Help me build a computer animation/graphics computer

So it's looking like I'll want to spend $1500-$2000 if I want to get everything on my list.
 
I still say if you're gunning for actual 3D workstation performance, getting a card designed for that specific type of application will be superior to any "regular" video card, even the 8800 series. A Quadro based on a slightly older chipset will outperform the 8800 in serious OpenGL 3D applications like 3DStudio, Maya, etc especially if you use the certified drivers.

So that'll be a stickler there, you have to figure out do you want primarily gaming performance with lackluster but reasonable 3D application performance, or do you want kickass OpenGL 3D performance in the applications and still get some decent playability with the flipside and regular gaming.
 
Like I said before, or maybe it was in another thread about a new build - damned threads keep popping up constantly - some things you just have to decide for yourself based on personal taste, creativity, choice, style, etc.

With the case being the most visible aspect of a computer (as far as desktops are concerned), that's the most personally subjective decision of all, soooo... having said that, I wish you well in that decision 'cause I learned a long time ago to simply say "Have fun" at this point. :)
 
Buy a 8800 series if you plan on doing much gaming, otherwise consider workstation graphics cards.
 
What would you recommend for a $2000 3D workstation rig then?

Fixed...

And as I've said earlier, if the PC is geared and "designed" from the start to be used primarily for professional 3D graphics work, it wouldn't have an 8800 in it, regardless of the model, it would have a professional 3D graphics workstation card, aka an ATI FireGL card or an Nvidia Quadro of some kind, possibly even a 3DLabs card of some kind but it looks like they've basically fallen off the face of the earth.

Regardless, people seem to think that 8800 series is the cat's meow, and for gaming and entertainment purposes that might be the case, but you won't find an 8800 of any kind sitting in any workstation doing pro 3D graphics work because it's simply not designed for that activity. High end FireGLs and Quadros would leave that card standing still when it comes to OpenGL performance as required by the big apps like 3DStudio, Maya, SoftImage, etc.

For people that are serious about a 3D graphics workstation, spending half the budget on the video card isn't out of the question or even considered ridiculous; the video card is really the most important aspect of a 3D workstation, followed by the CPU and then the RAM which should definitely be maxed out on both counts if possible.
 
Well the OP never made the desision between gaming and workstation graphics so reccomending either is kind of pointless.

Nevertheless arguing on the internet is like running in the speical olympics, even if you win your still retarded. :p
 
I'm about to enroll in school soon for a computer animation degree. I know it's not required to have a computer that can do the things required in the class, but it's something that I want. I want to be able to practice what I have learned at home so that I'll stay ahead of my teachings, and I also want to be able to create my own animation for my webpages and music videos for my band.

That looks to me like a person with a goal in mind: a 3D workstation, not a gaming box. He does say a few sentences later that he games on the last machine he built 3 years ago, but that's not the reason for his post. The title of the thread is "Help me build a computer animation/graphics computer" and I don't see "gaming/entertainment" there anyplace.

You seem to be under the false impression that a high end 3D workstation card like a FireGL or a Quadro will suffer dramatic and horrible performance issues when playing games or watching movies, and that couldn't be further from the truth. The fact is that a FireGL or a Quadro is based on the same chipsets as those other gaming/entertainment cards but they are geared more towards OpenGL performance while still fully supporting Direct3D, but at a penalty in performance - maybe 20-30% overall.

Professional and high end 3D workstation applications like 3DStudio, Maya, SoftImage and others rely on the full OpenGL instruction set to do their jobs; all OpenGL games ever made and will ever be made only use a tiny subset of the entire OpenGL graphics library (hint, hint, the GL in OpenGL means Graphics Library/Libraries). Direct3D support is an option in some 3D applications, but the performance of OpenGL specifically trumps the Direct3D capabilities, and believe me, the professional graphics industry would just as soon commit suicide as use Direct3D as the API of choice.

If it's professional work, and it's 3D, it's OpenGL. Period.

So, based on everything the OP said in the OP, I see a person looking for a 3D workstation, not a gaming platform. Sure, he can play games on this box when it's done, and he's more than likely not going to notice the difference between 200 fps and 150 fps because he chose a FireGL or Quadro instead of the 8800 that everyone keeps trying to shove down his throat (ok, I'm exaggerating there, sue me).

And in the long run the card that puts out 150 fps in a game will put out even higher framerates in a 3D application with OpenGL than the 8800 can, and that's where the power of a real 3D workstation card comes from.

Just for the record, it's "you're still retarded." I'll let the "speical" slip slide on by. :)
 
Yes, like I have said many times... the main focus will be 3D Applications. I will definatly take into consideration the Quadro. I'd like to know exactly what are the downsides to getting it for gaming compared to the 8800.

