Desperate search for blacker black levels.

I don't wonder if FP241W is unable to show anything resembling black:
Brightness: 500cd/m2
http://www.benq-eu.com/products/LCD/?product=636&page=specifications
There are many ways for makers to screw up LCD monitor!


Conditions in most shops are like tailor made for hiding differences between monitors: Very bright illumination, oversaturated advertising videos shown in center of monitor etc.
I don't think they'll let you switch off the lights, start adjusting brightness/contrast settings of monitors and looking own comparison photos, in US you would probably find yourself from the back seat of police car fast.


actually its not bad at all, once i calibrated it.

i'm a firm believer in display calibration. it can make a bad display look tons better.
i was also impressed with how good the benq calibrated but i couldnt get it under 167cd/m at 0 brightness. i think i had to settle on around 240 cd/m which is still pretty bright but anything lower brought out too much grey in the blacks. that was a good medium.
 
hell ya i do:)

i'm quite impressed with the black levels in mine.

i can say though they probably wouldnt be as good without the spectraview software though.
it made a huge difference from the default display out of the box.

kudos to NEC:D

Yeah the spectraview software is really good, even if you don't have a colour spider. The internal lookup table gives impressive results as is.

The difference between black levels (not to mention colours) was night and day (slight pun intended).
 
actually its not bad at all, once i calibrated it.

i'm a firm believer in display calibration. it can make a bad display look tons better.
i was also impressed with how good the benq calibrated but i couldnt get it under 167cd/m at 0 brightness. i think i had to settle on around 240 cd/m which is still pretty bright but anything lower brought out too much grey in the blacks. that was a good medium.

240cd/m2 ? Yikes. Way too bright for me. Is that your NEC? Does it have an economy mode that reducse backlight power?

Personally I like a comfortable white brightness more like 80 cd/m2. 200 cd/m2 scorches my Retinas.

Once you have the backlight on zero, any further attempt to lower brightness via changing calibration or graphics card settings will obviouis only work by changing LCD twist and affecting the brights while leaving the blacks the same, thus reducing contrast. Blacks may look more grey because you aren't blasting as much brightness to contrast it, but they shouldn't actual be getting any brighter.

I wish some manfuacturer would buck the trend of aiming for super powerd backlights and actually give us a comfortable one. 500cd/m2 is great for a TV where you are sitting 10 feet away, it is nuts for a monitor that you sit 2 feet away from. It is like staring at a lightbulb.
 
240cd/m2 ? Yikes. Way too bright for me. Is that your NEC? Does it have an economy mode that reducse backlight power?

Personally I like a comfortable white brightness more like 80 cd/m2. 200 cd/m2 scorches my Retinas.

Once you have the backlight on zero, any further attempt to lower brightness via changing calibration or graphics card settings will obviouis only work by changing LCD twist and affecting the brights while leaving the blacks the same, thus reducing contrast. Blacks may look more grey because you aren't blasting as much brightness to contrast it, but they shouldn't actual be getting any brighter.

I wish some manfuacturer would buck the trend of aiming for super powerd backlights and actually give us a comfortable one. 500cd/m2 is great for a TV where you are sitting 10 feet away, it is nuts for a monitor that you sit 2 feet away from. It is like staring at a lightbulb.

The NEC can go from very subtle backlight to a very impressive, uniform, and BRIGHT lighting. It really depends on what you use it for. I usually use mine around 170cd/m2 anything above 200 and I feel like I'm going to go blind.

I also have 3 of these LCDs, so if I had them all superbright I woudn't need any lights in the room :p
 
240cd/m2 ? Yikes. Way too bright for me. Is that your NEC? Does it have an economy mode that reducse backlight power?

Personally I like a comfortable white brightness more like 80 cd/m2. 200 cd/m2 scorches my Retinas.

Once you have the backlight on zero, any further attempt to lower brightness via changing calibration or graphics card settings will obviouis only work by changing LCD twist and affecting the brights while leaving the blacks the same, thus reducing contrast. Blacks may look more grey because you aren't blasting as much brightness to contrast it, but they shouldn't actual be getting any brighter.

I wish some manfuacturer would buck the trend of aiming for super powerd backlights and actually give us a comfortable one. 500cd/m2 is great for a TV where you are sitting 10 feet away, it is nuts for a monitor that you sit 2 feet away from. It is like staring at a lightbulb.

no, that was the benq. i have the NEC at 117 calibrated right now. 100cd/m is recommended for CRT and 120cd/m recommended for LCD for calibration/photo editing.
120 is actually quite soft on the eyes.
 
