR disk (partly sony fault for never updating display drivers or been able to officially use nvidia laptop drivers other half CP)
i did use anydvd HD before i fussed with the laptop and it fixed the problem right away but he would of had to pay for it as you need to keep anydvd upto date or it not play newer BR disks
 
It takes roughly 2 hours to rip a Bluray movie, removing the protection, and convert it to a 720p video file.

It's the same old argument agin and again... All these added extra security features are a waste of money and only affect those people who use them legitimately.
 
I can see the back of the DVD case now: "This is an Intel Insider movie.*"

"*Only playable on PCs with Intel Inside™."

And they thought DVD sales were hurting now...

This is about streaming video from the Internet, so there is no box and no DVD involved. The rest of your post was funny, though.
 
Lets say I have a FW900 or a high end CRT projector, can I watch a BluRay on it? Is there some technical limitation of the VGA port that doesn't allow it to carry a 1080p signal? Oh, wait, the only reason that you can't accomplish this is because of HDCP.... Or what if I've bought myself a Hauppauge Colossus (which has an HDMI input), surely I can attach my PS3 to it and record game footage to show my friends? Surely these two device's hardware are capable of such a feat? Oh wait.... :rolleyes:

This is but a SMALL list of examples of people being screwed out of legitimate use of their hardware because some douchebag decided that he wasn't making enough money. Instead they are relegated to using some shit conversion box that degrades the image...

Yeah, this type of douchebagger is going on across a whole gambit of areas of society. This isn't limited to the technology sector, but I do love the "oh those complainers should just shutup" comments that thare ongoing. Correct me if my memory serves me wrong, but when people were making these same complaints about such tech as HDCP, at the start it was all being downplayed, just like this is. No different then, and the appologists are going to be in the same friggin boat, once again, wrong and being herded along.
 
No it isn't. People can already steal all the high quality HD video they want. How is secure hardware decryption going to change that? Again, the legitimate consumers are going to be punished as pirates LOL at them.

Sad but true. This will be no different in the long run.
 
You guys are acting childishly. It is a hardware DRM for a service you DON'T have to subscribe to. It's not like it's going to prevent you from watching Gulliver's Travels that you downloaded off of bittorrent.
 
As I understand this, the basic concept is that movie vendors want to be able to offer streaming video from the internet that can't be copied. Why is that unreasonable? If you don't want to buy streaming video from the internet, what impact does it have on you? I really don't get the outrage.
 
You guys are acting childishly. It is a hardware DRM for a service you DON'T have to subscribe to. It's not like it's going to prevent you from watching Gulliver's Travels that you downloaded off of bittorrent.

The cost to develop and implement this will be passed on to people who buy the chips.
 
You guys are acting childishly. It is a hardware DRM for a service you DON'T have to subscribe to. It's not like it's going to prevent you from watching Gulliver's Travels that you downloaded off of bittorrent.

Pft at that the GT comment. As pointed out already, the cost will a.) be passed on to the consumer b.) who is to say it isn't going to get implemented on something that you do use? c.) assumption is the mother of all fuckups. We don't know how it's going to work, how it's going to be rolled out, how the costs are going to get passed on, etc, etc, etc. There are too many unknows and the answers of "trust us" doesn't work. To bundle all of the concerns that people, rightfully so, have about just another conceptual limit on how we use our systems, is not childish in any shape way or form.
 
I'm not sure that will be secured, i'm sure in month or two someone will figure out a way to crack any possible hardware based or software based security and put it on wiki and the first link of google.

also by the time intel cathes up to it it might not worth the effort as netflix will be lets say $1.99 to watch online via computer. then you'll be tired of watching movies and you'll think, "it's not worth my time canceling the account"

How is Intel Insider not DRM?

DRM

DRM

Sounds like a stupid politician making herself sound even more idiotic.

although i'm male, i'm not sure why you used "HERSELF" rather than himself/herself which is mostly correct.
 
I can see the back of the DVD case now: "This is an Intel Insider movie.*"

"*Only playable on PCs with Intel Inside™."

And they thought DVD sales were hurting now...

The most understandable and best comment on the thread.

Aside all, this is actually be big downfall for movie industry,

The only way this can be useful to consumer is for those who does streaming of security video and audio other than that there is no point of this having even in hardware form. this future can actually work in favor for big industry's security as no one can steal them and modify them to take advantage of somekind. just my thoughts nothing else i can think can make this thing better for average consumer.
 
You guys are acting childishly. It is a hardware DRM for a service you DON'T have to subscribe to. It's not like it's going to prevent you from watching Gulliver's Travels that you downloaded off of bittorrent.

I think it's plausible to assume that many if not most content providers who are in the position of using this will do so, if it ends up in a lot of computer systems. If you object to the idea of content providers encrypting their videos, then it's reasonable to object to the inclusion of this feature.
 
Lets say I have a FW900 or a high end CRT projector, can I watch a BluRay on it? Is there some technical limitation of the VGA port that doesn't allow it to carry a 1080p signal? Oh, wait, the only reason that you can't accomplish this is because of HDCP.... Or what if I've bought myself a Hauppauge Colossus (which has an HDMI input), surely I can attach my PS3 to it and record game footage to show my friends? Surely these two device's hardware are capable of such a feat? Oh wait.... :rolleyes:

This is but a SMALL list of examples of people being screwed out of legitimate use of their hardware because some douchebag decided that he wasn't making enough money. Instead they are relegated to using some shit conversion box that degrades the image...

Yeah. I haven't bothered getting a BD drive for my PC because I'd need to buy AnyDVD or something like that to crack the copy protection.

