InorganicMatter
[H]F Junkie
- Joined
- Oct 19, 2004
- Messages
- 15,461
Funny, I figured Steve would have rolled this news post up into this one:
http://hardforum.com/showthread.php?t=1720870

http://hardforum.com/showthread.php?t=1720870
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
I was being sarcastic, I like windows 8.All versions of Windows are very good. Better than the equivalent desktop Linux at the time. At this current time though, I would say that Linux has caught up on a number of platforms. This is because, for most users, Windows peaked about 10 years ago with XP. Most desktop Linux now is as good as Windows XP.
I was being sarcastic, I like windows 8.
...People who don't like Windows 8 have expressed so as well as people who do like it. Of course people who don't like it generally don't have very helpful points, it sucks is pretty useless information and I guess Microsoft didn't spend a lot of time listening to those kinds of suggestions. In any case Microsoft is trying to get into the tablet market and wasn't really looking for a lot input from anyone, for or against Windows 8.
I imagine W8 will be a fine OS on a tablet. If however, you're on a desktop computer and you already have a 64 bit version of W7 installed on it, W8 is essentially irrelevant. I don't know where this hate is that you speak of comes from. Indifference might be a better word to describe W8 for people that already have a fresh copy of W7 on their desktop computers.
I think the Metro design is best suited for tablets and cell phones, I personally don't think it fits well on the desktop, keep it to tablets and cell phones IMO.
I was agreeing.
Well then I agree with the agreement!
Windows 8 hate reminds me of the initial hate towards xp, windows 2000 did do better then xp initially but after the first service pack it was amazing, I don't see anything like xp was initially with windows 8.
Time honored tradition "I HATE THIS IT'S DIFFERENT" 2 years later "I CAN'T STAND IT WHEN IT'S NOT EXACTLY LIKE WHAT I SAID I HATE 2 YEARS AGO"Well then I agree with the agreement!
Windows 8 hate reminds me of the initial hate towards xp, windows 2000 did do better then xp initially but after the first service pack it was amazing, I don't see anything like xp was initially with windows 8.
It's not hate. Most of us are on desktops and we have W7. W8 is just...well...insignificant.
ooooh there is a TON of hate twords Win8.
But I agree its not a gigantic step from Win7 other then UI.
This makes no sense. People who don't like Windows 8 have expressed so as well as people who do like it. Of course people who don't like it generally don't have very helpful points, it sucks is pretty useless information
In any case Microsoft is trying to get into the tablet market and wasn't really looking for a lot input from anyone, for or against Windows 8.
2) Click & drag gestures being the only way to trigger things - this is so very, very painful on a laptop
Can you refresh me on what requires it? I remember watching a video and to do certain things you had to access the right, left, drag things, or go into Metro/Modern (covering the entire desktop). It seemed like a confusing, bloated, and really ugly mess.![]()
I haven't used windows 8 in awhile, but you can close apps by clicking(i think right or just left cant remember) on the top left or bottom right(both work) it brings up a pop up menu with all app that are launched and you can just right click to close any app you want. which i found was more useful when running like 4 5 apps at once then just a quick click drag. Mouse jesters are a bit obtuse.Closing an app is a click & drag from the top of the screen to at least the middle of the screen. Running two apps side by side is also a click & drag.
I do think it's a bit odd to simplify the UI while at the time having a heavy reliance on gestures to which a user has to know before hand. But mouse gestures are welcome on laptops ionno why you're bitching about trackpad and mouse gestures they go hand and hand with web browsers why can't the whole OS use it.And people who like it generally don't have any helpful points either. But here's something more specific:
1) Hiding crucial bits of the UI behind hidden screen edge gestures. Good luck explaining that one to your grandma ("no, move the cursor off the *LEFT* edge of your screen. I know there's nothing over there, just do it anyway")
2) Click & drag gestures being the only way to trigger things - this is so very, very painful on a laptop
3) HUGE GIANT UI THAT REQUIRES HUGE GIANT MOUSE MOVEMENTS TO INTERACT WITH - I have a precision device at my disposal, and large movements are again annoying on a laptop trackpad.
4) Throws away years and years of familiarity for nothing. Familiarity is a huge reason things are "intuitive". And in exchange for learning a completely new UI what do you get in return? Nothing. Nothing at all. Metro doesn't bring anything *useful* to the table. It's not faster, it's not more powerful, and it's not easier to use.
5) Jarring transitions. In metro mode and launch an app, end up on the old desktop - wtf? Using the old desktop because metro sucks, want to launch an app so you hit the windows key and SUDDEN EXPLOSION OF SOLID COLORS ALL UP IN YOUR FACE WHAT THE FUCK JUST HAPPENED
Now yes, for tablets and phones Metro brings the critical touch support and a simple UI that is very fast for low powered devices to render. But for laptops and desktops? No, just no.
