Why is Major "clearly" a Caucasian woman? What from the source material (the comic that was serialized between 1989 and 1990) says she is "clearly" a Caucasian woman?
Most Japanese person I've ever seen.
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
Why is Major "clearly" a Caucasian woman? What from the source material (the comic that was serialized between 1989 and 1990) says she is "clearly" a Caucasian woman?
When Hollywood gambles on an unproven white actor it is for the role cast as a white character. Hollywood isnt going to double down and cast an asian for a white character who is also unproven as an actress.I didn't say it was an example. I said it was a counterexample to the money argument. Your words: "I said hollywood isnt going to gamble on unproven asian actors." Yet, Hollywood has shown time and time again that they are willing, more than willing, to gamble on unproven white actors. This shows that it's not the "unproven" that matters; it's the "asian/white" that matters.
Her fucking appearance.You have given no argument to support your claim that Motoko Kusanagi is white.
Your source material extends into realms that hollywood producers would never touch. It's sorta like screaming something isnt authentic because they forgot about how the 3rd spinoff in Manga #265 has a single blurb describing some random factoid that only diehard extremist fans would know about. This movie was sourced from one thing and one thing only, the original GITS anime that went mainstream, and even then they practically changed the entire fucking storyline. All they were really after was the style of GITS. All the hard work such as the action scenes were done for them. With that kind of budget they had a pretty easy task ahead of them; a literal translation of the GITS movie would have succeeded, but for reasons unknown somebody meddled with the story in what was likely some attempt to make it easier to understand. Truthfully we'll never know why they fucked this up, but had this film been a carbon copy of the 1st GITS movie Major still would have been recognized as an obviously white woman.In fact, you all admitted that you didn't have an argument since you said the source material should be ignored.
![]()
Most Japanese person I've ever seen.
When Hollywood gambles on an unproven white actor it is for the role cast as a white character.
Your source material extends into realms that hollywood producers would never touch. It's sorta like screaming something isnt authentic because they forgot about how the 3rd spinoff in Manga #265 has a single blurb describing some random factoid that only diehard extremist fans would know about.
Because white people have eyes that take up 1/4 to 1/3 their faces. Obviously.![]()
Omg you're such a fucking TOOL dude... The choice to draw enlarged eyes is a cultural style that almost all animes utilize. BLUE FUCKING EYES AND AN ANGULAR JAW LINE IS NOT. I suppose if a black anime hero had giant eyes they too would be considered japanese right? Because I mean whats the skin color have to do with anything, could just be a stylistic choice. We have an entire facial structure that is clearly caucasian to support my argument. You have a fucking name. Thats it, her fucking name sounds Japanese so boom, alexyang: 1 / nysmo: 0Because white people have eyes that take up 1/4 to 1/3 their faces. Obviously.
Thanks for admitting that the money argument is crap. It isn't about Asian actors playing characters you mistakenly think are white. It just boils down to refusing to take gambles on Asian actors but being willing to take gambles on white actors.
And as I've said for I-don't-want-to-count times, this movie is based on the anime FILM. Not the fucking comic, the FILM. The FILM. Do you hear me? THEEEEE FILLLLMMMM. All extraneous details thereon are completely irrelevant. It doesnt matter what the film is based upon. And even THEN they still changed numerous details to suit what they thought audiences would want to see.Yeah, except as I've said for I-don't-want-to-count times, my evidence from the source material is literally page 1 of the comic.
Translation: I got owned and am still trying to pretend that Egypt isn't an Arab country.
I ask again who would you like to have seen in GITS?
Omg you're such a fucking TOOL dude... The choice to draw enlarged eyes is a cultural style that almost all animes utilize. BLUE FUCKING EYES AND AN ANGULAR JAW LINE IS NOT. I suppose if a black anime hero had giant eyes they too would be considered japanese right? Because I mean whats the skin color have to do with anything, could just be a stylistic choice. We have an entire facial structure that is clearly caucasian to support my argument. You have a fucking name. Thats it, her fucking name sounds Japanese so boom, alexyang: 1 / nysmo: 0
Jesus... am I being trolled here?