What is your definition of "subtle backlight"? That varies strongly from person to person. 170 cd/m2 is still strong to me. I use a CRT at work under office light and it is under 100 cd/m2.

At home my lighting is less strong than at work and I would prefer and even dimmer screen setting. Never a problem with CRT that you could set anywhere from 0 to 110 cd/m2 but when I tried a 24" LCD it was instant headaches from the excess brightness.
 
no, that was the benq. i have the NEC at 117 calibrated right now. 100cd/m is recommended for CRT and 120cd/m recommended for LCD for calibration/photo editing.
120 is actually quite soft on the eyes.


How close can you get to 100cd/m2 with just the backlight control? At home in dim lighting I find even 100cd/m2 quite bright (near the max of my CRTs rating). I have a CRT that is turned down a fair bit. I also have a 17" LCD that is one of the dimmest I have seen (smaller ones tend to have weaker backlights) and I run that 10% brightness. I estimate both my screens are well under 100cd/m2. I like a dim screen.

I am coming to the conclusion if I want something decent all around. The nec 2490 may be the only game in town. If it gets dim enough, I may have found a winner. Now I just have to find stock somewhere. These seem non existant in Canada.
 
The youtube video is of a 2407-HC which is hardly an old monitor. Here is another example. How bad the shift is, depends on the subject matter, how much it annoys you is a personal subjective issue. It drives me nuts.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CZnaMex2FUo

Or this one comparing IPS and PVA:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=91jDXHj1fN4


Personally I would rather have consistent blacks that are slightly less dark, that ones that shift like this.

Frankly these S-PVA monitors are the LAST thing I would buy. They have the worse input lags, the most strange overdrive artifacts and this gamma shift. Go read the the Dell 2408 thread, it sounds like it has more problems than the 2407-hc in almost every area.

Hmm... well I'm talking about a P-MVA, not an S-PVA. I get the impression that you are talking about all VA technology, and while my P-MVA does have gamma shift, it's not nearly as bad as all of those videos (as I said before).
 
How close can you get to 100cd/m2 with just the backlight control? At home in dim lighting I find even 100cd/m2 quite bright (near the max of my CRTs rating). I have a CRT that is turned down a fair bit. I also have a 17" LCD that is one of the dimmest I have seen (smaller ones tend to have weaker backlights) and I run that 10% brightness. I estimate both my screens are well under 100cd/m2. I like a dim screen.

I am coming to the conclusion if I want something decent all around. The nec 2490 may be the only game in town. If it gets dim enough, I may have found a winner. Now I just have to find stock somewhere. These seem non existant in Canada.

http://www.tigerdirect.ca/applications/category/category_slc.asp?Recs=10&Nav=|c:2775|&Sort=1

They seem to carry them. I got mine from NCIX, but they no longer seem to carry it. Pricing on Tiger Direct isn't bad. I think I paid about 200 more for my 2690 then what's listed on Tiger Direct.
 
Be careful with Tiger Direct, a few of the prices on that link are TERRIBLE!

Example: Westinghouse L2410NM is $574 at Tiger Direct, but only $350 at BB.
 
How close can you get to 100cd/m2 with just the backlight control? At home in dim lighting I find even 100cd/m2 quite bright (near the max of my CRTs rating). I have a CRT that is turned down a fair bit. I also have a 17" LCD that is one of the dimmest I have seen (smaller ones tend to have weaker backlights) and I run that 10% brightness. I estimate both my screens are well under 100cd/m2. I like a dim screen.

I am coming to the conclusion if I want something decent all around. The nec 2490 may be the only game in town. If it gets dim enough, I may have found a winner. Now I just have to find stock somewhere. These seem non existant in Canada.

on the NEC? it doesnt have a backlight control that i know of, and if it does, i havent found it yet because i havent needed to adjust it. the benq doesnt have a backlight control, only a brightness control. if you turn down the brightness too much on any LCD you start to lose your blacks.
on my CRT the brightness is at @ 31% and thats quite dim, but the blacks are so black that it doesnt matter, they stay black and dont start greying out.
it sounds like your eyes are more sensitive than average since you like screens so dim. the NEC does an excellent job of displaying black but you can only get so far with LCD's thats just the way they are.
 
The brightness control on every LCD I have see is the backlight control. People have even verified with power meter that turning down the brightness lowers power draw and I have read a ton of reviews where turning down the brightness proportionally dropped the black level as well (usually contrast is unaffected by changing brightness as both white and black drop in the same proportion). If you want the lowest absolute black level your backlight should be on zero.

