How Amazon Could Save the U.S. Postal Service

USPS doesn't need to be saved, it just needs to stop being actively sabotaged. Congress decided in 2006 that they should pre-fund their healthcare costs for the next 75 years and do it in 10, oh and they should still be legally required to operate without any sort of public financing, a distinction that puts us in an exclusive club with Somalia amongst countries who don't fund their postal service.

Also Congress did such a wonderful job with the math, that the CRS came out a little while ago and said that the USPS under the present payment system would have "over-funded its retiree health liability".

How many companies large or small could survive something like that?

Meanwhile FedEx and others are being subsidized through schemes like "SmartPost" where USPS has to accept responsibility for expensive last-mile delivery while FedEx makes most of the profits. The wonder is not that the USPS is having trouble, it's that it isn't having more given how the deck has been systematically stacked against them.

Oh and I'd say much the same about Amtrak if you actually look at what they have to deal with that their private competitors don't.
 
Silly that's due congress requiring them to pay for future employees retirement funds ahead of time, they have to prefund for employees retirement that have yet to be retired. They are the only government controlled business that has to do that. USPS only came into finical troubles in 2006 when congressed pass that rule, nearly all of their operational loss comes from that.

It doesn't matter what it's due to, it's a loss which was a counter argument to the poster I replied to that stated/questioned that the USPS is the only gov't agency to operate without a loss.

Also only about 2/3rds of that loss is due to prefunding pensions. The other third is due to the fact that only people over the age of 60 mail bills, write letters, etc.
 
The USPS is losing $16 billion a year. The pension prefunding is $5 billion a year. Unless I'm mistaken, the math doesn't add up here. If the prefunding were eliminated, it still looks like they are losing money.
 
The post office in our area is terrible. I have individuals bringing me my mail all the time. I even have a Post Office Box. Yet somehow people with mailboxes at their house will get my mail. Thankfully people recognize my name and call me or are nice enough to bring it to me at work. It is very rare that Amazon loses a package. Every time that I have lost one, it came through the post office. Thankfully Amazon is very easy to deal with when it comes to issues like that.
 
Thts still really really weird that companies will do that. Pretty much anywhere else in the world no company will just leave a package on the doorstep. If it's not there they leave a note for you to pick it up from their local depot, or try and deliver it the next day.

I know just doing that is the laziest and cheapest thing to do. But it's not really a remotely sensible way of doing something. Oh but it's the cheapest...

I would be quite upset if any package delivery company DIDN'T leave packages at my door. I would probably curtail most of my online shopping if I had to go pick up all my packages. The post office is probably a 25 minute round trip and I would probably have to wait until Saturday. UPS and Fedex are on my way home, but it would be a hassle plus the extra day wait time.

I probably get upwards of 75 to 100 packages a year and have yet to have one stolen. I do live in a pretty decent neighborhood plus my house is nearly 200 feet from the road. I also have a side door instead of a front door.
 
If congress allowed them to raise prices to a fair level they would be fine.

If congress didn't grant them a monopoly on services for which their price is fixed, they wouldn't exist.

If congress did not force them to bank 75 years worth of retirement benefits (something no other company or government does). They would be fine.

If the USPS had to securely fund the pension benefits of its 1-million + employees they wouldn't exist.

If congress allowed the USPS to monetize their brand, they would be fine.

If the USPS "brand" wasn't protected by private police, tax exemptions and monopolies they wouldn't exist.

There is no monopoly or tax exemption, just a congress that shits all over the USPS so they can break the unions.

You are so completely wrong.
The USPS has a monopoly on first class letter service
They have a monopoly on bulk-mailing service
They have a monopoly on the use of residential mailboxes
They are exempt from property tax
They are exempt from vehicle tax
They are exempt from sales tax
They are exempt from payroll tax
They are eligible for special lending from the government.
They have pension obligations for over a million employees including health costs and their market is shrinking, not growing. They exist off of the federal balance sheets, and they are not considered cabinet-level.
 
it would be great if USPS became a shipping option for amazon. Not to bash UPS or anything but i prefer USPS. Just cause of the fact that i can literally ship my items with their original boxes without any sort of protection except tape and it still gets to the customer in one piece. If i were to the that with UPS id be losing money
 
USPS doesn't need to be saved, it just needs to stop being actively sabotaged. Congress decided in 2006 that they should pre-fund their healthcare costs for the next 75 years and do it in 10, oh and they should still be legally required to operate without any sort of public financing, a distinction that puts us in an exclusive club with Somalia amongst countries who don't fund their postal service.