Hollywood historically takes very little gamble on unproven white actors too jackass. When possible they always go for a star. So obviously they are going to take even FEWER chances on unproven actors of different countries.
And as I've said for I-don't-want-to-count times, this movie is based on the anime FILM. Not the fucking comic, the FILM. The FILM. Do you hear me? THEEEEE FILLLLMMMM. All extraneous details thereon are completely irrelevant. It doesnt matter what the film is based upon. And even THEN they still changed numerous details to suit what they thought audiences would want to see.
No, I said that Omar Sharif was Egyptian, not Arab. (he wasn't even born Muslim) The entire West wants to label everyone from the Middle East area Arab, and the only true Arabs are from Saudi Arabia. Most Egyptians, Lebanese, Syrians, Libyans and even many Jordanians do not consider themselves Arabs... And I've met people from Egypt that would take offense if you called them Arabs- because it's grossly inaccurate. Even genographic studies of Egyptians show that less than 20% of their genetic makeup is Arabian, and the bulk of the heritage is North African. And the Egyptians were around LONG before there were Arabs or even Islam.
But keep pasting those cute links about the Arab League. It's certainly more useful than your constant droning on about GitS was a comic book once upon a time.
Newsflash, eye color is a product of DNA. Asian people lack this gene and thus do not have blue eyes. Shocker I know, but look at some pictures of Asian people and see how often blue eyes turn up in the mix. You might as well tell me "you're looking at skin color to determine race? omg"You're grasping at EYE COLOR to determine race
The quote you are referencing was meant to establish that we dont factor in race at all when it comes to casting leads in a film where race isnt a prerequisite (since you're so goddamn hung up that Major's caucasian appearance is purely coincidental and obvious glaring genetic attributes that belong exclusively to certain races are totally irrelevant). It's all about name recognition and/or ability. You're the one hung up on race. You want to know why Americans dominate the American film scene? Because thats where all the work is nimrod. Do you see anybody crying that there arent more americans starring in kung fu movies? Just google "top asian actors". They're all a bunch of nobody's that couldnt act their way out of a paper bag. You've got the guy from Lost that nobody remembers. The dude who gets his head bashed in from The Walking Dead. Jackie Chan who while an amazing choreographer is probably one of the worst actors of all time. Americans simply churn out the biggest stars. Even if you had some amazing thought provoking tear jerking capable asian actor get a starring role in the biggest American film, there's still a good chance he'd fail to connect with American audiences due to things like language barrier, appearance, etc. It's the same fucking reason Japan isnt recruiting top American talent for their films. Despite how great Tom Hanks is, he's just not relatable to asian audiences.Different countries? I'm talking about Asian Americans, Mr. "I'm not a racist, but I asked why should Asian Americans star in American films even though I know that I'd never ask why should white Americans star in American films."
Why the fuck do you keep referencing the comic when we're talking about the film?Translation: Ignore the original comic because it doesn't support my argument.
Newsflash, eye color is a product of DNA. Asian people lack this gene and thus do not have blue eyes. Shocker I know, but look at some pictures of Asian people and see how often blue eyes turn up in the mix. You might as well tell me "you're looking at skin color to determine race? omg"
It's all about name recognition and/or ability. You're the one hung up on race. You want to know why Americans dominate the American film scene?
Why the fuck do you keep referencing the comic when we're talking about the film?
Do you think this is a reasonable assumption to make? That Motoko is actually japanese and just decided to wear some blue eye contacts because it looks fashionable? In the world of anime hair-color is never explained, it's just one of those colorful adaptations that exists as part of a character in a fictional world. Not every person who has green hair in an anime has a back story of when and why they began to dye it. It's not dye, it's just style.And are we just pretending to ignore that in a world that clearly has green and purple hair dye, color contact lenses don't exist?
That particular design of superman was from a single era of a cartoon series done purely for stylistic reasons. It is already well-established what ethnicity superman is. Quit being a douche.Seriously, "eye color + jaw line = white" is an incredibly dumb argument when we're talking about cartoony character designs. Like I said, if you want to go there, DCAU Superman is an alien who looks like an Asian man.