Once the brightness (backlight) is minimized, you have to resort to contrast or calibration or video card settings to go lower, but this will not lower the backlight and kill your contrast. If you have to go this far to reduce brightness picture quality will suffer.
 
No, VA has not changed, and it can't really
Same goes for TN's vertical viewing angle: http://youtube.com/watch?v=-NYE_dk61j8 (halfway in video)
Little downwards from very narrow "spot of uniformity" and whole colour palette blacks out starting from top and dark colours (bright, centered and oversaturated advertising photos/videos shown in monitors at shops don't show this easily) and little upwards and darker colours get big brightness boost and black turns greyish... Brightness boost surely helps seeing shadow details not well visible at correct brightness (human vision's sensitivity to contrast varies depending brightness) but that has nothing to do with colour accuracy... and you can boost shadow brightness through graphic card's control panel for any monitor.
So going from VA to TN is like going from the ditch to the duck pond and IPS would be only logical choise then.

That video actually clears what this phenomenon is:
If those monitors were correctly and similarly adjusted "black crush" is entirely wrong name, it isn't about dark colours getting compressed/crushed but about dark colours getting brightness boost (=gamma shift) when viewed from angle which makes contrast in darker shades more visible to human vision similarly to TN being watched above that very narrow vertical viewing angle.
So let's leave black crush for TN panel's center/below center viewing and use correct name.

As for level of effect these videos are pretty useless except for telling that such phenomenon exists: (also clearly varies from panel model to other)
1. They're probably recorded with not so sensitive very low dynamic range sensor equipped consumer camcorder.
2. Which then often do contrast increasing processing to top of that... and now mostly save result in lossy format.
3. And as last step that already messed up content is downscaled and "put inside implosion primary" for making sure original bits/bytes are unrecognizable.


So IPS has better viewing angles/image quality but it doesn't automatically mean very small/zero lag, these NECs are quite comparable to lower lag VAs.
And Dell's newer IPS monitors are pretty horrible and similar to high lag VAs.


Again if game uses dark colour palette it's always dark unless shadow brightness is boosted in one way or another.

BTW, human vision system is one of the crappiest possible brightness/colour meters and for it nearly everything is relative:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Same_color_illusion
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Image:Gradient-optical-illusion.svg
 
Same goes for TN's vertical viewing angle: [
So going from VA to TN is like going from the ditch to the duck pond and IPS would be only logical choise then.

I mostly agree. IPS would be best. VA has horizontal gamma shift, TN has vertical gamma shift.

But I find horizontal gamma shift MUCH more annoying for two reason, I move a lot more horizontally when I am in front of my monitor and my eyes are horizontal and on two PVA screens I owned there was enough shift to present a different image to each eye. It drove me nuts, I replaced it with TN screen and haven't been bothered since, unless I turn the TN to vertical portrait mode, then it drives me nuts as well. Same monitor completely tolerable (but not great) in landscape and intolerable in portrait, because the direction of gamma shift makes a big difference. Horizontal shift is more problematic than vertical shift. It would be best of course to have no shift.

If those monitors were correctly and similarly adjusted "black crush" is entirely wrong name, it isn't about dark colours getting compressed/crushed but about dark colours getting brightness boost (=gamma shift) when viewed from angle

You will note that in my post above that you quoted, I call it gamma shift. I sometime refer to black crush, because some others call it that, and they will know what I am talking about, but I make it clear that I am referring to the angular gamma shift. While in some ways the youtube videos exaggerate the affect, I find it 10x worse in person to be sitting behind one of these panels at full size where it shifts gamma when you move half an inch, than watching a tiny vid of the effect.


So IPS has better viewing angles/image quality but it doesn't automatically mean very small/zero lag,

Viewing angles have nothing to do with lag of course. But basically from my experience and investigations I have found that VA panels are the slowest to react and need the most overdrive which tends to mean more processing and more lag, and more overdrive artifacts.

Yes you can find exceptions to everything. NEC professional monitor are geared toward the best possible stationary images and they use frame buffers and 12 bit LUTs with much image processing and they have about 2 frames of lag, which is still better than most PVA panels. Dell did manage to screw up the 3008 big time, can you find another S-IPS that bad, I can find many PVAs that are.

Now try comparing apples to apples: Two 30inch screens with no scalers or processing to speak of:
http://www.digitalversus.com/duels.php?ty=6&ma1=36&mo1=238&p1=2303&ma2=88&mo2=237&p2=2302&ph=12

On the whole S-IPS panels tend to be faster than VA. The other big factor is overdrive artifacts which tend to be plentiful on PVAs as well.

