inside the 4870 cooler, pics

yeah i took my sound card out and i couldn't even hanlde the god damn thing, it has the metal case around it (xfi titanium) i couldn't believe hot hot it was even with the 30% fan speed the cards run MUCH cooler but its not enough to prevent the sound card from meltdown temps much hotter and stuff my unsolder itself lmao
 
It looks like your soundcard is blocking the intake of the upper card, perhaps that's why its getting too hot? I dropped the temperature of my 8800GTS by several degrees just by providing better airflow around the fan intake.
 
It looks like your soundcard is blocking the intake of the upper card, perhaps that's why its getting too hot? I dropped the temperature of my 8800GTS by several degrees just by providing better airflow around the fan intake.

The top card runs about 6 degrees hotter than the bottom when idle with 33% fanspeed (55 degrees and 61)

Yes it's blocking the intake slightly which accounts for the top card being slightly hotter than it should be, however everyones 4870 cards tend to run at about 80 degrees before you've changed any profile settings.

This is just considered to be the normal operating temperature of these cards when idle, if it wasn't it would surely have been fixed in the 8.7 drivers.

Anywho, the difference is massive, the soundcard is too hot to touch with stock settings even when the cards are idle, with the driver profile tweak you can get the cards running at the temps posted above and the soundcard is much cooler.

I've emailed Asus support to see if they can provide me with safe operating temps for the soundcard, if its above 90 degrees then im happy but if its lower then I think AMD need to reconsider their default fanspeeds
 
i think the top card runs a little warmer for everyone, maybe something to do with the one always in use or displaying? dont know

my top card idles 4-5 deg higher than my lower one, but there the same under load
 
I am willing to bet that if you take some 90% alcohol and a cotton ball you will se some paint removed to reveal a nice aluminum heat sink. Just my $0.02
 
I am willing to bet that if you take some 90% alcohol and a cotton ball you will se some paint removed to reveal a nice aluminum heat sink. Just my $0.02

on what the stock ati cooler?

not unless it has a lead core, it weighs way to much to be aluminum base
 
I know its hefty but... I dunno. Looks a little bubbly of a finish. and not like copper. Maybe its just the pic.
 
the fins are aluminum, the base is copper

there is also a sticker on the bottom of the heat sink that's clear, with a sqaure hole for the die to sit in, not sure if you can make that out in the pics or not
 
you must have hearing like superman and a poorly ventilated case

you guys crack me up sometimes with this noise obsession, people tweaking about a little fan noise lol, get some good fans folks and youll see a difference like panaflos or scythe s flex fans

one certainly cannot hear the video card fan over your fragging in some game

You could say that about yourself. You obsess over a few degrees difference in temperature - a bunch of numbers on a screen that don't affect your experience and can't be sensually perceived, and yet you don't care about sound which IS easily perceived.;)
 
You're talking bollocks.

You're right in that the total heat generated by the card does not change, but when you slow the fanspeed down less heat is exauhsted out the back of the case, this initially causes the heatsink to rise in temperature, once the heatsink reaches a stable temperature it means the card is giving off the additional heat to its imediate surroundings which is the air around it (inside the case)

Even if there's less air being moved by the fan, it's still circulated by the fan. A lower amount of hotter air will still be exiting the rear of the case. Of course the plastic of the ducting on the 4870 will rise to the temperature of that air eventually. The plastic case and the fins of the heatsink have no thermal connection to one another other than the moving air flowing between them. That moving air will never reach the temperature of the heatsink fins, let alone the GPU core itself.

I would still be concerned that you're blocked have of the intake area of your top card with your sound card.

And, AGAIN, the temperature read out from the core is not the temperature of the air leaving the cooler, nor is it the same as the plastic ducting. The temperature is read at the heat source, all other temperatures throughout the cooler system will be lower.

Of course if you have a negative pressure situation inside of your case that is overcoming the fan on the cards, that's a different story.

Your sound card may be getting hot because it has no active cooling and there's not enough convection around it to remove the heat. You could override your ATI fans to 100% and it may not change a thing other than the top card will be moving air past the sound card. All of my sound cards since SB16 get hot when they're actually doing something, X-fis will be no exception.
 
with my stock ati coolers and stock fan speed i cant touch my xfi with the steel cover after an hour or so of tf2 to remove it, its that hot

fan speed turned up to 30% its still hot but you can still handle it if your quick

with my hr03gt coolers the card is only warm, probably more from being used and its own heat generated, the heat radiated off the cards adds up, especially from both sides
 
the akasa vortex neo uses the same design as the ati 4870 cooler..they both exhaust to the back but akasa looks like it only uses half the amount of fins as the 4870 and achieves the same (probably better) cooling..i scratched up my p5q-e motherboard heatsink while installing the sunbeam core contact freezer and it shows up aluminum under those niice paint
http://chilledpc.co.uk/portal/index.php?option=com_content&task=view&id=34&Itemid=55
 
You're talking bollocks.