Which is a real shame, because the lower level stuff and kernel improvements are really cool.
So what, we should give them a pass that they fucked up laptops and desktops because they were going after tablets?
Closing an app is a click & drag from the top of the screen to at least the middle of the screen. Running two apps side by side is also a click & drag.
And people who like it generally don't have any helpful points either. But here's something more specific:
1) Hiding crucial bits of the UI behind hidden screen edge gestures. Good luck explaining that one to your grandma ("no, move the cursor off the *LEFT* edge of your screen. I know there's nothing over there, just do it anyway")
2) Click & drag gestures being the only way to trigger things - this is so very, very painful on a laptop
3) HUGE GIANT UI THAT REQUIRES HUGE GIANT MOUSE MOVEMENTS TO INTERACT WITH - I have a precision device at my disposal, and large movements are again annoying on a laptop track pad.
4) Throws away years and years of familiarity for nothing. Familiarity is a huge reason things are "intuitive". And in exchange for learning a completely new UI what do you get in return? Nothing. Nothing at all. Metro doesn't bring anything *useful* to the table. It's not faster, it's not more powerful, and it's not easier to use.
5) Jarring transitions. In metro mode and launch an app, end up on the old desktop - wtf? Using the old desktop because metro sucks, want to launch an app so you hit the windows key and SUDDEN EXPLOSION OF SOLID COLORS ALL UP IN YOUR FACE WHAT THE FUCK JUST HAPPENED
Now yes, for tablets and phones Metro brings the critical touch support and a simple UI that is very fast for low powered devices to render. But for laptops and desktops? No, just no.
So what, we should give them a pass that they fucked up laptops and desktops because they were going after tablets?
Laptops and desktop sales are stagnant.
and speed. It was like I added some ram and bumped up the proc.
But mouse gestures are welcome on laptops ionno why you're bitching about trackpad and mouse gestures they go hand and hand with web browsers why can't the whole OS use it.
Regular desktop programs still use the old fashion red "X". If you don't like Metro apps in the first place, then why are you using it? Stick with desktop programs like you have been doing since 1995. Not that hard.
I've shown a couple of people how to use Windows 8 and this just wasn't an issue once people were shown how this works. Really, if one can't master hot corners there's probably a lot of other issues that that user would har have with Windows.
Agreed, but most Windows 8 laptops are going to have gesture capable track pads to facilitate these types of things.
Six of one, half a dozen of the other. Courser movements can be faster because they don't have to be as accurate.
It does work better on touch and tablet devices which are growing like wild. Laptops and desktop sales are stagnant.
After a while it simply becomes normal.
Windows 8 is a hybrid OS, it's not a desktop or tablet OS, it is a desktop AND tablet OS always across all devices and its behavior is driven by the programs one runs. Run Visual Studio or Eclipse or whatever and Windows 8 is just like Windows 7 on the desktop. Run IE Metro or Angry Birds or Fruit Ninja on a tablet and Windows 8 behaves just like a mobile OS tablet and all of this is possible on one derive.
No, it is very much an issue. Hidden gestures are great if they are a shortcut, but as the sole, primary mechanism they are terrible.
And these magical, non-existent trackpads will have what gestures, exactly?
Nope, you still need to be accurate as only *part* of the UI is huge and massive. Still have regular sized links and shit on the internet, in your emails, or while editing documents, which is what most people use.
stagnant != small
MS Office sales are stagnant as well, it's still an insanely profitable business for Microsoft.
Two completely different UIs on a single device will never become normal, it's confusing as fuck.
Yes, but the problem is that in becoming a "hybrid" it has clearly regressed significantly at one of the roles (laptop/desktop), and is largely unknown in the other role (tablet).
And no, Windows 8's "classic" mode is not just like Windows 7. It's certainly close, but still a notable step back due to the loss of things like the start menu and Aero - oh, and the annoying screen edge gestures.
^ heat, it sounds like individuals just don't want 'change'.
I think this was one of the major reasons users hated going from Office 2003 to Office 2007.
It got rid of their precious toolbars, which everyone had been used to for nearly the last decade at that time, and replaced them with ribbons and pallets.
Though 2007 was a bit clunky, 2010 fixed everything that could have possibly been an issue.
In the end, 2007 was far superior to 2003, and not just in the front-end GUI, but also the back-end coding and program architecture.
I'm really starting to believe Win 8 may be kind of the same thing, as it does have many optimizations that Win 7 does not have, and the fact that it is compiled for both x86 and ARM architectures including mobile devices are all a huge plus.
However, since I'm a super-mega-ultra-giga Linux shill, it will be my duty to absolutely hate Windows and Microsoft until the day I die, but even I have to admit Win 8 is a huge improvement, for both end-users and Microsoft.
We'll just have to see how it holds up in the enterprise front, that's what I'll be looking at when the time comes.