FCC To Propose New 'Net Neutrality' Rules

... to a certain extent a metered internet does make sense ...
Only if you believe ISP propaganda that bandwidth is 'expensive' (its not, they make crap loads of money every year) and that 'data hogs' are the cause of any network congestion.

then they should pay for what they consume ;)
They already do and no one was arguing against paying for bandwidth.

What they're pissed off about is the ISP's using their regulatory capture and monopoly power to act as rentiers a la the aristocracy in old school feudal systems and leech off the economy/society.
 
Yeah because none of the other public utilities, like electricity and water, are interesting to big money ... oh wait, they are ;)
Public utilities are subject to quite a bit of regulation including price controls in some cases. No one wants another Enron.
 
" At the same time, you are not discriminating against specific websites or people, you are discriminating against particular types of traffic."

Thus defeating the point of "neutrality."
But this is perfectly legitimate even to many hard-core supporters of net neutrality :

"I want to be clear what we mean by Net neutrality: What we mean is if you have one data type like video, you don't discriminate against one person's video in favor of another. But it's okay to discriminate across different types, so you could prioritize voice over video, and there is general agreement with Verizon and Google on that issue."

Google CEO Eric Schmidt (August 4, 2010)

"In a universe of applications, including both latency-sensitive and insensitive applications, it is difficult to regard the IP suite as truly neutral"

Tim Wu

So basically the Internet already by its designed (and the speed of light) is heavily biased against Streaming Video to begin with, and anything else that requires high sustained bandwidth, low latency and jitter.
 
So basically the Internet already by its designed (and the speed of light) is heavily biased against Streaming Video to begin with, and anything else that requires high sustained bandwidth, low latency and jitter.
Nope.

You're mistaking hardware and technology inadequacies for design there.

High bandwidth + low latency + low jitter is still hard to do.

High bandwidth on the other hand, which is what they're looking to limit, isn't difficult to do at all and is already artificially limited in the US to protect ISP/media profits.

The money quote:

Farhad Manjoo has the explanation for why this should be. Internet service is very cheap for the cable companies to provide, and it's also price sensitive: if you reduce the price, more people will sign up. As a result, the cable companies would make more money from their broadband offerings if they reduced the price. So why don't they? Because right now, 91% of Americans with broadband also have cable TV (I think, I can't find the link for that right now), and the cable companies make their real money from TV, not broadband. The cable companies therefore have every incentive to price broadband as high as possible, so as to make the marginal extra cost of getting TV as well as small as possible.

In the U.S., cable TV rates are very high; as such, the best way to prevent cord-cutting is to ensure that broadband rates are also very high. That's bad for broadband adoption, but it's reasonably effective at keeping people paying very large sums for TV every month. In other words, high broadband rates are a bit like most newspaper paywalls: they're not so much a way of making lots of money themselves as they are a way of persuading you to pay lots of money for something else. (Physical newspaper delivery, or cable TV.)
 
The American government proves one thing resoundingly.

Which is, the larger a country becomes the less power each individual citizen, and each individual state, wields. Federalization is another word for centralization.

If you have a government composed solely of citizens of your specific neighborhood, you have a outstanding chance at being heard and making decisions that affect your life. When that same civic government expands to encompass a town, you have less ability to have an impact. When it becomes a city, you have less. A state? Still less. A federal government composed of 52 states? With license to tax on command? Go fuck yourself, little man.
 
The American government proves one thing resoundingly.

Which is, the larger a country becomes the less power each individual citizen, and each individual state, wields. Federalization is another word for centralization.

If you have a government composed solely of citizens of your specific neighborhood, you have a outstanding chance at being heard and making decisions that affect your life. When that same civic government expands to encompass a town, you have less ability to have an impact. When it becomes a city, you have less. A state? Still less. A federal government composed of 52 states? With license to tax on command? Go fuck yourself, little man.

People tend to try to eliminate redundant stuff like layers of leadership. Companies even do it to layers of management because a limited, shallow management stack thingey is totally awesome for saving tons of moolah and being efficient. If you don't like big government, why on Earth are you trying to get tons and tons (literally...there are sooo many fat people out there) to be a part of government institutions. I swear you library people are always saying stuff that contradicts other stuff you say. That's so weird.
 
information on the ground tends to be more accurate than what gets relayed to D.C.

The guys in North Dakota are probably better able to handle oil rig decisions than some Georgetown grad on the capital hill.
 
When it becomes a city, you have less. A state? Still less.
While its true that as an individual your vote means less in a bigger system the trade off is you can benefit from the economy of scale a bigger system gets you.

There is a reason why so many small countries with weak central govt. are poor and/or hell holes and its not just location. Hell the Articles of Confederation failed for a reason too if you want a American example.

Especially one that the Founding Fathers had personal experience and a hand in creating...and then dismantling in favor of a strong centralized govt.
 
information on the ground tends to be more accurate than what gets relayed to D.C.

