Dumb to buy i7?

I have this rig from back 2004 or 2003, can't remember. It's a Pentium 4 , is it worth to jump in the I7 - Nehalem wagon? or a Q9550 x38 4 gig 800 is enough for gaming and some amateur editing?
 
Isn't that speculation? It may be the intent at this time, but it could be that a revamp of this socket could come quick.

Well, it will sure last more than 775...since its EOL.
Are you kidding? How many "quick" socket changes have you seen?
Roadmap says there will be another one for lower end SKUs, but if you're looking for lower end then it really doesn't matter what you get.
As for me I'm going to buy a solid 775 platform with a q9550, that should hold me over for a few years.
The ONLY reason I'm not buying i7 is I already have some of the parts for my new rig.
 
I have this rig from back 2004 or 2003, can't remember. It's a Pentium 4 , is it worth to jump in the I7 - Nehalem wagon? or a Q9550 x38 4 gig 800 is enough for gaming and some amateur editing?
Reply With Quote

i'm in a similar boat. I have aS478 P4 and I bought a laptop this summer to bridge the gap to i7. I think it was a good decision. When I build my Nehalem rig it will most likely still be my main rig 5 years from now just like my P4 rig was. I don't think you "need" i7 for what your doing but the upgrade headroom is so much better and the cost is not that much greater compared to your Q9550 setup. The only major cost diff is the mobo, $150-200 premium over x38, and the memory, $100-150 premium.

For people like us that hold onto a system for years it makes sense to me to go with the new architecture. I got into my last system at the end of S478 and AGP so it's been gimped for a long time. An i7 920 based system will leave tons of upgrade room on video cards and memory, not to mention a possible 32nm CPU upgrade if the 920 ever gets loaded. Your x38 is limited to ATI for multi-GPU setups and is using the venerable but aging DDR2 memory. My 2 pesos.
 
I already have most of the stuff I want in my new rig in my current rig. All I will be changing is the CPU, Motherboard, and memory. I will probably go for a nice custom watercooling kit as well.
 
i'm in a similar boat. I have aS478 P4 and I bought a laptop this summer to bridge the gap to i7. I think it was a good decision. When I build my Nehalem rig it will most likely still be my main rig 5 years from now just like my P4 rig was. I don't think you "need" i7 for what your doing but the upgrade headroom is so much better and the cost is not that much greater compared to your Q9550 setup. The only major cost diff is the mobo, $150-200 premium over x38, and the memory, $100-150 premium.

For people like us that hold onto a system for years it makes sense to me to go with the new architecture. I got into my last system at the end of S478 and AGP so it's been gimped for a long time. An i7 920 based system will leave tons of upgrade room on video cards and memory, not to mention a possible 32nm CPU upgrade if the 920 ever gets loaded. Your x38 is limited to ATI for multi-GPU setups and is using the venerable but aging DDR2 memory. My 2 pesos.

are you filipino?
 
If you've got a Core2 system you'd be dumb to waste money on an i7. If you can benefit from a quad core system just get a Core2quad and thats good enough for pretty much everyone.

My wolfdale at near 4Ghz is good enough for me for now. Later on at some point I'll just drop in a Penryn at OC it to 4Ghz. That'll last me a long time.
 
If you've got a Core2 system you'd be dumb to waste money on an i7. If you can benefit from a quad core system just get a Core2quad and thats good enough for pretty much everyone.

My wolfdale at near 4Ghz is good enough for me for now. Later on at some point I'll just drop in a Penryn at OC it to 4Ghz. That'll last me a long time.

That is true for you with only one GPU. MultiGPU in any form however is another story when i7 make a difference.
 
That is true for you with only one GPU. MultiGPU in any form however is another story when i7 make a difference.

That does not seem to be the case with one of the newest graphics engines out that does a great job of multithreading. If I were buying an i7 for gaming, I would looking forward in terms of 3D engines, not backward. I will get out an 790i board and strap the 2-way SLI to it and see what FC2 has to say about all of this. :) But I am not going to spend time evaluating 3D engines that are way past their prime.

1225698242I6VvskAKIu_4_3.gif
 
i'm in a similar boat. I have aS478 P4 and I bought a laptop this summer to bridge the gap to i7. I think it was a good decision. When I build my Nehalem rig it will most likely still be my main rig 5 years from now just like my P4 rig was. I don't think you "need" i7 for what your doing but the upgrade headroom is so much better and the cost is not that much greater compared to your Q9550 setup. The only major cost diff is the mobo, $150-200 premium over x38, and the memory, $100-150 premium.

For people like us that hold onto a system for years it makes sense to me to go with the new architecture. I got into my last system at the end of S478 and AGP so it's been gimped for a long time. An i7 920 based system will leave tons of upgrade room on video cards and memory, not to mention a possible 32nm CPU upgrade if the 920 ever gets loaded. Your x38 is limited to ATI for multi-GPU setups and is using the venerable but aging DDR2 memory. My 2 pesos.

There is sense in your post.

I might add that in my experience with this P4 I've had for over 4-5 years now, I've been able to play any games that support Shaders 2.0. You name it, I can run it. Of course, only at 1280x1024 with almost no eye candy but just because my ATI X800XT is bottlenecking and if it wasn't because AGP death I could have upgraded the GFX and still pull out some great graphics with decent fps.
I want a new system that lasts me for 3 years, at least. Meaning I only need to upgrade the graphics card once there are games that demand it.

A nehalem may very well be a feasible option for people who comes from a Pentium 4. Isn't it?
 
I already have most of the stuff I want in my new rig in my current rig. All I will be changing is the CPU, Motherboard, and memory. I will probably go for a nice custom watercooling kit as well.

So I guess you didn't get your Core i7 September? Just busting on you. You gave me so much grief in our little argument. :p
 
Back
Top