You cannot accept the fact that there are no good Asian American actors that would ever be cast in a leading role for a movie like this, or likely any movie. But awww why wont hollywood just give them a handout? I mean they did it fucking 10 years ago for that one movie nobody saw that got terrible reviews. Good reason to do it again.Jesus Christ, you just cannot accept that Asian Americans are Americans.
Of course I'm talking about the adaptation you fucking dolt, BECAUSE THATS WHAT THE NEW MOVIE IS BASED UPON. You're just so desperately grasping at straws you keep referencing totally unrelated material trying to move the goal posts to suit your argument that an obviously blue eyed white woman should have been cast with an asian woman, given contact lenses, had $100,000 in plastic surgery or CGI face fx to make her look white, all because her name starts with Motoko and because you always envisioned her as a Japanese woman.You're talking about the 1995 animated adaptation.
Do you think this is a reasonable assumption to make? That Motoko is actually japanese and just decided to wear some blue eye contacts because it looks fashionable? In the world of anime hair-color is never explained, it's just one of those colorful adaptations that exists as part of a character in a fictional world. Not every person who has green hair in an anime has a back story of when and why they began to dye it. It's not dye, it's just style.
That particular design of superman was from a single era of a cartoon series done purely for stylistic reasons. It is already well-established what ethnicity superman is. Quit being a douche.
You cannot accept the fact that there are no good Asian American actors that would ever be cast in a leading role for a movie like this, or likely any movie. But awww why wont hollywood just give them a handout? I mean they did it fucking 10 years ago for that one movie nobody saw that got terrible reviews. Good reason to do it again.
Of course I'm talking about the adaptation you fucking dolt, BECAUSE THATS WHAT THE NEW MOVIE IS BASED UPON. You're just so desperately grasping at straws you keep referencing totally unrelated material trying to move the goal posts to suit your argument that an obviously blue eyed white woman should have been cast with an asian woman, given contact lenses, had $100,000 in plastic surgery or CGI face fx to make her look white, all because her name starts with Motoko and because you always envisioned her as a Japanese woman.
Because there is an obvious line drawn between style and substance. Anime characters have flashy hair because it looks cool, but it's clear when they are trying to define the ethnicity of a character though other means such as skin and eye color. To claim that Motoko is a Japanese woman and 100% of her caucasian appearance is just 'because it looks cool' is ridiculous and you know it.So you accept green and purple hair as "just one of those colorful adaptations that exists as part of a character in a fictional world," but eye color, DNA, genetics. Got it.
Thats great, and guess what, if they made a movie francise based around THAT EXACT MATERIAL then I would expect to see Dean playing the lead role. Or if there were any other superman spin-off that was merely an adaptation of something I would expect the actors to resemble who they're playing. You know, kinda like how Scar Jo is a spitting image of Motoko. Still curious who you'd nominate for the role, since we already know any Asian woman would require extensive "reconditioning" to even look remotely close to Motoko.BTW, you know Dean Cain was born Dean Tanaka and is half-Japanese?
The Last Airbender, your one and only example of a big budget hollywood movie that did not cast a Caucasian as the lead.Which movie are you talking about?
"Totally unrelated" was not the best choice of words, but the point still stands. Whenever you are making an adaptation of an adaptation, in this case a live action film based upon an anime based upon a manga, the 3rd degree of separation there does not count. GITS film was based upon the GITS anime, you need not look any deeper than that.Yes, the original comic that started the franchise is "totally unrelated material." You people are idiots.
Because there is an obvious line drawn between style and substance. Anime characters have flashy hair because it looks cool, but it's clear when they are trying to define the ethnicity of a character though other means such as skin and eye color. To claim that Motoko is a Japanese woman and 100% of her caucasian appearance is just 'because it looks cool' is ridiculous and you know it.
