You are proposing a classic false dichotomy. There are further options which you fail to point out.
Supposing the earth is overpopulated and we are aware of this, then you suppose that the only conceivable opinion anyone could have would be to cull the population. I can readily point out some alternatives which demonstrate your either-or fallacy:
1) Do nothing.
2) Let natural forces stabilize the population.
3) Dig underground cities.
4) Develop methods for reducing consumption further.
As you can see, even if they genuinely believe the earth is overpopulated, there are indeed other responses they might have to it.
And now you are back to they are 100% correct again.
Your ideas there fail as that wouldn't work according to their numbers if you assume that are 100% correct like you are back to doing. It is IMPOSSIBLE. As we said, if you everyone in the world consumed almost nothing except the bare min to survive, we are 3 times over the limit. How the hell do you reduce any more from almost nothing without everything going to nothing. NO cars, NO power, NO water, NO houses, NO planes or other modes of transportation, NO garbage, NO eating of anything other than some local plants = 3 times over the limit now. So #4 on your list isn't going to work as you can't reduce that any more. #1 & 2 mean they should all stop bothering us with the safe the planet bullshit then and just let whatever happens happen.
My point was NEVER that we should actually kill anybody. It was just that their numbers are bullshit and that you shouldn't fully trust their results.