E4500 vs. Phenom 9600

swanysto

Limp Gawd
Joined
Mar 3, 2005
Messages
340
So right now I have an E4500 that tops out at 3ghz. I want to wait for Nehalemto come out but I am bored with my E4500 at the moment. I really don't want to pay 200 for a processor right now, which is why I am asking about the 105 dollar 9600. I just want a quad core to play around with till the end of the year.

Will this processor outperform my E4500 in any scenario? I mostly play HL2 games which are known to be more CPU reliant than the newer games are. I do a bit of encoding and such but nothing to be picky about.

I am neither an AMD or Intel fanboy, and I know that Intel is dominating right now. However I do not need the best right now, just something better than my E4500 for cheap.

Bottom line, is the Phenom a better chip than my E4500? If it is I will buy it.
 
As with any quad vs dual discussion, the presence of two extra cores will make the 9600 faster if the applications make use of it - encoding will certainly show an improvement, most gaming won't show a huge effect. Team Fortress 2, for instance, only uses one core, and a 9600 comes out a little behind an E6750, which your overclocked CPU has a higher clockspeed than (although yours has half the cache, which will probably narrow the gap slightly):
http://www.techreport.com/articles.x/13633/5

So it will outperform it in scenarios which are highly multithreaded, but the Phenom's weaker per-core power (especially as Phenoms don't overclock hugely) will mean it falls behind in those which can't take advantage of the extra two cores.

Of course, replacing an E4500 with a Phenom will also involve getting a new motherboard, unless you happen to have an AM2 one already, which will increase the price.
 
I was in a similar position. My e2160 @ 3.1ghz I was getting bored of... so I went to a Phenom 9550 and couldn't be happier. I have it running at 2.86 GHz right now on my gigabyte 790fx motherboard and it runs like a champ. I definitely noticed a performance improvement in general usage over my overclocked 2160; however, it wasn't as if the 2160 was a slouch by any stretch of the imagination.

The way I like to think about it is that AMD has solved the chipset i/o problem (and some would argue that it's even overkill), but the way I see it... I/O was always one of the biggest bottlenecks in any system (hard drive).... so I'd rather go with the company that has solved the i/o bottleneck problem. CPU's won't be an issue for games, so I'd rather spend less on a CPU and more on a GPU if that's what I'm going to be doing; and it is what I'm doing. Pretty much any dual/quad core CPU you buy today will be plenty for gaming at high res.... GPU's, on the other hand, will require more horsepower.

Just my $0.02
 
TF2 uses 1.5 cores. it offloads physics to a 2nd core, but nothing really beyond 50% usage of a 2nd core.
 
Back
Top