Feds Settle "Facebook Firing" Case

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
The courts have ruled that it is okay to talk smack on Facebook about your employer. On a related note, it is still okay for your boss and coworkers to unfriend your ungrateful ass too.

The National Labor Relations Board sued the company last year, arguing that the worker's negative comments were protected speech under labor laws. The company claimed it fired the employee because of complaints about her work.
 
If it was an "at will" work state like California, then the only problem with firing an employee is giving them a reason at all!
 
There's really no winning this. You should be free enough to express dislikes about your job or boss. But, if said job or boss picks up on it, they can make your work life much more of a hell then it was before posting.

I stick to keeping work and personal separate. Neither one knows much about the other.
 
The lady deserved to be fired for many reasons, the main one being she is an idiot.

First off, why did she bitch on her PUBLIC profile knowing every nosey ass person in her life job and family is reading her every thought?? Secondly, what idiot uses a public profile anyways? It's just retarded to do and a huge invasion of personal privacy, if you actually do share stuff on it about your personal life....

Good ruling though I say, its your opinions... but I gotta say if you are that stupid and you don't like something out loud on your profile, I am not going to be surprised if you get fired. And I don't see how you can keep your job, a boss can do as they please with their company, no?
 
If it was an "at will" work state like California, then the only problem with firing an employee is giving them a reason at all!

Even though California is an "at will" state, that still doesn't prevent companies from losing "dismissal" related lawsuits.

It's much better to get the employee to "resign" with a signature on a piece of paper that says he/she will not litigate that's tied to some amount of compensation. (I know of many cases that companies in California have done this to get rid of somebody that in IMHO should have been fired.)
 
The lady deserved to be fired for many reasons, the main one being she is an idiot.

First off, why did she bitch on her PUBLIC profile knowing every nosey ass person in her life job and family is reading her every thought?? Secondly, what idiot uses a public profile anyways? It's just retarded to do and a huge invasion of personal privacy, if you actually do share stuff on it about your personal life....

Good ruling though I say, its your opinions... but I gotta say if you are that stupid and you don't like something out loud on your profile, I am not going to be surprised if you get fired. And I don't see how you can keep your job, a boss can do as they please with their company, no?

This. If you want to talk smack about work, don't do it on the internet...unless you are anonymous, which facebook isn't.
 
I think the point that should be taken away from this story is that just because some thing isn't the smartest thing to do in the world, doesn't mean it should be illegal. Plenty of us do things everyday that someone, somewhere, would consider to be rather idiotic, but not illegal.

The article makes no mention of whether or not the employee had the expectation of privacy on FB, therefore we cannot conclude that she expected any at all.

I also think this article speaks equally about the employer who apparently thinks their market position could be threatened by a disgruntled employee on FB.
 
I think it's great! It forced the company to change it's policy about employees rights. It will force a change for all companies that are smart.

I love seeing the Government actually protect something of the people for a change.

For years, when I worked at the old EDS (Ross Perot old company) it was a dismissal charge if you even talked to fellow employee's about your salary!

Times keep getting better.
 
Nice to hear workers will have some protections in cases like this.

I had a "near miss", in that I was commenting on my private facebook page about a recent round of layoffs at my company. just general bellyaching and replies to comments others I worked with had made.

Luckily, I made no derogatory commenst about anyone, or the company, as shortyly afterwards my boss commented on some of the things I had posted. evidently one of my friends, wasn't.

I canceled my FB account the next day. I need my damn job to much to risk a casual comment from making it's way to my boss, protected speech or not.

I might reopen it, but only after careful consideration of who I friend, thats for damn sure, and no interaction between work and personal life. but that line tends to blur, to, if your workplace disapproves of your personal life....
 
There's really no winning this. You should be free enough to express dislikes about your job or boss. But, if said job or boss picks up on it, they can make your work life much more of a hell then it was before posting.

I stick to keeping work and personal separate. Neither one knows much about the other.

Agreed to some point. IF you go online and talk shit about your work and make it publicly know who you are talking about I see no probblem with them firing you. Going online and posting "I work for Company XYZ and they are the worst fucking company out there. we get treated like shit, they do everything they can to fuck over customers. Don't buy from XYZ if you know what it smart for you" why shouldn't i expect to get fired? if your profile is private, and you are talking to your friends / family about a bad day you had a work then that is something else. I agree about work and personal. I have a facebook profile that i really don't use much for anything however i refuse to add anyone that i work with solely for the reason if i ever decide to say anything about work or anything related to anyone i work with i don't have to worry about any of them seeing it.

To many people want to think of FB and other social networking sites as their diary / personal rant page where they can say what they want, when they want, and not think about who can see it. I had a friend on mine list that is young and ignornant. 20 year old girl in a relationship with a 42 year old guy. Has his mom on her friends list. She would say crap about his brother or his daughter who is her age, then get mad when his mom took offense to that and would always say that it is her fb page she should be able to say what she wants. But that isn't the case, you shouldn't take your social networking site to be your little world where you can say and do as you want. You should treat is as a room where you would only say and do whatever you would if everyone that can see your page was in that room. If you wouldn't stand in a room with your boss and bitch about your job, then you shouldn't do that on facebook with your boss listed as a friend.

