Cool Car Commercial

I think I'd argue with that "send the money overseas" line as I know people and have friends that work at the Honda plant in Marysville, Ohio. Without people buying the cars, those folks would all be out of jobs so... the majority of that cost of a new Honda stays here in the US, believe it or not, and most of the US purchased Hondas are made here in the US by people here in the US getting paid to build 'em.

My 09 Honda Civic Si is 60% American, assembled in Ontario, Canada. (Which is 15% shy of being considered "Made in the USA" by the government.)
The only thing Japanese is the Engine and Transmission.

Just for thought...
According to the government, these "American" cars are imports.

MAKE/MODEL ASSEMBLY PARTS STATUS
Jeep Liberty USA 74% IMPORT
Dodge Ram USA 74% IMPORT
Jeep Cherokee USA 73% IMPORT
Lincoln NavigatorUSA 70% IMPORT
Dodge Caliber USA 70% IMPORT

According to the government, these are domestic...

MAKE/MODEL ASSEMBLY PARTS STATUS
Toyota Sienna USA 85% DOMESTIC
Toyota Camry USA 80% DOMESTIC
Toyota Tundra USA 80% DOMESTIC
Honda Ridgeline USA 75% DOMESTIC
Honda Pilot USA 75% DOMESTIC

NOTHING is 100% made in America.
Ford Econoline is the closest at 95%.
 
List from 2006.....

MAKE/MODEL ASSEMBLY PARTS STATUS
Ford F-Series USA 85% DOMESTIC
Chevrolet Silverado USA 90% DOMESTIC
Toyota Camry USA 80% DOMESTIC
Dodge Ram USA 74% IMPORT
Honda Accord USA 70% IMPORT
Honda Civic USA 70% IMPORT
Chevrolet Impala CANADA 92% IMPORT
Dodge Grand Caravan – SWB USA 83% DOMESTIC
Nissan Altima USA 65% IMPORT
Chevrolet Cobalt USA 75% DOMESTIC
Toyota Corolla USA 75% DOMESTIC
GMC Sierra USA 90% DOMESTIC
Ford Focus USA 60% IMPORT
Ford Explorer USA 80% DOMESTIC
Chevrolet Malibu USA 80% DOMESTIC
Honda Odyssey USA 70% IMPORT
Ford Mustang USA 60% IMPORT
Toyota Tacoma USA 70% IMPORT
Chevrolet TrailBlazer USA 85% DOMESTIC
Chevrolet Tahoe USA 67% IMPORT

Surprising, isnt it? Ford Mustang is an IMPORT....
 
The parts imported? Sure... not gonna even attempt to argue that. Assembled in the US? Most of 'em in the US, yep... but the point holds. Someone else pointed out how we're a global economy earlier, and while it's not 100% accurate, sooner or later we probably will be.
 
4000lb, handles like shit, single digit miles per gallon, has no body lines..? Yes. It's shit. The SRT8 just barely matches my 4-cylinder in 0-60 and quarter mile times... but it costs about $12,000 more than mine.

Some of your points on previous pages are valid, and I can tell you're definitely passionate about your arguments (as usual:D). I agree that when a company stops making crap, I will buy. I think GM and Ford have been steadily improving their bodies - GM not quite as good as Ford yet - and this is good. But there's still the engines to think about. In 2007 my mom was looking to buy an SUV. Their old Ford Aerostar with 300k miles (been through two or three wrecks to boot) was finally about to kick the bucket. What a tank, that beast. They were looking at a small SUV like the CRV, Vue, Blazer, etc. I did some research on various models, as they were planning on buying new or close to new, and big purchases like that I research just as much as computer hardware purchases.

I found that the Chevy Equinox 6 cyl., while slightly more pricey than its Saturn V6 counterpart, produced 30-40 less horsepower and had worse fuel mileage than the Saturn V6. Turns out Honda manufactured the V6 and 4 cyl. engines for the Vues of 2007. The good ol' American motors just didn't compare to what Honda was making for us at the time. My mom went with the Vue, has put a lot of miles on it, and hasn't had a single issue to date.

Ford on the other hand ... well, this is what Consumer Reports had to say:

"Ford's three brands-Ford, Lincoln, and Mercury-continue to pull away from the rest of the Detroit automakers. Almost all Ford models are now average or better, with the exception of some that are truck-based. Excluding those, Ford's reliability is now on par with good Japanese automakers.

Chrysler Sebring
LOW The Chrysler Sebring Convertible has the worst predicted-reliability score among new cars in our survey. It is 283 percent worse than the average model.
General Motors is a mixed bag. Among the bright spots is the redesigned Chevrolet Malibu; in its first year, the four-cylinder version is better than average and the V6 is average. The Buick Lucerne with a V8 and the Pontiac G6 with a four-cylinder are above average, and the Chevrolet Avalanche has improved to average.

But a quarter of GM models are still well below average in reliability. Some that didn't fare well are fairly new designs that did well in our testing, such as the Cadillac CTS and the Buick Enclave, GMC Acadia, and Saturn Outlook SUV triplets. Chrysler trails the pack. Almost two-thirds of its products rate below average for reliability. The redesigned 2008 Chrysler Town & Country and Dodge Grand Caravan minivans earned low scores, as did the Chrysler Sebring V6 and Dodge Avenger sedans and the Jeep Liberty SUV. The Sebring Convertible has the worst score: 283 percent worse than average. The only above-average models are the Dodge Caliber hatchback and Jeep Patriot SUV."

This is the 3rd year in a row that Ford has made more progress than the other two American brands at improving build quality, and they just happen to be the one automaker that didn't need any bailout money, even though they wanted it available just in case...

