Has the Plasma Display Reached EOL?

I would choose a Plasma over an LCD anyday. In fact, I have a 42" Plasma in my garage. (has a bit of burn-in :D )
plasma01.jpg

If you take that set and set it to a non channel, that is all you get is the black and white raster and bump the brightness up a bit then allow it to run say two or three days I think you will find a great deal of the burn in gone.

Just a little industry trick;)
 
Why would I want a TV that will be washed out within a few years? My friend owns a timeshare in Vegas and they put brand new 42" plasmas in every room. Within two years, they were essentially black-and-white TVs from all the use they got. That convinced me to never buy a plasma.

That myth was debunked years ago. I have a 5 year old Pioneer 50” Elite and recently snagged a new 50” Elite Kuro. Put side by side and taking into account the change in panel technology there are no washed out colors and not even a noticeable difference in brightness.

I think the biggest problem plasma faces was the colors dieing after 5 or so years and they really never found a fix for this.

See above and the "fix" was simply buying a better set.

Somebody brought up dot craw. Any set with a crap comb filter is going to have dot crawl.

With a 3-D or 3DYC comb filter there is no problem regardless of the tech behind the set.
 
Agreed, I'd grab up a Plasma any day, so what if it dies in 5 years, so does every piece of tech these days and or it's severely outdated anyway! I know it's a big investment, so is a large LCD TV. Which are you going to enjoy more throughout it's lifetime? What about LCD backlight life, what about it's dimishing brightness?

By the time it dies, we may be running 1600P.

With the stuff we watch now, a mix of SD, DVD, and HD/Gaming, I'd rather take a $1000-$1500 720P plasma and enjoy it till a better or improved tech comes around.
 
Agreed, I'd grab up a Plasma any day, so what if it dies in 5 years, so does every piece of tech these days and or it's severely outdated anyway! I know it's a big investment, so is a large LCD TV. Which are you going to enjoy more throughout it's lifetime? What about LCD backlight life, what about it's dimishing brightness?

By the time it dies, we may be running 1600P.

With the stuff we watch now, a mix of SD, DVD, and HD/Gaming, I'd rather take a $1000-$1500 720P plasma and enjoy it till a better or improved tech comes around.

That and plasmas generally look better. :cool:
 
Every HD TV regardless of technology as a rule makes a bad or at best a less then acceptable computer monitor.

Two very different designs made for two very different purposes.;)
I don't see such a big difference. Obviously dot pitch is bigger, which I don't see as being an issue for movies and gaming. Other than that, an lcd hdtv panel doesn't seem any different from a monitor, provided it's used in 1:1 pixel pc mode (sidestepping the built in video processor). Response times are similar and if anything the tv will be newer tech since product cycles seem to be a lot shorter in the tv industry.

It's hard to see how a 32" IPS or PVA tv with 1920x1080 res is going to be vastly different from a 27" monitor with practically the same res. YMMV of course but I have to be less than a foot away to notice the bigger dot pitch. For me, text is perfectly acceptable with a 40" 1080p at my normal viewing distance, the price is about the same as a 30" monitor, much more screen area for movies and gaming and I don't need SLI to drive it properly.
 
AND DLP is much cheaper. My wife and I picked up a 50" Samsung in January of '07 for $1000. I don't think either Plasma or LCD will be that cheap any time soon.

I would have prefered plasma to DLP honestly but the I couldn't justify the cost at the time. A 42" plasma at the time cost almost $1,000 more. I figured I'd go with the DLP which was cheaper, still looked good, and was 10" larger.

I got my 42" Panny plasma (admittedly 1080i) for a little under a grand during last year's Black Friday deals. In my case, larger than 42" would be too big for our living environment.

Plasmas have gotten a lot cheaper in the past year, though they definitely were higher at one point.
 
BTW- I have not seen anyone mention power consumption figures, that alone is enough to doom plasma screens in some markets.

I know they are fobidden in the building I work at (127 beds)
 
Most consumers are not geeky fans. LCDs are winning by far due to price, which can scale down a lot more than plasma can, and features because there's a lot more competition. Plasma used to be a very profitable niche when flat screen HDTVs commanded huge price premiums. Plasma makers are finding it hard to compete even when they drop prices by 50-66%, and the field of offerings continues to dwindle.

Except in the 42"-50" range (where plasmas and LCD intersect). Here, LCDs typically cost more (not less) than plasmas of the same size; worse, an LCD, until recently, often lacked features compared to a same-size plasma. The only feature that an LCD in that size range offers today that a plasma would lack is 1080p resolution, and that's only relevant if you watch mostly/primarily BD or use it as a PC screen (otherwise, the typical TV resolution will be, at best 1080i).

What is really a shame is one feature that has been dying even faster: CableCARD support (in all TVs, and especially flat-panel TVs). I bought my Philips 42PF7320A/37A (a close-out at a local warehouse club) when I did because it was the largest wall-mountable TV I could get for my bedroom that both supported CableCARD and was affordable (the only LCD with even most of the same features was ten inches smaller and cost $200 more), and I paid less than $1700. Nowadays, you can't buy a TV with CableCARD support for less than $4000 unless it's a close-out projection TV (this includes any DLP, which is a varant of RPTV). Instead, you are *sentenced* to getting a STB (if you're a cable subscriber), even if you have a new flat-panel TV.
 
AND DLP is much cheaper. My wife and I picked up a 50" Samsung in January of '07 for $1000. I don't think either Plasma or LCD will be that cheap any time soon.

DLP is a projection-based technology (smaller mirrors, but essentially a variant of old RPTV technology); whereas both typical LCD and plasma are direct-view technologies (similar to CRT). Also, DLP is still not exactly easy to wall-mount (a DLP TV is heavier than a same-sized plasma, and is also "thicker" from back-to-front), and even DLP has a minimum practical size (just as LCD has a maximum practical size, which just recently entered the 40"-50" crossing point usually inhabited by plasmas). The one advantage DLP does have (it's a common advantage shared by almost all projection formats in this size category compared to a same-size direct-view set) is price (in fact, DLP TVs are replacing more traditional RPTVs in this size class). However, there are two trade-offs that any DLP TV makes compared to both plasma *and* LCD TVs: picture sharpmess (plasmas still have it over LCDs in this area, for the most part) and weight/ease of mounting (plasmas and LCDs can be wall-mounted, even in the 40"+ size ranges, which isn't exactly easy with a DLP TV of any size). You still have to decide what trade-offs you are willing to make.
 
I love my 42 inch 1080P Panny Plasma. I got it for less than $1300 AR just in time for the NFL playoffs. Watching sports, especially football, is one of the primary uses of this set and the potential for motion blur on LCDs (even the more expensive 120Hz models) was a deal breaker.
 
Back
Top