The guys in North Dakota are probably better able to handle oil rig decisions than some Georgetown grad on the capital hill.

The people in North Dakota will make a decision that's more favorable to them. Assuming they don't have a college education, they're not going to be as likely to consider their social and ethical responsibilities to the rest of society because they just don't have a bigger picture understanding of the world around them without the additional education and super deluxe awesomeness that comes along with it.
 
information on the ground tends to be more accurate than what gets relayed to D.C.

The guys in North Dakota are probably better able to handle oil rig decisions than some Georgetown grad on the capital hill.

The guys in North Dakota are also just as easily bought and sold by lobbyists...and with little room for any oversight or appeal.
 
The people in North Dakota will make a decision that's more favorable to them. Assuming they don't have a college education, they're not going to be as likely to consider their social and ethical responsibilities to the rest of society because they just don't have a bigger picture understanding of the world around them without the additional education and super deluxe awesomeness that comes along with it.

Yeah, I hail from Maryland. We aren't anything special, sorry.
 
Nope.

You're mistaking hardware and technology inadequacies for design there.

High bandwidth + low latency + low jitter is still hard to do.
In other words, the Internet discriminates against Streaming Video. So one cannot treat all data identically since the Internet doesn't do that.

High bandwidth on the other hand, which is what they're looking to limit,
This isn't related to my argument on net neutrality.
 
In other words, the Internet discriminates against Streaming Video. So one cannot treat all data identically since the Internet doesn't do that.
Discrimination in the context you're talking about would've required all the ISP and backbone carriers to coordinate to sabotage streaming video.

That is not what is happening. Its a technical issue.

This isn't related to my argument on net neutrality.
But it is related to the ISP's argument on net neutrality, which is what really matters here.
 
I just wish that for once, someone in our government would actually have the BALLS to tell these greedy stains what they can go do with themselves. Declare the internet a utility and tell the ISP's and anyone else who stands to profit from this to fuck off.

It's impossible. In a country controlled by only 2 parties, there isn't enough room for diversity of opinion. By the time you get through the money processes, the primaries, then the general election, you've effectively weeded out anyone with a sense of morality or scruples, because it's impossible.

Let's make political parties illegal, you just have to run on your own. And let's blow out Congress making it 5x-10x the size, so perhaps you actually have a chance to see and speak to your Representatives even if you aren't waving billions of dollars around. (Fun fact: the house of representatives used to be scaled up based on population based on every US Census; this practice was stopped in the early 1900s)
 
It's impossible. In a country controlled by only 2 parties, there isn't enough room for diversity of opinion. By the time you get through the money processes, the primaries, then the general election, you've effectively weeded out anyone with a sense of morality or scruples, because it's impossible.

Let's make political parties illegal, you just have to run on your own. And let's blow out Congress making it 5x-10x the size, so perhaps you actually have a chance to see and speak to your Representatives even if you aren't waving billions of dollars around. (Fun fact: the house of representatives used to be scaled up based on population based on every US Census; this practice was stopped in the early 1900s)

No, here are some things that should be done that would dramatically change Washington:

1- Remove money from politics. None of this bullshit high paid corporate lobbyists buying politicians. Also get rid of super PACs and the ability to donate unlimited money anonymously.
2- Corporations are not people, and not entitled to free speech. Revert that bullshit ruling.
3- Get rid of gerrymandering. Make it so the elected officials actually fear not being re-elected. Creating a zone of constituents that all vote for your party is absolute bullshit, and defeats the purpose of democracy.
4- If the government shuts down, congress doesn't get paid. They don't get to dick around with everyone else's lives while working 3 months out of the year with no fear of the same happening to them. Or even any consequences for their actions/inactions.
5- Change filibustering back to the old way. You want to block a vote you need to hold your piss and go read from the phone book or something. The current way of just calling filibuster then being able to leave and stop the vote is horse shit.


That's all I can think of off the top of my head, but those are some of the most severe problems corrupting the government right now.
 
Americans have only ourselves to blame. Majority of this country vote based on their religious beliefs and campaign rhetoric rather than the most basic common sense and thinking ability. People would rather watch reality tv than read real news (on the Internet, while its still available for free).

Lets face it, US is not a democracy, the people have no power. You want to effect some change, start with actually being aware of the issues and taking some action. Its amazing how ignorant most people in the US are compared to other countries. Its because life here is so easy, tghey simply don't care about anything as long as they have their fast food and tv, even in this terrible economy. If the people aren't even aware of the problem, no change will ever be made.
 
stop voting.

Or stop voting for the main parties.

Next election, I'm probably voting green party. More people need to start voting green or other parties. If they see an increase of votes for these tiny parties it will send a bigger message than if people just don't vote. Not sure how it works in the US though or if they have other parties like that.
 
The ISPs are also cable TV providers and content producers. They care what you do with your internet bandwidth because it affects their bottom line.

And guess who wants positive stories about them, while sweeping the scandals under the rug? Politicans? Can they earn favor?
 
Back
Top