You're right in that the total heat generated by the card does not change, but when you slow the fanspeed down less heat is exauhsted out the back of the case, this initially causes the heatsink to rise in temperature, once the heatsink reaches a stable temperature it means the card is giving off the additional heat to its imediate surroundings which is the air around it (inside the case)

The soundcard is jammed right between both 4780s and so recieves a lot of heat from them when the temperature of the cards is high, and recieves less heat from them when the fanspeed is high because more heat is being exauhsted out side the case and the cards are overall lower in temperature.

The soundcard generates no real significant amount of heat on it's own, yet when in a very cool case, it actually gets too hot to touch the metal case, my guess is about 80 degrees when the 4870's are under full load with the default fanspeed (slow) at this point the 4870's are closer to 90 degrees.

When the fanspeed is set higher and the 4870s run cooler more heat is being put outside the case and less is leaking from the cards to the air inside the case, which means the soundcard is cooler, cool enough to touch.

What I was saying in my previous post was that im quite happy for the 4870's to run that hot since they were designed to, but applying huge amounts of heat to other devices inside the case in unacceptable, more specifically heating my soundcard case to be too hot to touch is not good, I expect it puts it well outside its normal operating temps (i'm trying to find them online now actually)

Pics for reference, if you think the temperature of the 4870 graphics cards doesn't effect the temperature of the soundcard then you're nuts.

2641309865_56f54fd758.jpg




The overclock is entirely FBS related, yet the throttle is done by lowering the multiplier, so the throttled speed when overclocked is still greater than the throttled speed when not overclocked, i.e. it still runs hotter than it should do.

Wait let me throw in a few of these as well :rolleyes::rolleyes::rolleyes:

There we go :D



how about sticking your fingers in water thats 90 degrees celsius? see if you think its okay or perhaps put your microwave dinner in water thats 90 degrees celsius, not too far from the boiling point, cook eggs at far less than that, you guys must upgrade soo often that you dont burn your computer out completely
 
Even if there's less air being moved by the fan, it's still circulated by the fan. A lower amount of hotter air will still be exiting the rear of the case. Of course the plastic of the ducting on the 4870 will rise to the temperature of that air eventually. The plastic case and the fins of the heatsink have no thermal connection to one another other than the moving air flowing between them. That moving air will never reach the temperature of the heatsink fins, let alone the GPU core itself.

I'm not saying the soundcard is as hot as the GPU or heatsink, I estimate it to be lower in temperature, either way its FACT that it's hotter when the cards HSF are hotter, you can do a simple test by touching it to notice the difference in temperature between stock fanspeed cooling and the modified speed is very similar to the difference of the video card itself under the same testing conditions.

It's perfectly simple, other components local to the video cards tends to heat up more, the higher the temperature of the cards, when the video cards are hot, so is the soundcard.

I would still be concerned that you're blocked have of the intake area of your top card with your sound card.

Im not really concerned, the temps i've measured to be about 5-6 degrees hotter with equal fanspeeds and most people with SLI/Xfire are reporting that the top card tends to be slightly hotter anyhow.

And, AGAIN, the temperature read out from the core is not the temperature of the air leaving the cooler, nor is it the same as the plastic ducting. The temperature is read at the heat source, all other temperatures throughout the cooler system will be lower.

it's not a perfect serial connection of:

GPU -> heatsink -> Fan -> air inside case

For starters even the best air cooling is never going to be removing 100% of the heat from the heatsink. In addition there are areas where the heatsink directly meets with the air inside the case (but not inside the vga cooler)

Of course if you have a negative pressure situation inside of your case that is overcoming the fan on the cards, that's a different story.

I dont think anyone case pressure significantly differs from 1 atmosphere, you'd need an airtight case with some really hefty fans to change the pressure.

Your sound card may be getting hot because it has no active cooling and there's not enough convection around it to remove the heat. You could override your ATI fans to 100% and it may not change a thing other than the top card will be moving air past the sound card. All of my sound cards since SB16 get hot when they're actually doing something, X-fis will be no exception.