Yet I am kinda torn because I'm a big fan of gaming. Crysis seems to be the big one this year and I would love to be able to run the game at max everything... play it at it's full potential.

So I'm not really sure what card I want to go with. I guess I need to do some research.

On another subject, what does anyone think of this ram for this rig? I'm thinking 2 packs of these to total 4 gigs of ram.

http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16820145034

Also, what about monitor? I'm only going to have enough to buy one at first. I'm thinking wide screen... something big.
 
That RAM is excellent, and Corsair makes solid products.

As for a monitor, well, here we go again. :D

If you're serious about the 3D career, you'll want to get the highest possible resolution LCD you can get your hands on at the lowest possible price but still get something that's high quality - talk about a tough call. The standard resolution for most widescreen LCDs these days is 1440x900 and that's on 19 inchers; on 20.1" to 22" inch models it's 1680x1050, and then the big enchilada for most people are the 24" models at 1920x1200. If you're independently wealthy the 30" Dell or Apple becomes a possibility at 2560x1600 is the cream of the crop, so to speak.

My suggestion: look for a 22" at 1680x1050 but keep checking prices on 24" models almost every single day because Dell has been known to sometimes just go nuts for a day or two and put up 24" LCDs for ridiculously low prices. That 1920x1200 resolution and 3D graphics were made for each other, I swear. :)

I can see this thread will be around for awhile... hehe
 
Ok.

Perhaps I can get an 8800 at first. And then when I start learning how to use the programs, I can get the quadro. How bad would it be to switch the cards out regularly depending on what I'm doing? I would think it wouldn't be a good idea.

Anyone know any articals that explain the downsides of using Quadro's for gaming?
 
Thanks for all the help, I have read the graphics card thread and have alot to think about and consider. I can't wait to have this thing finished.

Someone said that there would be a conciderable drop in quality with playing Crysis on a Quadro. I hope the difference really isn't that much. I have a fealing if I don't get a quadro, some people will be dissapointed. Either way, I'm losing quality on SOMETHING that I'll be doing with the computer.
 
You originally stated your purpose in your first post, so that's your goal: a 3D computer animation/graphics computer. Games should be a secondary concern, sooo... don't go waffling on yourself dammit. :p
 
Well... sence I wont be using the computer "right away" for computer animation, I might as well use it for gaming. I'm thinking that I'll buy an 8800 first. Maybe my 2nd simester... in Spring... I'll get a quadro. It may sound silly, but I might actualy switch them out every so often depending on what I'm doing. I'll be getting more money in January so this should be no problem.

This build so far, is almost $1000 more than what I was expecting to pay. I guess I wasn't think realisticly at first... although I really didn't know what I was looking for when posting this. Hopefully I'll be able to get it all.

So far, this is the build I'm looking at. Any opinions?

$159.99 MOTHERBOARD:

Gigabyte GA-P35C Intel P35 ATX
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16813128048

$266 CPU:

Core 2 Quad q6600
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16819115017&Tpk=core+2+quad+q6600

$160 RAM:

Patriot DDR2 1GB PC6400
http://shop4.outpost.com/product/5278197?site=sr:SEARCH:MAIN_RSLT_PG

$399.99 GRAPHICS CARD:

ASUS GeForce 8800GTS 640MB
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16814121034

$324.98 HARD DRIVES:

OS: Western Digital Raptor X WD1500AHFD 150GB 10,000 RP
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16822136011
DATA: Seagate 7200.10 500GB
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16822148135

$38.99 DVD BURNER:

Samsung Black 18X DVD+RW SATA W/ Light Scribe
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16827151141

$109.99 PSU:

Silverstone Zeus 640w
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16817163108&Tpk=silverstone+zeus

$169.00 CASE:

Thermaltake Armor Series VA8003BWS Black
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16811133021

MONITOR:

Still looking. Will probably get a 22" or 24"

TOTAL SO FAR:
$1631
 
Drop the Raptop, get some cheaper RAM and upgrade to the 8800GTX
 
Well... it's smart to have a seperate hard drive for the OS and programs right? I have a 300gig but it's full. I have an 80gig as well but i'm going to sell it with my current computer.

Will I notice a difference if I get cheaper ram?
 
Will I notice a difference if I get cheaper ram?

Not really. Just buy reasonably low latency DDR2-800 and you should be fine. Shouldn't cost more than $90 a kit. Crucial Ballistics is on sale (today is the last day) for $70 a kit after $45 MIR at Newegg, and unfortunately it's one of those "one per household" deals on the rebate.

You probably won't notice much difference between the Seagate 7200.10 drives and a Raptor, either. I'd just get a smaller Seagate (or even another 500GB) in place of it.
 
