Developer Reveals Mac Security Hole Without Telling Apple

I replied to your post which quoted my post...

And no, the 1st amendment does not apply here. Did you actually read what the post said before replying? The location had nothing to do with the argument.... He is not showing a flaw, he is releasing code to exploit a flaw. Showing a flaw would a proof of concept to show it can be done, not giving anyone the ability to exploit it. 2 completely different things, I can't believe you are having a hard time understanding that....

There's no difference. Proof of concept exploit code demonstrates the flaw. If I show how a lock is flawed and make a video that effectively demonstrates how to exploit that flaw, that's my right.

And your post said if he did it at a white hat convention, which implies the venue/audience matters. I don't agree. I think it's better to tell Apple and then demonstrate to researchers, but AFAIK, there's no difference from a legal perspective between the 2. Both are free speech (unless you can show me why it's not covered, while porn, movies, and books (just 3 examples) are).
 
I replied to your post which quoted my post...

And no, the 1st amendment does not apply here. Did you actually read what the post said before replying? The location had nothing to do with the argument.... He is not showing a flaw, he is releasing code to exploit a flaw. Showing a flaw would a proof of concept to show it can be done, not giving anyone the ability to exploit it. 2 completely different things, I can't believe you are having a hard time understanding that....

No, your original post was this http://hardforum.com/showpost.php?p=1041803260&postcount=34 (which was a reply to post I made in reply to Nenu (as quoted above)

And I see no difference between a proof of concept and code (which is also a proof of concept). As I said earlier, it's a dick move, but I fail to see how it's less protected than porn, a movie, a book, an article in the NY Times that might explain what the exploit is and how it was implemented (even though they wouldn't bore their audience with such details, they could).
 
sorry for the dupe. The first one didn't show up so I rewrote it. Really need an edit function [H]
 
Back
Top