i7 Motherboard thoughts

gkanakis

[H]ard|Gawd
Joined
Oct 11, 2004
Messages
1,167
Need your opinion.
Just picked up a couple items and need a good motherboard for them:

CORSAIR XMS3 6GB (3 x 2GB) 240-Pin DDR3 SDRAM DDR3 1600
Intel Core i7-920 Bloomfield 2.66GHz

Need 2 PCIe slots minimum for sli.
Able to OC well
And a very good raid controller. I have 3 SSD drives that I want to RAID 0 for performance.
I know nothing about the quality of raid controllers.
Quality is more important then price, but I don't need the very top of the line beast.
Let me know what you guys have for ideas.
 
I have the same situation. Im looking at the EVGA 3x Classified board but im not sure if its worth the $380 AR price.
 
There's not going to be a difference between boards as far as RAID goes, since the best you'll get on a consumer board is Intel's own built-in RAID which all X58 boards have.

As for specific motherboard models, there are many that fit your criteria. I would recommend something from ASUS, Gigabyte, or EVGA, but I've heard good things about offerings from MSI, Foxconn, ASRock, and DFI as well. Since we're talking about X58 boards here, all of them will have at least two PCI-E 16x slots and most of them have SLI support.
 
A few I would look at:

Gigabyte EX58-UD5
ASUS P6T Deluxe V2
EVGA E758-TR
 
Thanks guys! Just need a general direction to go with.
Edit: Damn those are some feature rich boards!!

When looking for a controller card, what would be a good one for a reasonable price?
Or would the Intel controller be OK?
 
Last edited:
i have pretty much all the latest x58 boards for testing at work and from what i have found and seen the p6t deluxe v2 is the best clocking and generally consistently stable

im kind of dissapointed at the EX58 however ive been a big fan of gigabyte boards and this one just doesnt seem to shine the way the evga or asus boards do
 
The only thing I don't care for on the Asus is the board layout. I feel they wasted a PCIe slot. They should have double spaced them all.
Other then that I would go that way. My last 3 gaming boards have been Asus and I love them!
 
The only thing I don't care for on the Asus is the board layout. I feel they wasted a PCIe slot. They should have double spaced them all.
Other then that I would go that way. My last 3 gaming boards have been Asus and I love them!
The spacing they have is actually better for airflow, so unless you want to run three cards, it's pretty well laid-out in my opinion.
 
The spacing they have is actually better for airflow, so unless you want to run three cards, it's pretty well laid-out in my opinion.

True, it has better airflow, but if you wanted to add a Physx card you would be out of luck if you had dual sloted cards. Which is the standard for high end cards.
Plus I run the Antec Nine Hundred Two case on all my builds now. I like the 8 expansion slots in back.

Like I said though, I love my Asus boards! I'm actually getting ready to retire my Asus A8N-SLI Deluxe board when I buy this new board. My Rampage Formula, current system, will be my sons new computer. He is excited!
 
In my opinion...........and it's just that......

take a hard look at the EVGA X58-SLI (758-A1)......in other words, vanilla non-Classified.
If you are only looking at SLI and maybe a PCI card, this is your board.

The board is laid out very well, it's very mature. I easily reached a 200 BClk, and if you have a D0 920 I'm sure you can get more.
I'm not some kind of EVGA fanboy, but I think they have outstanding support that alot of the others don't.

I liked the board, and later stepped up to the Classified which has been solid as a rock for me, as was the 758.
You could save a few bucks and get the TR model, which is identical except it has only a three year warranty and can't be stepped up.
 
Legion Hardware claims Asus P7P55D is best OC mb currently. I installed P7P55D LE just yesterday but haven't attempted OC yet. LE is cut down version so you may be more interested in Deluxe model.
 
I don't think anyone's mentioned it specifically yet, so I'll throw another mobo into the fray.

ASRock X58 Extreme LGA 1366 Intel X58

It's cheap, feature-heavy, and it's a Tom's Hardware 2009 Recommended Buy.
 
Legion Hardware claims Asus P7P55D is best OC mb currently. I installed P7P55D LE just yesterday but haven't attempted OC yet. LE is cut down version so you may be more interested in Deluxe model.