Hell, I went to play a TV-on-DVD the other day and I was getting a copy protection error of some sort until I unplugged the FW900 from my VGA port. I still didn't figure out what that was about...I just didn't get around to watching it, instead. **** 'em.

HDCP isn't transparent, either. I've had issues using HDMI splitters (they've gotten better in recent years). Try a complicated setup with a switcher, a splitter and a couple of displays and see what happens. Sometimes I need to power cycle the receiver or the device (happens a lot with my HD-DVD player and my Xbox 360) to re-sync the HDMI up. Ugh.
 
The cost to develop and implement this will be passed on to people who buy the chips.

Considering that the mid-level CPUs in question rival the previous high-end CPUs in performance and cost 3 to 4 times less, I find this argument to be really thin.

Also, Intel has over 20 billion dollars cash on hand, indicating that they are a very profitable company. The cost to develop and implement this is probably a drop in the ocean of profit they make on their product.
 
Also, Intel has over 20 billion dollars cash on hand, indicating that they are a very profitable company. The cost to develop and implement this is probably a drop in the ocean of profit they make on their product.

Upon further thought, I must correct myself. Intel wouldn't be doing Intel Insider if they weren't expecting to make a profit by doing it. How? From the movie vendors that license it. Those movie vendors in turn pay for the license from the money they earn from selling streaming internet video.

In short, the only people who ultimately pay for it are the ones who use it. If you don't use it, it didn't cost you anything.
 
Thread necro! I am pondering building a little shiny new HTPC, just for streaming and web browsing mostly, and wanted to pick up the G1610 for it. In researching this it looks like the G chips have some gimped features. None of these really concern me. However I had no idea what this "Intel Insider" thing was. I did some research on this to see if this will be a problem for the foreseeable future, since Intel touts it as a feature necessary to watch streaming 1080p movies from entertainment industry partners. All I really want out of any future HTPC media-wise is the ability to stream, so naturally this was semi-alarming. (I don't maintain much of my own digital library.) If I can, I want to avoid buying a chip with more power than I actually need (thanks Intel!)

I did some brief research on the current state of affairs on this and wanted to share what I thought. And of course, if the knowledgeable folks here have anything to add or correct me on, please do.

The gist: Intel Insider is currently worthless. You all know that already. "Ultraviolet," the industry consortium's attempt to take advantage of Intel's hardware encryption (or whatever it is) offers digital access to 1080p movies off of a "digital locker" which you buy for full price, either from the website directly, or in a physical store with a code to use online. This is basically worthless to someone who is only interested in renting or streaming a movie once. So the question I am trying to figure out: how much will it be worth in the future? Intel touted this as a way for the movie industry to trust in HD streaming content. 2 years following their launch of this, it still seems mostly useless, which to me does not bode well for its future utility.

To see the current state of affairs and figure out if there was any utility to this down the line, last night I tried to see what I could watch on various sites that Intel was pimping on its Ultraviolet page. I was using my current HTPC which has an i5-2400 with "intel insider." I visited sites such as WB and Paramount's official websites, linked from Intel's "ultraviolet" page. First, WB's streaming is well known to be rife with issues. The process, 2 years later, is still buggy and mostly useless. For instance, you have to install a roxio plugin on firefox to check if your PC is "HD ready" (i.e., if it has the chips Intel paid WB to require you to have). The plugin in my case (a) crashed and (b) when it did work, could not verify that I did indeed have a 2nd generation Intel i5 chip, as it requires. Obviously they're not trying very hard. CinemaNow (BestBuy's offering) worked, but again, what's the point? If you want to pay full price for high def, why not just go out and buy the blu ray copy to ensure you actually have a physical copy rather than gimped access to a "digital locker?" Lame!

So the current state of affairs for the "Intel Insider" feature: it is next to useless and is not actually being taken advantage of in any meaningful or useful way by the movie industry. Amazon didn't really buy into it very much, which was a major blow. For the future, will it matter for streaming content? For instance will Netflix adopt it as a requirement for rentals? Unlikely in my opinion. Netflix already offers HD to certain subscribers and I don't believe (correct me if I am wrong) that you need the "Intel Insider" feature on your CPU for that to work. Will TV broadcasters require it for sites like iTunes and Amazon to sell HD TV shows? Also unlikely--I doubt they will want to limit their market share. I think a more likely limitation will come from cable providers who will strike deals with distributors to limit access to people who use their cable internet service. Like Fox does now with some of their streaming content (you have to subscribe to Xfinity, for example, to watch some online streaming content after it is broadcast at Fox's website. If you only have comcast internet with no cable, you have to wait a week. Much to my wife's chagrin, who likes to watch Glee online on our HTPC.)

Does anyone disagree with this analysis? Will Intel Insider actually matter in another year or two? Or will it remain a useless, unused gimmick that Intel tries to push on people to buy more CPU than they need? (Hopefully, it will remain a useless gimmick...) What do you guys think?
 
It's not specifically DRM in name, but it is DRM in function. It's the function that counts. Saying the sky is purple is fine, but we all know it's the sky. Next.
 
Or will it remain a useless, unused gimmick that Intel tries to push on people to buy more CPU than they need? (Hopefully, it will remain a useless gimmick...) What do you guys think?
It was simply an application of the chip's encryption engine. One proposed use under the name "Intel Insider" has gone nowhere, and is dead.

Some people get so hysterically worked up over anything that can be labeled "DRM" that there is no explaining anything to the contrary. The encryption engine built into the newer chips can be useful for some purposes, or used for something no one is asking for like "Intel Insider."

Any new vendor-specific feature like for streaming this is probably doomed to fail, because there will not be an installed base significant enough to attract attention, and it leaves the vast majority of systems unable to use it.

Anyways, necro fail. There's an Intel sub-forum.
 
Back
Top