Gaping Flaw in Microsoft's 'Do Not Track' System

CommanderFrank

Cat Can't Scratch It
Joined
May 9, 2000
Messages
75,399
Microsoft touted a ‘Do Not Track’ by default feature incorporated into Internet Explorer 10 earlier in the year, leaving many Internet advertisers more than just a little upset over the move. They were upset for nothing it seems, since the track mechanism turns out to be largely voluntary on the advertisers part. This could be one of the reasons we haven’t heard much from Explorer 10 lately.

Without cookies, advertising on the web is a largely random, untargeted affair—and advertisers won't tolerate it.
 
Why is it largely random and untargeted? If you visit [H] you probably want computer gear, etc etc.
 
Gaping flaw ? It is like saying that possibility to put images on a web page is a gaping flaw.

DNT works exactly like robots.txt - you can honor it, or ignore it.
 
The "gaping flaw" has been allowing cookies and information gathering by default AT ALL.

The advertisers can and should have to live with knowing no more than the conected IP address and the general location of that address. That is plenty enough information to make good guesses about how many people from what few square miles.
 
I don't care, just as long as someone finds the person (or persons) responsible for putting those absolutely annoying video-with-sound-that-you-cant-fucking-turn-off ads on so many pages.

I don't use adblock apps because I like to support a lot of the sites that I visit (even random ones). But it's getting absolutely absurd. Even random (left alone) pages will cue up an annoyance.
 
I don't care, just as long as someone finds the person (or persons) responsible for putting those absolutely annoying video-with-sound-that-you-cant-fucking-turn-off ads on so many pages.
Those are the worst, and they're always at full volume, so even though your sound's at a reasonable level, they're still loud. It really kills me when I've open several tabs and then once they've loaded I have to find the one pesky site that's making my ears bleed. :mad:
 
I don't care, just as long as someone finds the person (or persons) responsible for putting those absolutely annoying video-with-sound-that-you-cant-fucking-turn-off ads on so many pages.

I don't use adblock apps because I like to support a lot of the sites that I visit (even random ones). But it's getting absolutely absurd. Even random (left alone) pages will cue up an annoyance.

I enjoy the adblock that keeps me from getting caught up in that mess. To each their own though.
 
It's very easy to add a *.something.com or whatnot to Internet Explorer's restricted site list and never see cookies or ads from that site. I have a running list of domains that I restrict which I add to once in a while by peeking into IE's cache folder. I had to figure that out to keep Adobe Flash installer notifications from coming up since I don't have Flash on any of my computers at home and every site in the world wants to install it. Restricting *.adobe.com got rid of it and I just kept going from there to clear the really nefarious ones.

You have to do stuff like that to keep enough memory and CPU power free on a 766 MHz Celeron with 320 MB of PC-100 RAM anyhow or the Internet becomes a really miserable wait while your poor processor works its little tail off. :(

Cut out font smoothing, tell the browser to not run animations, and then there's enough PC left to play MP3s or open LibreOffice too! :)
 
Those are the worst, and they're always at full volume, so even though your sound's at a reasonable level, they're still loud. It really kills me when I've open several tabs and then once they've loaded I have to find the one pesky site that's making my ears bleed. :mad:

Yep. It may seem like a perfect idea from the marketard that dreamed it up, but it is just forcing people to adblock. Best course of action is to allow for people to force no sound unless they initiate the play. So no autoplay w/sound.
 
Yep. It may seem like a perfect idea from the marketard that dreamed it up, but it is just forcing people to adblock. Best course of action is to allow for people to force no sound unless they initiate the play. So no autoplay w/sound.

I enjoy the adblock that keeps me from getting caught up in that mess. To each their own though.

Yeah, I know it's all based on opinion. But I understand that these sites run based on ad revenue otherwise they don't exist. They supply content based on that.

It's a different paradigm than with TV (for example) where we're paying for access to channels that pays directly to the content providers who are also forcing commercials down our throat.
 
I don't understand DNT. Doesn't it basically just ask third parties to voluntarily not set cookies? Isn't there already a setting in all the major browsers to allow you to forcibly block all third party cookies? I know IE and Chrome have it.

Secondly, from reading the draft (http://tools.ietf.org/pdf/draft-mayer-do-not-track-00.pdf) it seems like there's a pretty big exception that allows you to be tracked provided the data collected can't be linked to you personally (section 9.3.3) Don't the big trackers (like Google) already make that claim?

Thirdly, what's to keep first parties - which are already willing participants in the tracking by linking to the third parties - from tracking you and selling or giving that information to the third parties?
 
I don't mind non-intrusive advertising, but all of this tracking creepiness makes me hope someone finds a way to bankrupt these scumbags.
 
Why is it largely random and untargeted? If you visit [H] you probably want computer gear, etc etc.

That's not good enough. They want to know what you're specifically interested in right this moment. They want to know everything about you...like, for instance, they want to know women are pregnant before their loved ones do:
http://www.nytimes.com/2012/02/19/magazine/shopping-habits.html?_r=1&pagewanted=all

Their creepiness has gotten well beyond "out of control."
 
they should have an go at avg as well as default to have DNT enabled

it trys it's best (even if the user does not want it) to enable the dnt, uninstall the dnt part of avg it keep on nagging you to re-enable it, advertisers should have an go at avg next, as there are more avg installs then windows 8 currently
 
It's very easy to add a *.something.com or whatnot to Internet Explorer's restricted site list and never see cookies or ads from that site. I have a running list of domains that I restrict which I add to once in a while by peeking into IE's cache folder. I had to figure that out to keep Adobe Flash installer notifications from coming up since I don't have Flash on any of my computers at home and every site in the world wants to install it. Restricting *.adobe.com got rid of it and I just kept going from there to clear the really nefarious ones.