They're required to fund the NPV of their benefits expenses.
This is not an unreasonable requirement of a government-protected and taxpayer-supported GSE with growing pension obligations and shrinking market.

Also Congress did such a wonderful job with the math, that the CRS came out a little while ago and said that the USPS under the present payment system would have "over-funded its retiree health liability".

It's part of the facade that the USPS is not a government agency.
If it's to be treated like a private company (and I don't think it should be!) then take away the monopolies.
However, we want to pretend it's a private company so that it's mounting liabilities and employment costs don't show up on the federal balance sheets and this is dishonest.

Make it a cabinet-level agency, put its costs on the balance sheet and enforce the federal rules on unionized government employees.

How many companies large or small could survive something like that?

A company whose pension obligation is growing, and whose market is shrinking isn't long for this world. Congress (both R and D alike) recognize this fact and want the USPS to actually fund their obligations so that 1M+ employees don't get a pension default and require a bailout.

Meanwhile FedEx and others are being subsidized through schemes like "SmartPost" where USPS has to accept responsibility for expensive last-mile delivery while FedEx makes most of the profits. The wonder is not that the USPS is having trouble, it's that it isn't having more given how the deck has been systematically stacked against them.

Which is it? You can't have it both ways.
Either USPS is a tax-supported agency which "subsidizes" FedEx, or it's not a tax-supported agency and they're simply servicing other couriers.

Oh and I'd say much the same about Amtrak if you actually look at what they have to deal with that their private competitors don't.

Further demonstrating that GSEs are a dangerous thing.
 
Does any other private company really want into the first class mail business anyhow? First class mail mail volume is way down.

Unless the USPS is shuttered totally, any private company would have to compete with the USPS. How could a private company deliver first class mail for the same cost as the USPS with all the additional taxes a private company pays?

Would a private company be allowed to pick and choose who they deliver to? The USPS has to deliver to everyone at the same cost. I'm sure it costs a lot more than 46 cents to deliver a first class letter to a remote Alaskan village by plane.
 
Does any other private company really want into the first class mail business anyhow? First class mail mail volume is way down.

Bulk and business mailing is the bread-and-butter of USPS.

Unless the USPS is shuttered totally, any private company would have to compete with the USPS. How could a private company deliver first class mail for the same cost as the USPS with all the additional taxes a private company pays?

They can't. But it doesn't really cost you 45 cents to mail a letter, either. The real cost is obfuscated by the tax exemptions and monopolies.

Would a private company be allowed to pick and choose who they deliver to? The USPS has to deliver to everyone at the same cost. I'm sure it costs a lot more than 46 cents to deliver a first class letter to a remote Alaskan village by plane.

It still costs more than 46 cents, you're just paying for it in taxes instead of in postage costs.
 
Since it is a clause in the Constitution is it even permitted for Congress to close the Post Office completely or do they need to figure out a way to make it work ... I doubt you are going to get too much interest in taking over the mail, although the package and PO Box side of the business is probably attractive to some takers
 
Since it is a clause in the Constitution is it even permitted for Congress to close the Post Office completely or do they need to figure out a way to make it work ... I doubt you are going to get too much interest in taking over the mail, although the package and PO Box side of the business is probably attractive to some takers

Correction there's no clause in the the Constitution that says there HAS to be a post office, the "Postal Clause" is basically what gives congress the power to essentially run the post office as they see fit, where mail offices are, routes (although this aspect is a bit outdated due to the road infrastructure we have today), basically they're the reason the post office spends as much as it does, and they're the reason why they're going bankrupt. Remember these are the same group of people that essentially told the Army they had to buy billions of dollars in tanks they didn't want, even though they have thousands literally collecting dust from non-usage. (and you can't blame this one on just democrats or just republicans, both are fuck ups)
 
Correction there's no clause in the the Constitution that says there HAS to be a post office, the "Postal Clause" is basically what gives congress the power to essentially run the post office as they see fit, where mail offices are, routes (although this aspect is a bit outdated due to the road infrastructure we have today), basically they're the reason the post office spends as much as it does, and they're the reason why they're going bankrupt. Remember these are the same group of people that essentially told the Army they had to buy billions of dollars in tanks they didn't want, even though they have thousands literally collecting dust from non-usage. (and you can't blame this one on just democrats or just republicans, both are fuck ups)

