Digital Camera: Compact

Stormlifter

2[H]4U
Joined
Oct 19, 2002
Messages
2,968
I'm looking into getting a digital camera, I've owned a Casio Exilm ex-Z750, which I loved, had great video recording, but the flash was a bit weak.

I'm looking at

Canon SD700
Canon SD800
Canon SD900
Canon S80 < this thing is so hard to find and I think it's too expensive.


Anyone got a say on any of this or another recommendation?
 
I would go for the 900 to get the DigicIII processor and because of owner opinions I have seen:

Yesterday, I got home with my new sd800. And due to the scrutiny of the forums, I immediately had to test it. I compared exact duplicate shots from my SD550 to this “upgrade” sd800. I am very sad to say that in normal shooting conditions, this model just couldn’t keep up. The main things I saw the sd800 losing horribly to the sd550 in were: picture clarity, sharpness (edge to edge) and color accuracy (the sd800’s produces a very warm shot, too much yellow & red). This was a disappointment indeed when you compare the fact that my sd550 is almost a year old.

Now, on the flip-side, and should you ever find yourself in “overhead fan lighting,” this will be where the true benefits of the sd800 become VERY clear. If this is how you shoot, the IS will become a lifesaver for every single shot. But aside from a museum or other “no flash,” location, RARELY am I not using the flash on my camera. And I found the trick to not having over-saturation or too much flash contrast (whatever the model) is to just lower the brightness setting prior to shooting and use a bit of Photoshop shadow highlight love. (Although this can never fully prevent your shot from the flashlight effect left on objects from shooting, but it helps). This camera is only ideal for shooting in an IS situation. Period. Or at least IMHO, but it is my review right? lol

My solution was simple. I ended up taking a risk against better judgment, returned the sd800, and got the sd900. Let me just say that the quality from this camera will NEVER be achievable from an SD800. So make the call. If IS is your “make or break feature,” go for the 700is, or800is. However if its quality you want from your shots, and you aren’t found in low light situations often, the 550 or 900 are the way to go! Price per mega pixel being the only difference.

http://www.dpreview.com/reviews/read_opinion_text.asp?prodkey=canon_sd900&opinion=33341
 
hrmm... I do some low-light shots, will the SD900 really be terrible in those? It would seem it should do fine. Also the SD900 doesn't have IS, hrmmmm...
 
depending on your budget I'd recommend a intro DSLR. I have the D50 and I love it (of course...my lenses are worth about the same as the body but we won't go there) its not portable at all though. the SD700 is probably the one I'd recommend, I would not dump money into a point and shoot.
 
The part of the SD700 that bothers me is it can only take 1GB video...

Maybe I should go with a Exilim EX-Z750 or z850, or z1000
 
Make sure it has some form of Image Stability...
 
Yeah, I'm still strugling... :) Hard to pick one, I just need to pick one soon though, going to head to colorado and don't want to be without one.,
 
if you are going to take more video than pictures why dont you get ones of those video cameras that can take digital pictures too... i think ive seen some that do like 3mp pictures... which is ok
 
Well no, I guess I'm not going to take that much video that I'd actually want a video camera over a picture camera.

I'm leaning towards SD700 or SD900 now, a 4GB mem card can take about 45 mins of video that's probably enough.
 
Stormlifter said:
Goodness it's hard to choose...

Canon SD800
Canon SD900
Canon A710 IS

The A710 sure looks sweet. What's the difference between the models that start with A and the ones that start with SD?
 
Any other takers? I'm still without a solid choice,

seanmcd - nice recommendation, that F30 looks quite snappy, lookin' to see if the next revision of that line comes out.
 
Stormlifter said:
Any other takers? I'm still without a solid choice,

seanmcd - nice recommendation, that F30 looks quite snappy, lookin' to see if the next revision of that line comes out.
From what I've read -the F31fd is not going to add much in the way of features, besides their "Face recognition" crap. I've been taking photos for the last 20 years without any "face recognition" capabilities and I've done just fine... :) The one thing I dislike about the F30 is the proprietary battery. Not a big deal, but I prefer AA. You will not find anyone complaining about the F30 image quality though, top notch. There had been a $50 rebate on it recently - so you could get one for about $220 or so. Great deal.

If you could go a little bigger than compact, the Fuji S6000fd is really nice - has the same chip as the F30 but has a 28mm-300mm zoom, runs on standard AA batteries.
http://www.dpreview.com/reviews/FujifilmS6000fd/
 
Take a look at dcresource.com. I like his reviews. Here is a direct link to his reviews on the models you have listed. He hasn't reviewed the SD900 yet. The z850 review he mentions the 750 being pretty much the same camera.

http://www.dcresource.com/reviews/canon/powershot_sd700-review/

http://www.dcresource.com/reviews/canon/powershot_sd800-review/
http://www.dcresource.com/reviews/canon/powershot_sd800-review/gallery.shtml

http://www.dcresource.com/reviews/casio/exilim_z850-review/index.shtml

http://www.dcresource.com/reviews/fuji/finepix_f30-review/
http://www.dcresource.com/reviews/fuji/finepix_f30-review/gallery.shtml

My vote is for the Canon SD800 for image stabilization and face recognition (multiple focus points), overrall good picture quality plus Digic 3. Also, it uses SD cards which are used in many more devices so you can swap around or may not have to buy any.

F30 is very notable if you can live without IS, you gain higher ISO speeds for better shots if people are moving slightly plus a little better in low light. It also did better with red-eye. It uses xD cards though which may or may not be a con for you.
 
I'm debating, all the damn sample pics look the same on any damn digital camera that isn't an SLR...
I suppose I need to take freatures into account.

Things I'll take pics of

1) people in a house
2) nature
3) video of random things (15 min clips)
4) maybe use it for a macro shot now and then.

I hate xD memory

edit: I'm going to see what's on FS/FT, cause I think i'm good with any of the suggestions, it now boils down to getting a good deal I think..

edit2: ah, the Canon S3 IS looks so nice, to bad it's big.
 
Basically I'm deciding between SD800 and SD900

It appears as though the SD800 would be better with the IS and the ZOOM that it has..
What do you all think?

Also, any other suggestion besides the SD800 I'm about to buy.
 
Back
Top