You have to do stuff like that to keep enough memory and CPU power free on a 766 MHz Celeron with 320 MB of PC-100 RAM anyhow or the Internet becomes a really miserable wait while your poor processor works its little tail off. :(

Cut out font smoothing, tell the browser to not run animations, and then there's enough PC left to play MP3s or open LibreOffice too! :)

It's even easier to add the handful of sites you use to the allowed list and block everything else.
 
We knew this from the beginning and it applies to all versions. which is why Microsoft's choice to make it on by default was controversial. The ad industry basically said if anyone made it default they just were going to ignore it. I think I've mentioned before in previous threads about this that it's more to get good press for doing the right thing than trying to protect people since it was always optional with no repercussions for ignoring the flag.
 
I actually enjoy most of the ads on hardcop.com here. Like right now it has a Corsair ad at the top, an Asus TOP graphic card ad on the right, Tigerdirect and AMD's Nexuiz promotion below it. These are ads that are relevant to my interest, as well as the purpose of this site.

Those that I really hate are those obnoxious ads with sound, video and pop ups
 
I actually enjoy most of the ads on hardcop.com here. Like right now it has a Corsair ad at the top, an Asus TOP graphic card ad on the right, Tigerdirect and AMD's Nexuiz promotion below it. These are ads that are relevant to my interest, as well as the purpose of this site.

Those that I really hate are those obnoxious ads with sound, video and pop ups

Almost all the ads I see on the forum are non-product specific TigerDirect ads. I'm pretty sure that Creepy Uncle Google has no idea how to advertise to me based on my surfing habits and is just grabbing at straws by associating my catty-ness with TigerDirect. They're the only ads I ever see here.
 
I am in the UK so most of the time the ads are not related to me (google ones norm do show UK ads ) if it's flash based ad I have to click on it to see it (any site even to play an YouTube video as I have like 80 tabs open on opera and quite an number on chrome, if flash and java was not set to click to play I probably use 6gb+ in ram alown due to flash) I hate to have 80 tabs open on Firefox with or with flash enabled

opera does not like intiletext scripts nor do i (but that affects all sites that wish to use it if the script even runs) as they slow the browser to an craw as opera is single threaded

still the DNT flag if any browser sets it to default(user did not enable it) advertisers would just add an rule to ignore that browser and still track it
 
I am in the UK so most of the time the ads are not related to me (google ones norm do show UK ads ) if it's flash based ad I have to click on it to see it (any site even to play an YouTube video as I have like 80 tabs open on opera and quite an number on chrome, if flash and java was not set to click to play I probably use 6gb+ in ram alown due to flash) I hate to have 80 tabs open on Firefox with or with flash enabled

opera does not like intiletext scripts nor do i (but that affects all sites that wish to use it if the script even runs) as they slow the browser to an craw as opera is single threaded

still the DNT flag if any browser sets it to default(user did not enable it) advertisers would just add an rule to ignore that browser and still track it

Yikes! I start to feel cramped at 3-4 tabs opened.
 
I have two big screens

you can also stack tabs on opera as well most of my tabs are stacked for different like eBay news, tech sites, I use chrome for quick links like msn that I am likely not going to be open long (move them to opera if I want to lol at them later on )
 
Maybe it's just me but don't you guys set your cookies to ask you whether to allow or not? Just don't allow certain cookies. Actually I don't allow any cookies unless they are for shopping carts or Hard OCP of course.
 
Maybe it's just me but don't you guys set your cookies to ask you whether to allow or not? Just don't allow certain cookies. Actually I don't allow any cookies unless they are for shopping carts or Hard OCP of course.

You either don't visit many websites or you are insane :D. Just because there are maybe few % of "ad" cookies, you want to bother with the remaining part of "good" cookies ? Just look around in your cookies list once in a while, block the ad domains from sending you cookies and call it a day.
 
I am in the UK so most of the time the ads are not related to me (google ones norm do show UK ads ) if it's flash based ad I have to click on it to see it (any site even to play an YouTube video as I have like 80 tabs open on opera and quite an number on chrome, if flash and java was not set to click to play I probably use 6gb+ in ram alown due to flash) I hate to have 80 tabs open on Firefox with or with flash enabled

opera does not like intiletext scripts nor do i (but that affects all sites that wish to use it if the script even runs) as they slow the browser to an craw as opera is single threaded

still the DNT flag if any browser sets it to default(user did not enable it) advertisers would just add an rule to ignore that browser and still track it

Which browser are you using that supports flash click to play? I use Firefox and I'm pretty sure that feature isn't available yet for us.
 
Nevermind, apparently it's a hidden feature in Firefox until the next couple of releases. I just enabled it, should help my poor C-60 netbook cope. If I could get HTML5 youtube to work in IE I'd drop Firefox and uninstall Flash, but this will work for now. Can't wait until Flash is killed off entirely.
 
opera ,settings , pref, adv content ,enable plugins on demand
on chrome tools ,settings + show adv settings + ,content settings ,scroll down bit and select click to play

good thing is opera and chrome can allow plugins allways to load on some sites like YouTube BBC iPlayer, chrome does handle it better as it shows you An puzzle peace that you click on to allways the domain, opera you right click on the page (empty space) and click edit site preferencesthere (opera does have more options you can do very rare feature I use not that allows you to fake ie or Firefox for lame sites that force ie or Firefox use or send different broken frames (ms) that do not work or brake stuff when the ie version of the page works fine)
 
Back
Top