No the soundcard doesn't have cooling, thats why I'm worried!

I HAVE changed the speed of my cards, and it does make a difference, as I've previously said, running at stock cooling (which i've read is something like 7-12% fanspeed) means the cards run at 80 degrees idle.

However with 33% fanspeed the cards run at the numbers I posted earlier, I think it was 46 and 51? degrees, which is significantly cooler, and verified the soundcard runs cooler also.

Its not pulling more air over the soundcard, the majorety of the airflow is coming from the 3x front mounted 120mm intake fans, with the orientation of the picture they're on the right which means the closest part of the card is the fan.

with my stock ati coolers and stock fan speed i cant touch my xfi with the steel cover after an hour or so of tf2 to remove it, its that hot

fan speed turned up to 30% its still hot but you can still handle it if your quick

with my hr03gt coolers the card is only warm, probably more from being used and its own heat generated, the heat radiated off the cards adds up, especially from both sides

Exactly, the cards pass more heat into the case when the cooling is worse, the total heat generated stays the same I'm sure we all agree but the components inside the case suffer and get warmer because of it.

how about sticking your fingers in water thats 90 degrees celsius? see if you think its okay or perhaps put your microwave dinner in water thats 90 degrees celsius, not too far from the boiling point, cook eggs at far less than that, you guys must upgrade soo often that you dont burn your computer out completely

Um?

The video cards just run that hot, most people with 2 4870's in crossfire are seeing these temps, in addition the full load temps of these cards even when you use just a single one is approx 85 degrees (see reviews like [H]'s)

Again I will re-state, I'm happy for the cards to run that hot if thats how they're designed HOWEVER if they're raising the temps of other components in the meantime then thats possibly an issue, I dont want a capacitor or something on my Xonar to blow, that'd suck for a £110 soundcard.
 
Frostex:

With your ATI fans at 100%, you are going to flow considerable air near your X-Fi, since your X-Fi overlaps the intake of one of your cards. Do you see as much of an X-Fi temperature drop if you run the bottom card at 100% (no air interaction with the X-Fi) but leave the top one stock? The number one factor to your frying X-Fi is that it is sandwiched, regardless of what it is in-between, fan profiles or power ratings.

If you think that running two 4870s with tangential blowers at 100% doesn't change the airflow in your entire case think again. I still feel that the change in airflow is cooling your X-fi more than the drop in 4870 core temperature. If running at 100% fixes your problem, then just do that. If it doesn't, find another way to arrange your components so you don't fry your sound card. My point is that any card which draws the power of the 4870 will have the same contribution to case heat - it doesn't matter what ATI set as the default fan profiles or what the chip core temp is. At least the 4870 vents externally.

As for atmospheric pressure, I have an 8800GTS512 which vents outside of the case. It doesn't take much negative pressure at stock fan profiles to overcome the flow from the card blower on the GTS and the GTS runs higher fan profiles than the 4870 from the sounds of things. It happened to lots of people who bought GTSs - air was still being drawn in the card outlets in the rear of the case at stock speeds. Don't spew variation from 1 atmosphere crap at me. It happens to lots of people, and could be a factor for you *at stock speeds*. If you had 2x120mm exhaust fans and a single 120mm intake fan (ie. power supply plus one case fan exhaust), THAT is negative pressure. Keep running those 4870s at 100% and your negative pressure is even worse. Your power supply will probably start flowing backwards well before then. Air seals my ass. *IF* you have negative pressure at stock fan speeds, regardless of the core temp, you may have HOT air from the 4870 exiting the blower intake and hitting your X-fi directly. Higher fan speeds will correct this flow and allow the X-Fi to cool. Again, not related to the core temp or the 4870.

conghelach: chips aren't fingers, as such they have different operating parameters than fingers.
 
how about sticking your fingers in water thats 90 degrees celsius? see if you think its okay or perhaps put your microwave dinner in water thats 90 degrees celsius, not too far from the boiling point, cook eggs at far less than that, you guys must upgrade soo often that you dont burn your computer out completely


Last I checked video cards dont contain flesh which can be damaged by the temperature. Nor do you generally eat a video card, nor cook eggs on it, nor is there water in it which can boil away (unless you're using water cooling :p).

If its designed for that temperature then it'll run at that temperature fine, who cares if its too hot to touch? :p Go drive your car for a few hours then stick your hand straight on the exhaust manifold, or open the radiator cap and have the boiling water spray all over you. Just because it hurts YOU doesn't have anything to do with how the car itself is supposed to run. :p
 
Back
Top