Thats great, and guess what, if they made a movie francise based around THAT EXACT MATERIAL then I would expect to see Dean playing the lead role. Or if there were any other superman spin-off that was merely an adaptation of something I would expect the actors to resemble who they're playing. You know, kinda like how Scar Jo is a spitting image of Motoko. Still curious who you'd nominate for the role, since we already know any Asian woman would require extensive "reconditioning" to even look remotely close to Motoko.
The Last Airbender, your one and only example of a big budget hollywood movie that did not cast a Caucasian as the lead.
"Totally unrelated" was not the best choice of words, but the point still stands. Whenever you are making an adaptation of an adaptation, in this case a live action film based upon an anime based upon a manga, the 3rd degree of separation there does not count. GITS film was based upon the GITS anime, you need not look any deeper than that.
No, thats not what I said at all. If they want to re-invent superman thats fine, and then if they continue that lineage into a new feature film that is a DIRECT ADAPTATION then it would stand to reason they should continue the look and feel of that character. Superman has been around forever. GITS has no such luxury to have numerous adaptations as its history and attempts to relaunch are far fewer, especially when put in context to popular culture. The only GITS most people are familiar with is the original anime, hence the reason hollywood decided to adapt that version.Funny how you don't seem to follow your obvious line. For DCAU Superman, eye color etc. should be ignored. Go with the comics.
When you say extensive reconditioning, you mean basic makeup, right?
![]()
So a movie that gave handouts to white actors is why we shouldn't give handouts to Asian American actors. Do you have any sense of what the word "logic" means?
So, your argument that this is an adaptation of an adaptation is not supported.
No, thats not what I said at all. If they want to re-invent superman thats fine, and then if they continue that lineage into a new feature film that is a DIRECT ADAPTATION then it would stand to reason they should continue the look and feel of that character. Superman has been around forever. GITS has no such luxury to have numerous adaptations as its history and attempts to relaunch are far fewer, especially when put in context to popular culture. The only GITS most people are familiar with is the original anime, hence the reason hollywood decided to adapt that version.
Who the fuck is that and why should any producer drop 100 mill budget on her?
Do you honestly believe no-name Asian American actors deserve an equal shot vs A-list celebrity American actors?
WTF are you going on about? Let me break this down nice and simple for you.
1. GITS anime
2. GITS live action movie
3. The end
Thats all that is being referenced here. Thats all hollywood cared to reference. Nobody could give a fuck less what Kazuki Ito doodled in high school in the 60's that inspired him to create the GITS universe since thats all part of the original history of the manga. You have 1 movie that was adapted for a live action film. Quit talking about all this other bullshit.
Ghost in the Shell is a 2017 American science fiction action film directed by Rupert Sanders and written by Jamie Moss, William Wheeler and Ehren Kruger, based on the Japanese manga of the same name by Masamune Shirow.
On a visit to the set, Collider talked to producer Avi Arad, who said the following:
We’re not doing Puppetmaster. It’s not Laughing Man. It involves Kuze. The Kuze story. The big thing we are doing here is that we’re not necessarily doing an origins backstory, but we are addressing her sense of self and resolving how she defines herself in terms of memories. That’s one of the main thrusts in the story. Inspired by that episode of Affection in Second Gig. It’s bits and pieces of those mixed together.
“Kuze” is referring to the main antagonist of the GitS TV series Stand Alone Complex: 2nd Gig, where Major Motoko Kusanagi and Section 9 fight a terrorist group called the Individual Eleven, of which Kuze is a member.
http://io9.gizmodo.com/we-finally-know-what-part-of-ghost-in-the-shell-the-mov-1788549513
first shows you were wrong that shirow wrote it(movie script). youre welcome
second shows that you guys were both wrong and its based on SAC, not the manga or the first movie. youre welcome.
Keep bringing up irrelevant story arcs and trying to distract from the conversation because you know you're wrong.tl;dr Ignore the original Ghost in the Shell comic because it contradicts my arguments.
But that person doesnt look anything like Motoko. Scar Jo does. Plus Scar Jo has proven she can act. Win Win.An example of how basic makeup is what you really mean by extensive reconditioning.
Why would you cast an asian actor for a caucasian role all things being equal?I honestly believe no-name Asian American actors deserve an equal shot vs no-name white American actors.