People need to learn to realized that what they post / do online can and will have consequences.

I think the point that should be taken away from this story is that just because some thing isn't the smartest thing to do in the world, doesn't mean it should be illegal. Plenty of us do things everyday that someone, somewhere, would consider to be rather idiotic, but not illegal.

The article makes no mention of whether or not the employee had the expectation of privacy on FB, therefore we cannot conclude that she expected any at all.

I also think this article speaks equally about the employer who apparently thinks their market position could be threatened by a disgruntled employee on FB.

Who ever said it was illegal? people aren't being arrested for these stuff, they are being fired.

And where do they speak equally about the employer?
 
It's funny. The general concern is this. People are afraid to lose their jobs. So instead of acting to get better at their jobs because they wish to improve themselves and those around they react bitterly and in fear.
Tell me if you don't see the parallelism between this and slavery. I know, at least from a psychological standpoint. Although all things considered is better to let workers get out of work if you know they're going to come back tomorrow. Sometimes this country really makes me laugh. But then again the people are the ones that create these situations. So I guess everyone gets what they ask for. Whether they do it directly or indirectly.
 
It's funny. The general concern is this. People are afraid to lose their jobs. So instead of acting to get better at their jobs because they wish to improve themselves and those around they react bitterly and in fear.
Tell me if you don't see the parallelism between this and slavery. I know, at least from a psychological standpoint. Although all things considered is better to let workers get out of work if you know they're going to come back tomorrow. Sometimes this country really makes me laugh. But then again the people are the ones that create these situations. So I guess everyone gets what they ask for. Whether they do it directly or indirectly.

There is a difference between being afraid of losing your job and not biting the hand the feeds you. The world is becoming more connected. It is one thing to go home and tell your spouse about your bad day at work, or go to a bar after work with your friend and talk about your bad day. It is another to walk outside of your work and bitch directory to the customers or clients. If you were giving a sales pitch to a large client would you stop and say "you know what, i can't go on any more. screw my employer go find somebody else" and walk out? The problem is that years ago you left work and you were nobody, you didn't represent your employer anymore. If somebody passed you on the street they wouldn't know who you worked for. But now peeople go online and create public profiles on facebook and twitter, they friend people from all over, they friend coworkers, business clients, their kids teachers, their bosses, people at other bussinesses that they work with. They flash their employer in their profiles, they make sure everyone knows who they are, who they work for and go off saying whatever they want. If your client, business partner, etc see you talking shit about your work why would they care if it was done during business hours or not. Either way you are representing your business now at all times. This would be like a Microsoft employee walking around with a big sign saying that they work for Microsoft (swap that out with Apple, Google or any other large company) and them talking shit about the company to everyone that they see.

Now yes, some people are afraid of making waves, they are afraid of getting fired. So instead of trying to do a better job to make sure they are kept around, or finding themselves a better job they will bend over backwards to ensure that they get to keep their job. But others just believe in having some professionalism to how they conduct themselves. Doesn't matter how good of an employee you are if all of your coworkers chase away your clients and force the company out of business.
 
Agreed to some point. IF you go online and talk shit about your work and make it publicly know who you are talking about I see no probblem with them firing you. Going online and posting "I work for Company XYZ and they are the worst fucking company out there. we get treated like shit, they do everything they can to fuck over customers. Don't buy from XYZ if you know what it smart for you" why shouldn't i expect to get fired? if your profile is private, and you are talking to your friends / family about a bad day you had a work then that is something else. I agree about work and personal. I have a facebook profile that i really don't use much for anything however i refuse to add anyone that i work with solely for the reason if i ever decide to say anything about work or anything related to anyone i work with i don't have to worry about any of them seeing it.

To many people want to think of FB and other social networking sites as their diary / personal rant page where they can say what they want, when they want, and not think about who can see it. I had a friend on mine list that is young and ignornant. 20 year old girl in a relationship with a 42 year old guy. Has his mom on her friends list. She would say crap about his brother or his daughter who is her age, then get mad when his mom took offense to that and would always say that it is her fb page she should be able to say what she wants. But that isn't the case, you shouldn't take your social networking site to be your little world where you can say and do as you want. You should treat is as a room where you would only say and do whatever you would if everyone that can see your page was in that room. If you wouldn't stand in a room with your boss and bitch about your job, then you shouldn't do that on facebook with your boss listed as a friend.

People need to learn to realized that what they post / do online can and will have consequences.



Who ever said it was illegal? people aren't being arrested for these stuff, they are being fired.

And where do they speak equally about the employer?

When this was challenged in court, if the court upheld that the reason for termination was valid, then it would set a precedent, and effectively become legal. Employment at will is one thing, but if the company is going to provide a reason for termination, then it would behoove them to make sure it is within the legal boundaries.

And the comment of speaking equally about the employer, was my opinion of an employer who first chose to make the policy, chose to enforce it in such a manner, and chose for the matter to make it to federal court.
 
Back
Top