InvisiBill
2[H]4U
- Joined
- Jan 2, 2003
- Messages
- 2,608
Well said.
Necrosis, your example is invalid because FireFox would have LESS resources to help fix the found issues than Microsoft, as they rely on purely donated time from random people and a small core group in their non-profit.
Firefox's only good thing is addons, and if those can't be used due to security issues, why would you want to use Firefox at all? It's less intuitive than IE8, requires a separate download, reports more habits back to their makers than IE8 does, and is less secure, plus is open source so hackers can find exploits more easily. Lose/lose...
I've used IE almost exclusively over the years with short one-week bouts of Firefox because of the hype, but it's just a vocal minority that makes it sound good, not the actual truth.
Mozilla has paid employees. Not as many as Microsoft obviously, but it's not just Linux geeks playing around with it in their spare time. On the flip side, where MS only has their own internal IE team (plus a few "authorized" individuals) looking at their code, open source theoretically has the whole world looking over their code checking for bugs. Even 100 people looking over code is more likely to find a bug than 10 people looking over it.
The article uses multiple meanings for "plugin". They specifically refer to the new plugin checker, which checks actual web browser plugins - Flash, Acrobat Reader, etc. - the same plugins that IE and every other web browser uses. However, the context of the article implies addons, the things like NoScript, AdBlock, Greasemonkey, etc. They're ambiguous about what they actually mean, so it's hard to tell exactly what items they're including in this vuln count.
And as has been stated multiple times already, the count means very little regarding the actual security of the product. First, it's only the reported issues, which are inherently going to be higher on an open source product. Closed source apps like IE and Opera can simply hide their flaws and hope nobody else finds out. It also doesn't take into account duration, severity, or context. While the example given by necrosis might not be exact, it's not that far-fetched either. Mozilla has a history of fixing a large number of small bugs quickly, while IE is known for having huge issues go unpatched for a long time. Yes, Mozilla has had some issues go unpatched for a while too, but they're generally low-priority issues. For a very long time, Netscape/Mozilla had nothing worse than data-read bugs, while IE was executing random code left and right. Ideally, all bugs should be patched, but the simple truth is that some are worse than others.
At least for browsers, open source doesn't really make it any less secure. Most Firefox attacks are done exactly the same way as attacks against IE - they wait for a bug to be found and patched, and they compare the two versions. Whatever part is different is what was patched, and therefore that part of the old version is where the vuln lies. While it's possible for crackers to look through Firefox's code for bugs, it's a lot easier to just wait for someone else to find a bug and then write an attack against the old version, hoping to get people before they patch. When you consider that this is how most attacks in the wild are done, it doesn't really matter how they do their source, as the released patches are reverse-engineered to create the attacks.
Personally, I feel exactly the opposite about the interface. In my eyes, IE8 (and 7) are very different from other browsers and even other apps in general. Their layout is very different from IE6, and I spend a long time trying to find things that used to be in a certain spot. For me, it's the exact opposite of intuitive. At least when I find something I don't like in Firefox, I can write/install an addon to change it to match my preferences. IE is less flexible, handles code quite strangely at times, and is annoying to use. I find IE to be the one with all around poor scores. As for reporting back, the only references I can find via a quick Google search are regarding the phishing filter, the extension blocklist, RSS feeds, and other similar periodic updates (all of which can be disabled). If you've got anything better, I'd like to check it out.
I was using Firefox as my default browser when it was still called Phoenix. I have occasional bouts with IE because of poorly written sites, but it's just a bunch of people who don't know any better that make it sound good, not the actual truth.