Who cares what patronage they decided to "honor" somebody with. You've seen the movie, which does it more accurately represent story/action/scenery wise, the comic or the anime?Yet, you continue to argue that the 2017 film is an adaptation of the 1995 animated adaptation.
the movie was not based around this version of the character, please try to focus.Purple colored hair and violet eyes. Those just scream Caucasian woman to me.
Keep bringing up irrelevant story arcs and trying to distract from the conversation because you know you're wrong.
But that person doesnt look anything like Motoko. Scar Jo does. Plus Scar Jo has proven she can act. Win Win.
Why would you cast an asian actor for a caucasian role all things being equal?
Who cares what patronage they decided to "honor" somebody with. You've seen the movie, which does it more accurately represent story/action/scenery wise, the comic or the anime?
the movie was not based around this version of the character, please try to focus.
We’re not doing Puppetmaster. It’s not Laughing Man. It involves Kuze. The Kuze story. The big thing we are doing here is that we’re not necessarily doing an origins backstory, but we are addressing her sense of self and resolving how she defines herself in terms of memories. That’s one of the main thrusts in the story. Inspired by that episode of Affection in Second Gig. It’s bits and pieces of those mixed together.
yeah actually you were both wrong about which version it was from that's why I posted it. but that doesn't mean he gets to use it as an argument against you now...the movie was not based around this version of the character, please try to focus.
![]()
Such whitewashing ermagerd. Definitely should have cast this random fucker as the role, no way can Scarlett be trusted to deliver a movie. Anyway, you bore me now.
This argument is still going on.
Not to add more fuel to an already raging fire. But I had an interesting discussion yesterday with the people in my department that plays a lot into choices of movie studios as I know these people aren't alone. One person was saying that they never watch indy films and actually goes as far as if he turns on a movie and doesn't see a single person in the first 15 minutes that he knows from something else he will turn the movie off. So he will never watch a movie that is 100% unknowns. Somebody else was kind of the same way, she will only watch movies that have big named actors or actresses in it that she knows.
Stuff like that is why you see a movie where some big named actor is heavy promoted for the movie even if they are only in it for 5 minutes. The last US made Godzilla movie is proof of that. You can then trick these people into the theater. Because sadly the mindset that my people have is the same mindset that the average population has.
Translation: I've been talking out of my ass for the past week insisting that instead of reading literally two sentences on page 1 of the original comic, we should rely upon "blue eyes" and the "angular jaw line" from the 1995 animated film adaptation to conclude that Motoko Kusanagi is a white woman. Now I've been told that the 2017 film actually adapts a key storyline from the 2004 animated cartoon, which depicts Motoko Kusanagi with purple hair and violet eyes.
Instead of admitting that I've been talking out of my ass for the past week, I'm going to continue to insist that the 1995 animated film adaptation depiction of Motoko Kusanagi is the one to use because obviously, I can't argue that a character with purple hair and violet eyes is white anymore. I am not a racist even though I rhetorically ask questions about Asian Americans that I would never ask about white or black Americans.
Translation from pig-latin to reality: I've been insisting a blue eyed white skinned female with obvious caucasian characteristics is in fact a japanese woman wearing contacts because she has a japanese name. I do this so I can furiously shake my first in the air and proclaim hollywood start dumping hundreds of millions of dollars on unproven actors in the hopes that it all works out in the end. PM for more great tips on stocks, bonds, and how diversify your portfolio.
Clearly their primary focus was on recreating the look and feel of the anime film. For some reason they felt the need to mix and match certain details and basically rewrite core components of the story because I guess producers felt the anime itself wouldnt stand alone. It's hollywood afterall, they make stupid decisions about adaptations like this all the time. But from the action scenes to the cityscape and backdrop, the film is recreating the anime.This is a far more interesting choice than just a live-action redo of the first anime film, though Arad says there will be plenty of visual references to the original.
I noticed Netflix is doing a Death Note movie and the lead looks white. I don't recall if the anime character had distinctly caucasian or asian features or not.