OK ... then I stand by my previous recommendation ... we don't privatize the post office, we shut down mail delivery completely ... if someone else wants to do it, Great ... if not, it is overdue for society to get rid of our environmentally unfriendly fascination with paper :cool:
 
1. FedEx - The service I trust the most. I dont recall a problem with them.
2. USPS - Routinely crush my mail and delivery my pay stubs to the neighbor.
3. UPS - Their Ninja delivery drivers ignore the Big Sign on the door: UPS: Please Ring Door Bell.
No point in getting any special delivery option with UPS.
Its always a delivery slip pick up with them.

I thought this is about Amazon choosing USPS as their Primary Carrier.
This could bring more money to the USPS but would it be enough to bring back quality people?
The longer the quality base erodes, the longer it will take to bring it back.

Quality is created with quality people.
 
But why would anyone choose USPS? They are slow, they treat your packages like crap, and they drop them pretty much anywhere on your property with no regard for weather.

Amen to that, I had a package left in the center of my garage a while ago and I ran it over with my car while I was backing out.
The package was far enough away from my roof over hang to be protected from rain, and but close enough to not be seen in my mirrors.
 
I'm sure Obama will be more than happy to issue another federal bailout of the USPS.

I don't understand this childish view, taxes are given to private corporations all the time, in many forms.
This republican's children's version of the world is really getting old.
Listen, the world does not work like that OK? Many, of 'the rich' did not make it on their own. Getting social security, medicare, medicaid and a tax-favored mail service (which is not to begin with, but since many on this post argue this stupidity) is not UN-fair to any one..
It is only the elite's view that those piles of money is theirs, since that is what they are used to, to begin with. Don't be a dumb-ass and believe them please?
 
It's funny the most 'advanced' and 'best' country in the world has no money to spend on healthcare, education, social services, science, any kind of reform, public transport, postal service etc.

But we have more than enough to spend on defense (more than the 10 next combined), wars, tax breaks to wealthy, protecting the word of God (as long as he's Christian), giving bailouts to hedge funds and banks (but not those who are poor).

This is a country run by the rich for the rich. The rest of us are told to 'dream big' about the 'American dream', live paycheck to paycheck and watch as the greatest transfer of wealth in history takes place.
 
It's funny the most 'advanced' and 'best' country in the world has no money to spend on healthcare, education, social services, science, any kind of reform, public transport, postal service etc.

But we have more than enough to spend on defense (more than the 10 next combined), wars, tax breaks to wealthy, protecting the word of God (as long as he's Christian), giving bailouts to hedge funds and banks (but not those who are poor).

This is a country run by the rich for the rich. The rest of us are told to 'dream big' about the 'American dream', live paycheck to paycheck and watch as the greatest transfer of wealth in history takes place.

We spend more on social programs and medical coverage than on defense. In fact this year defense spending shrunk while other social spending grew.
 
We spend more on social programs and medical coverage than on defense. In fact this year defense spending shrunk while other social spending grew.
He mucked up his own point of reducing defense spending to funnel into other areas. In reality in terms of % of gdp we don't spend all that much or less compared to counties with nationalized health care system and stronger social programs. What is said about that is we don't really spend less as a % of gdp on the avg we spend a little more and we offer less coverage to the average citizen. Problems with the postal server has to do with the bureaucracy dealing with it's business, it has small advantages mostly in sectors that nobody wants in on, in trade it's completely limited in its role, expansion and day to day operations. It is still the US' largest employer, along with being one of the largest employers of veterans.
 
I hear the doorbell and about .000025 seconds later a UPS/FedEx truck taking off lol.

^this. The driver just assumes no one is home during the day, or doesn't want to wait even a minute. I caught him running up to the front door with one of those 'sign here and leave it stuck to the door and I'll drop off your package tomorrow' stickers. Didn't even try to bring the package. Just run, stick on a sticker to the door, ring the doorbell a few times and get out of here as fast as they can. I know they're under pressure to deliver as many things as possible, but it's become ridiculous.

But USPS is even worse. They'll don't even ring the bell. Then I have to go to the friggin' post office to pick up the package.
 
Back
Top