The OP has a core i7 socket 1366 CPU. (920)
The P7P55D is for socket 1156 core i5 and i7s.:D
 
i have pretty much all the latest x58 boards for testing at work and from what i have found and seen the p6t deluxe v2 is the best clocking and generally consistently stable

im kind of dissapointed at the EX58 however ive been a big fan of gigabyte boards and this one just doesnt seem to shine the way the evga or asus boards do

Really? I really like mine. Mind you I have the EX58-Extreme, not the UD5 but that is pretty much the same board from what I understand, mine just has (I think) a waterblock on the northbridge, and one can connect an extra passive heatsink to the northbridge also instead of (or even on top of) using the waterblock.

Having said that, the ASUS and the EVGA listed above are probably good choices too.
 
In my opinion...........and it's just that......

take a hard look at the EVGA X58-SLI (758-A1)......in other words, vanilla non-Classified.
If you are only looking at SLI and maybe a PCI card, this is your board.

The board is laid out very well, it's very mature. I easily reached a 200 BClk, and if you have a D0 920 I'm sure you can get more.
I'm not some kind of EVGA fanboy, but I think they have outstanding support that alot of the others don't.

I liked the board, and later stepped up to the Classified which has been solid as a rock for me, as was the 758.
You could save a few bucks and get the TR model, which is identical except it has only a three year warranty and can't be stepped up.

This pretty much sums up my experience too, other than the overclocking. I cranked it up to 150 for a while, but haven't taken the time to actually try anything else yet.
 
with all the new x58 boards coming out in the next week or so, you should wait


any details? i've already pretty much settled on the gigabyte UD5 but am willing to wait if the new stuff brings SATA 6Gb or any other upgrades to the subsystems...
 
I have had the Foxconn Blood Rage, the Classified, the Rampage Extreme II, the Rampage Gene, the Gigabyte UD5 Extreme, the EVGA SLI x58 758 A1 and for the most part they perform the same. All were able to go to 200BCLK with a I7 920 putting it at 4.2Ghz with HT and turbo turned on. If you want to go past that then you will want the top tier boards, the Classified, Rampage Extreme II and the Blood Rage. The Blood Rage probably wouldn't work for you since you may end up with an add in RAID controller. If you are not planning on benching and doing extreme cooling, i.e. Phase or LN2, then I would go with what fits your budget and fit a specific need. Personally, I would stick with an Asus or an EVGA board. Asus offers cross shipping on thier ROG series automatically, whereas EVGA you have to pay extra for it upfront. This can really save you a lot of down time.
 
any details? i've already pretty much settled on the gigabyte UD5 but am willing to wait if the new stuff brings SATA 6Gb or any other upgrades to the subsystems...
The ASUS P6X58D Premium with USB 3.0 and SATA 3.0. No official date yet, but it's supposedly out in Q4 2009. Layout looks pretty good too, and I like the heatsinks (SB could be better though):





Some people might say SATA 3.0 is overkill, and I'd agree if they're talking about standard harddisks (only onboard cache benefits), but it will be helpful for future SSD's which can really make use of that extra speed. And USB 3.0 is pretty nice for external harddisks, USB sticks and HD webcams. Most of them are bottlenecked by USB 2.0 currently.
 
It is SATA 6.0 that is new.
SATA 3.0 is the current specification.

(It went from SATA 1.5 to 3.0 and now to 6.0)
 
It is SATA 6.0 that is new.
SATA 3.0 is the current specification.

(It went from SATA 1.5 to 3.0 and now to 6.0)
No, it went from SATA 1 to 2 and now to 3. What you're referring to is the speed of communication of each version of SATA, which is 1.5Gbps, 3Gbps, and 6Gbps for 1, 2, and 3 respectively.
 
personally I am just waiting to see if these new usb/sata3 boards drive the price of the older ones down a bit.
 
No, it went from SATA 1 to 2 and now to 3. What you're referring to is the speed of communication of each version of SATA, which is 1.5Gbps, 3Gbps, and 6Gbps for 1, 2, and 3 respectively.

This is precisely the reason why SATA-IO requests that people refer to the new spec as "SATA 6Gbps" or "SATA Revision 3.0" rather than "SATA 3.0" to reduce confusion with the older SATA 3Gbps spec.
 
[X]eltic;1034941406 said:
The ASUS P6X58D Premium with USB 3.0 and SATA 3.0. No official date yet, but it's supposedly out in Q4 2009. Layout looks pretty good too, and I like the heatsinks (SB could be better though):




Well, Q4 is 2/3 over already. :eek: I just went over to the ASUS site (USA) and nothing there about a supposed P6X58D.

Anyone have any recent inside information? ;)

x509
 
Back
Top