help me find the bottleneck

foosh

n00b
Joined
Oct 16, 2004
Messages
11
recently, i just upgraded from XP Pro to Vista Home Premium 32bit at the same time as going from a 19" CRT to a DELL 2407 upping my resolution from 1280x1024 to 1920x1200.

at 1920x1200, my computer is really slow but its only the OS. ex: takes 15 seconds to open the startmenu plus increment 15 seconds to every tab open. so its frustrating searching thru the startmenu. scrolling will be slow. DVD movies are choppy. h264 videos are choppy. window explorer slows things down a lot. however, once i have an application open, say Opera, Outlook, Nero, or Media Center, things in there will run smooth.

however, when i lower my resolution down to 1680x1050, all the slowness goes away. however i would like to go back to 1920x1200.

is all this happening because my CPU is to slow or my videocard? basically can i fix the problem by upgrading one of those components? or both? and if its the videocard, could i get away with just a 8600gts (looking at an MSI fanless for $175). this is pretty much just a media pc and i dont play any intense games, mainly just Titan Quest. sometimes ill put in R6Vegas but that was before i upgraded. i dont want a major upgrade right now, just want things stable.

my pc specs:

p4 550 3.4ghz
geforce 6600gt
2gb ddr 533 ram
500watt xclio psu
37gb raptor hd
nec 3550a dvdrw
creative x-fi xtrememusic
vista home premium 32bit

what id really like to do is watch 1080p movies, some games, like WoW, Fanta Tennis, kmmo's
thanks in advance =)
 
Your issue is odd. The fact that you have problems running at native resolution, but can easily run 1680x1050 tells me that it's a video card issue. The 6600GT is the mid-range champ of 3 years ago, but I think that even then it fully supported 1920x1200 resolution.

Was your vista upgrade an "upgrade" or a completely formatted hard drive installation? That's something you can try if you haven't, but I think it's more a driver support issue.

A quick google brings up: 2048x1536 @ 85Hz as the maximum resoultion support for this card. Your 24" native resolution should be fine with that card as far as the windows interface. Your games will suck at that resolution, however. Most people will recommend a stronger card for your monitor if you game, like the 8800gts 640mb or the 8800gtx. That's at least twice what you want to spend however, so consider getting a x1950xt for about $170 AR.

This is, of course, if it's the issue with a 6600GT supporting 1920 reso in vista. Driver updated?
 
actually, i take back my suggestion on the x1950xt... seems like you're into watching movies, so the h.264 hardware decoder on the 8600gts will be nice while giving you decent gaming performance (though not as good as the x1950xt)
 
it was a clean install after a format. i have the latest geforce 6 drivers. (geforce 8 has newer drivers) i asked over at IGN and they think videocard too, but my friend insist its the CPU. even before, i had trouble running h264 but now i cant even run dvd's smoothly.

my resolution, the highest it will let me goto is 1920x1200. im connected thru DVI

my vista ratings are:
proc: 3.5
ram: 5.2
graphics: 5.2
gaming graphics: 4.3
hd: 5.3

overall 3.5
 
it was a clean install after a format. i have the latest geforce 6 drivers. (geforce 8 has newer drivers) i asked over at IGN and they think videocard too, but my friend insist its the CPU. even before, i had trouble running h264 but now i cant even run dvd's smoothly.

my resolution, the highest it will let me goto is 1920x1200. im connected thru DVI

my vista ratings are:
proc: 3.5
ram: 5.2
graphics: 5.2
gaming graphics: 4.3
hd: 5.3

overall 3.5

the cpu is slow, but not that slow. it should be able to do windows interface just fine. are you running aero? turn it off and see how performance is. if that fixes the slowdown issue, then your 6600gt just isn't fast enough to run vista aero at that resolution.
 
if your friend insists it's the cpu, have him prove it to you by letting you borrrow his video card (which i will assume is better than the 6600gt) to show you it's not the video card's issue. I really do not think it's the cpu's issue.
 
hmm okay i took off aero and the two resolutions do seem to perform about the same. so do the vista ratings not mean that much? because its pretty high.

i should probably note too my videocard is geforce 6600GT 128mb. if i were to upgrade, i would go for the MSI 8600gts

thank you so much for your help btw =)
 
hmm okay i took off aero and the two resolutions do seem to perform about the same. so do the vista ratings not mean that much? because its pretty high.

i should probably note too my videocard is geforce 6600GT 128mb. if i were to upgrade, i would go for the MSI 8600gts

thank you so much for your help btw =)

Go for the purchase. I didn't realize you were on a 128mb card, not 256mb. That's your limiting factor right there. The graphics score does not take into account your graphics card memory. And it also does not take a top notch card to max it out at 5.9 like it does for my 8800gts. My old 7600GT maxed it out also.

And you're welcome, it's my pleasure.
 
is vista doing a lot of 3d rendering for the OS? doubling my resolution, is that more stress on the videocard than it is on the processor, say even for games?
 
is vista doing a lot of 3d rendering for the OS? doubling my resolution, is that more stress on the videocard than it is on the processor, say even for games?

If aero feature is turned on, doubling resolution will stress video card more than it did before. In games, the aero feature automatically turns off so that it will not affect your gameplay. If you're gaming at 1920x1200, native reso. of 24", you will be more gpu bound than cpu bound. So purchasing a 8800gts, for example, will show you significant gameplay improvemnt over a 8600gts at those resoultions. At lower resolutions, lets say 1024 x 768, it's your cpu doing more of the work and the difference between these two cards is not as substantial. In other words, it will depend on your cpu speed at lower resolutions.
 
Back
Top