You're a student. The Professional 3D cards are for.... wait for it... pros. Seriously, the high end gaming cards are the poorman's openGL cards. I know a contractor who uses high end gaming cards instead, since he doesnt want to fork out the money on a prof. card, and he doesn't even game, lol. If some pro's can get by with high end gaming cards, I'm sure students could, too. Even when I was in college, the 3D Lab for undergrads used high end gaming cards instead of pro cards. Quadro's are priced for the businesses... not the student. You'll be fine with an 8800 until you graduate, lol, and maybe even afterwards, too.

Oh, and I agree on the RAM... you won't really notice the difference between CL4 and CL5, so go with the cheaper one. Damn, RAM already started going up... :(
 
Bleh.

You're paying too much for lackluster performance in some respects. Fry's regularly (and even right now) sells Patriot DDR2 800 4-4-4 RAM for $40 a stick - 4x40= $160, there's $100 you just saved on RAM right there. And the Patriot RAM is FASTER and yes you will notice it, especially since it's ~20% faster across the board in every timing instance that matters. Anyone would notice a 20% difference.

As for the Raptor, there's nothing short of SCSI or Fiber-Channel hardware that can match it for application performance, not even the much vaunted Seagate 7200.10 line of drives. The Raptor excels in loading the small stuff since it was and still is primarily geared towards server duties with lots of little transactions. The Seagate 7200.10 series has been shown that, in the long run, it can keep up with Raptors (even the Raptor 150GB) in sustained reads and sustained writes, but in application load times and application performance, the Raptor will spank it like a redheaded stepchild.

My suggestion about the Raptor was because (not thinking about games) I know the 3D applications mentioned already are "beasts" and take time to load even on normal hardware, so a Raptor would provide him with a noticeable and far more snappy load time without him needing to get double drives and do RAID duties with bigger and technically slower drives. Sure he can get something like 2 Seagate 320GB 7200.10 drives and RAID 0 them together for increased performance, but having a Raptor as a separate application/operating system drive and extra drives like the 7200.10 series as storage space would give him a wicked fast system all around. I don't think anyone would dispute the performance aspects of my suggestions.

You can find ridiculously powerful Quadros for roughly the same price as an 8800 GTS these days, for a few more bucks (reaching into the $500-600 range, surprisingly right where a lot of 8800 GTX cards are) you can get even more powerful Quadros, but it seems that the OP has waffled a bit and the attraction of gaming has crept in (awwww...). I still say a Quadro is the best card for your machine, but so be it. All we can do is make suggestions. Whatever is "top end" today will be replaced by far more powerful hardware between now and next spring, I just hate seeing someone spend money only to realize < 12 months later the dreaded "Dammit I should have <insert condition here>" situation and kick themselves for not making the other choice the first time.

There's nothing wrong with the 8800 cards, I know this, I know their rep and I've built several machines using them, but for the 3D workstations I build (and I have 27 people that are currently enrolled in animation courses at UNLV that own machines I've built by hand and not one of them has anything but a Quadro in 'em - and those people game just fine, thank you very much) never use gaming cards, there's just no point when the Quadro is basically the same hardware and can perform just as well minus a few points on performance. As we say, really people, what's the difference between 150 fps and 200 fps?

I know the DX10 capabilities of the 8800 series are the big draw especially since the OP said "Crysis," and once he said that I already knew where he was going like an entire page ago in this thread. :D

So, have fun building it, look around for better pricing and don't limit yourself to Newegg unless you have a Newegg credit card and you're stuck. Fry's sells their products online most of the time, and that Patriot RAM is better than the Corsair by quite a margin - not only on price. They had the Q6600 yesterday for $266 + a crappy mobo for $33 (package deal out the door for $299) at the actual retail stores or the Q6600 itself online for $299, so the price drops are rolling in and Fry's is leading the way. Newegg actually increased their price for the Q6600 on July 4th to a max of $649!!! Right now it sits at $480, but even so, that's some fuckin' ridiculous price fluctuation in light of competition, and downright scandalous I'd say.

500GB Seagate 7200.10 drives for $89.99... geez, I hate being broke. :)

If you have questions, I'm around, and I'll help if I can.

Good luck...
 
Thanks for the link to the patriot ram, I will definatly get that instead! I'll edit the post with that ram and link.

I do think I'll go with the raptor.

I know a Quadro is best for the apps, which is why I will most likely get one in January.

Thanks for all the responces.
 
Either get a Quadro or a 8800GTS/X don't buy one now and the other later on. If you want a Quadro then buy one now and SLI later if you feel the need. :p
 
Back
Top