Read the current 2408 thread horror show, read about the 2407 overdrive ghosting, even present on the NEC with the PVA panel.

As a former owner of two PVAs, I won't touch one with a ten foot pole, lag, overdrive issue and horizontal gamma shift make them a complete no go for me. I LOL everyone talks about the better black on PVA...

My suggestion start with TN because they have the best value, best speed, lowest lag, no overdrive artifacts and good horizontal gamma stability. If you think the TN has inadequate quality (after seeing it for yourself) go for an IPS where you will get better image quality but you will likely be sacrificing speed/lag. Go for a PVA if you are oblivious to a range of defects (overdrive artifacts, generally higest input lag, worse horizontal gamma shift) and you feel the need to spend more than a TN screen costs. :D
 
How close can you get to 100cd/m2 with just the backlight control? At home in dim lighting I find even 100cd/m2 quite bright (near the max of my CRTs rating). I have a CRT that is turned down a fair bit. I also have a 17" LCD that is one of the dimmest I have seen (smaller ones tend to have weaker backlights) and I run that 10% brightness. I estimate both my screens are well under 100cd/m2. I like a dim screen.

I am coming to the conclusion if I want something decent all around. The nec 2490 may be the only game in town. If it gets dim enough, I may have found a winner. Now I just have to find stock somewhere. These seem non existant in Canada.

Be careful if you plan on getting an NEC *WUXi , behardware wasn't to impressed with its 'actual' response time (in case you play a lot of games) and strong twinkling w/ movies: http://www.behardware.com/articles/648-6/nec-multisync-lcd2690wuxi-the-first-26-inch.html
 
need the most overdrive which tends to mean more processing and more lag
Overdrive isn't any excuse for multiframe lag because it doesn't need knowledge of future frames:
http://www.national.com/appinfo/fpd/files/48_03.pdf
So it's that other processing which causes majority of lag, also there seems to be at least some correlation between input lag and gamut size in Dell and Samsung monitors.
And in TNs spatial and temporal dithering processing required for attempting to show missing 16½ M colours seems to be lifting their lag to multiple frame level. (so in them good colours probably means lag similar to balanced VA monitors)

As for gamma shift problem, about year ago I recommended LG 2000C for one photography hobbying neighbour because it received good reviews and was specced as IPS. Now basing to threads in here it has actually used all three panel types and during last visit I watched monitor closely and noticed some shadow brightness increase when viewed from angle. But it wasn't any problem because it become easily noticeable only around 35 degree angle and was fraction of that in video!

Be careful if you plan on getting an NEC *WUXi , behardware wasn't to impressed with its 'actual' response time (in case you play a lot of games) and strong twinkling w/ movies: http://www.behardware.com/articles/648-6/nec-multisync-lcd2690wuxi-the-first-26-inch.html
So in the name of fairness that means also IPSes are crap...
Looks like we should start organizing demonstrations for pressuring makers to forget tweaking these faulty liquid crystal kludges and concentrate research to real flat display technologies.
 
actually its not bad at all, once i calibrated it.
...had to settle on around 240 cd/m which is still pretty bright...
Well you certainly had better luck then me because I tried several times to calibrate my FP241W, each time lowering the brightness level (started at the default value of 100% down to around 30) and the monitor still blinds when displaying white and is more grey than black when viewing black backgrounds. It's really prominent when watching a 16:9 movie and the surrounding letterboxing is grey rather than black.

But maybe it's because my calibration tool, A Spyder 2 Express, is to rudimentary to properly calibrate such a bright monitor...

Any tips you may have (such as what brightness and contrast levels you started with prior to calibration) will be much appreciated :D
 
The blackest blacks I've ever seen on a monitor/TV were on the Samsung 4066 LCD TV. It has a glossy screen and a PVA panel. It was dramatically darker than any other screen in BB. In a dark room the difference might not be so pronounced.

I believe the best blacks were on the the Sony 60/70" XBR2 SXRD sets, but good luck finding either of those new....might find the 60" at Frys.

Oh wait, were you limiting this to LCD TVs ;)
 
For your budget Eizo S2231W could just fit in
I picked one up last week and over all, I'm quite happy with it! And talk about blackest of blacks... :D
It has an odd, ah, characteristic that is either associated with the panel itself or Eizo's backlighting, which I like to call FACTOR X...

Anyways, I hilighted my observations, along with pics over at PRAD's English forums

:)
 
Back
Top