E8400 vs Q6600

q6600 is more future proof

This always gets said, but what time horizon are you looking at it being future proof in? What is going to change in the next 2 or 3 years that is going to obsolete a dual-core? Nothing, is the answer you are looking for. Will apps become more multi-threaded in the future, probably so, but probably not enough to matter to the average person - how many threads does Firefox need to run on? There is very little that the average user is going to do that is going to tax a decent dual-core chip today, tomorrow, or next year. Why pay for something you aren't going to use?
 
This always gets said, but what time horizon are you looking at it being future proof in? What is going to change in the next 2 or 3 years that is going to obsolete a dual-core? Nothing, is the answer you are looking for. Will apps become more multi-threaded in the future, probably so, but probably not enough to matter to the average person - how many threads does Firefox need to run on? There is very little that the average user is going to do that is going to tax a decent dual-core chip today, tomorrow, or next year. Why pay for something you aren't going to use?

People said just about the same exact thinkg when dual cores first came out. Why pay a few $$$ more for another core nothing even uses! It was a completely silly idea, right? Faster single core FTW!

Then the people with the fast single core PCs shortly found themselves needing an upgrade sooner compared to the people who purchased a dual core instead :p
 
People said just about the same exact thinkg when dual cores first came out. Why pay a few $$$ more for another core nothing even uses! It was a completely silly idea, right? Faster single core FTW!

Then the people with the fast single core PCs shortly found themselves needing an upgrade sooner compared to the people who purchased a dual core instead :p

Well, one could certainly argue that there really hasn't been a good case made for even having a dual-core processor, for most people. Again, how many cores does Joe User really need - my 65 year old parents certainly don't need a dual-core, do yours? One could also argue that going from one core to two provides a greater benefit than going from two to four, following that old law of diminishing returns. But I won't bother making either of these arguments, since almost everyone has already made up their mind on this issue, and are either in the more cores is always better camp, or the just get as many cores as you need camp.

I'm curious to see how this plays out when Nehalem (sorry i7) comes out because then we can all argue over the relative benefits of having virtual Hyperthreading cores as well.

Personally the day the eight core chips launch can't come soon enough because I really, really need 8 cores running at 0.05% utilization instead of my current 2 running at 2%.
 
Well, one could certainly argue that there really hasn't been a good case made for even having a dual-core processor, for most people. Again, how many cores does Joe User really need - my 65 year old parents certainly don't need a dual-core, do yours? One could also argue that going from one core to two provides a greater benefit than going from two to four, following that old law of diminishing returns. But I won't bother making either of these arguments, since almost everyone has already made up their mind on this issue, and are either in the more cores is always better camp, or the just get as many cores as you need camp.

I'm curious to see how this plays out when Nehalem (sorry i7) comes out because then we can all argue over the relative benefits of having virtual Hyperthreading cores as well.

Personally the day the eight core chips launch can't come soon enough because I really, really need 8 cores running at 0.05% utilization instead of my current 2 running at 2%.

Speaking of seniors.....

My mother (who just hit sixty-five this year) has the motherboard in her Dell Dimension 2400C (single-core Northwood-based Celeron) failing, and I brought up my even older (but somewhat better equipped; specs in the sig) system for her to use while she gets things together for a guts transplant (new motherboard/CPU/RAM).
My system's hard drive is in major need of defragmentation, and it showed.

On the subject of *her* system's transplant, I'm going with a low-end C2D (E7200), 2 GB of RAM, and onboard graphics (she is, like me, running Vista Ultimate, and will be staying with it). Mom is notorious (almost as much as I am) for having multiple browser tabs (and multiple browser windows) open (so a single-core CPU doesn't really cut it any more); however, her application load has not gotten to the point where a quad-core (even a budget quad like the Q6600) makes sense.

However, *my* system is dog-slow because one thing I haven't been doing since the last wipe-and-reinstall is keeping my partitions defragmented, and it's seriously screwing up my system performance.

Still, it's getting harder and harder to justify sticking with a single-core processor, even with light application loads.
 
Well, one could certainly argue that there really hasn't been a good case made for even having a dual-core processor, for most people. Again, how many cores does Joe User really need - my 65 year old parents certainly don't need a dual-core, do yours? One could also argue that going from one core to two provides a greater benefit than going from two to four, following that old law of diminishing returns. But I won't bother making either of these arguments, since almost everyone has already made up their mind on this issue, and are either in the more cores is always better camp, or the just get as many cores as you need camp.

I'm curious to see how this plays out when Nehalem (sorry i7) comes out because then we can all argue over the relative benefits of having virtual Hyperthreading cores as well.

Personally the day the eight core chips launch can't come soon enough because I really, really need 8 cores running at 0.05% utilization instead of my current 2 running at 2%.

I find this excuse rarely works since inevitably something will come out that needs more CPU. My mother is in her mid 50s right now, she barely knows how to use the PC but she wants it to work quickly when she does go to use it. She upgraded from a Celeron something to a P4 when she wanted to watch DVDs on her PC while using it. Then upgraded again to a 3800x2/more RAM/bigger HD computer when she got a digital camera since that was slow as shit when going through her massive pile of digital pics on her PC. Now she wants to use Vista (which I am down with since it less likely for her to mess up) and that 3800x2 with 2GB of RAM is already getting long in the tooth, and she is looking at a digital video camera to shoot HD vids.

Heck a few years ago, 800MHz was consider all you need to surf the internet. Just setup come old people with that and you never need to upgrade again, right! :) Now modern websites can bring an old 800MHz to a crawl with no trouble. PCs may have a longer lifespan for basic internet use and such, however point here is just that even when dealing with regular folk, even the basic stuff they may want to do gradually becomes more CPU intensive to justify more CPU cycles.
 
Back
Top