Many of their successful cars are based on Mazda and Volvo platforms with Ford's newer, much-improved build quality on the bodies. Their half ton F150 has generally fared well, also, at least in my own research. I have some way richer than myself friends that own a large construction company in Utah. It's a pair of brothers and their dad. They are still in business today, but when they were just getting started, they purchased equal amounts of fleet trucks - 1/3 Ford, 1/3 Chevy, 1/3 Dodge, mostly half-ton models with a few compact models and of course some larger ones as well. They kept incredibly accurate books on everything - fuel mileage, repair costs, repair frequency, regular maintenance costs, etc. Over a period of 2-3 years the Fords consistently cost less to own and operate. I'm sure there are some of you that may have different experiences with your Fords who might even subscribe to the old "found on road dead" acronym. But data from well over 130 trucks with daily use spoke volumes as to overall build quality, and carried a lot more weight in my mind than individual bad experiences. They have gradually phased in more Fords and less of the others, but to this day they still buy a few Dodges and Chevys every year and track reliability and operating cost data on them. If they start to excel more so than their Fords, they have no qualms with gradually phasing to another brand.

While not all domestics are created equal, it's the same with Japanese models. When we bought our Prius we carefully researched and test drove many other vehicles, including the similarly priced Honda Civic hybrid. Both cost the same, but the Honda had much less passenger room, a noticeably rougher ride, worse acceleration, and less cargo room. The Prius for the same price came with vehicle stability (traction) control and a rear view camera for the same price as the Civic without. We've had it for a year and a half. It saved us over $2500 is gas its first year, all while providing us with curtain airbags and the same cargo/passenger room as a Camry, but cheaper than the Camry. Of course that was when gas was $3.00 or more a gallon, but who's to say it will stay below $2.00 for long ... and we put so many miles on ... we've already got almost 60,000 miles on it! I change the oil and do most of the other maintenance on it myself. Easiest oil change in the world. The thing hasn't given us one single problem, even a minor one, yet. Not only does it continue to post some of the highest reliability among cars, but even among Toyotas it's one of the most reliable cars they make.

And I'm not fretting about that battery. When they were testing the new 2004 models they took a touring and a base model and just started driving and driving, simulating real world usage as best as possible. When they got to 160,000 miles and the batteries were still performing over 90% of brand new, they gave up and quit testing. I know people with over 300,000 miles on the original batteries.

There are people that have some great experiences with vehicles, and some not so great. I used to research automobiles as much as I now research computer hardware, and I've seen lots of trends over the years. Ford is definitely trending up, and it's showing.

And even though I sent my money to Toyota, they provide the most U.S. jobs per 1000 cars produced of any foreign manufacturer: 17. Now that's a two-edged sword because there's something to be said for efficiency. Why does it take 17 employees for Toyota to produce 1000 cars when it only takes Hyundai 7? Well for one, there's the kind of cars manufactured to account for. But GM takes over 40 employees to make their 1000 cars. Now you can argue that GM provides way more jobs, but now their less efficient processes (along with pension and union problems) have come back to bite them in the butt.

It will be interesting to see how this pans out.
 
A coworker of mine keeps trying to convince me Hyundais are great, in spite of them being cheap, Korean pieces of crap.

That would be because they are good, and have been on par with Japanese cars for over a decade now. They follow the same cycle against the Japanese that the Japanese did against the Americans.

My dad bought a 1994 Hyundai Excel GL new off the showroom floor. Oh, he had many friends telling him it was a cheap, Korean piece of crap and that he'd probably never get it to 100k miles. He didn't listen. After a few years of faithful service, he drove it across the country. After a few more years of faithful service, he took a job that involved driving. Lots and lots of driving. Hundreds of miles a week across the bay area. 11 years and well over 230,000 miles later, he decided it was time to say goodbye. It was still running, still getting him 35+ mpg, still in one piece. But some teenager in and SUV backed into it and he couldn't open the hood to change the oil. I imagine it's still out there, running like a champ as it always has.

He bought a used Toyota to replace it, but at 230k miles it snapped the timing chain.

It's been a while since I've even had an American-made rental car, but the ones I've rode in have just felt like cheap tinfoil pieces of crap that would fall apart if I looked at them wrong. Maybe things have changed, but I would like to see long term reliability figures and see how they stack up to the Jap automakers.

Put it this way, I've known too many people with American (and German, I'm not too impressed with them either) cars that have been continually in the shop for repairs. In comparison, I bought my Civic new and have had it a lot longer than I wanted to (over 12 years), and with regular maintenance (following the recommendations religiously) it has not given me problem one in all these years. It's been all I could ask for, which is why I'm buying another one.

As someone else mentioned, rentals tend to be crap, though I have driven models from each of the big three. Sepcifically, it was a Chevy Cobalt, a Ford Focus, and a Dodge Neon. The Cobalt and the Focus were btoh fine cars. Cheap fleet cars, for sure, but still enjoyable. The Dodge Neon was horrible. It had a spartan interior, a weak and buzzy motor, and some of the worst handling I've ever dealt with in a car. I also drove a Merceds C240 several times. Best rental car I've ever touched. Powerful, efficient motor. Superb handling. Smooth ride. Feature-packed and very comfortable. I'd take it in a heartbeat.

I also own a 1994 Chevy Lumina that I inherited from my grandmother. She took it in for regular maitenence and didn't drive it much. I drove it across the country with no issue, and in 15 years the biggest repair it's had to undergo was to replace the radiator. And that was just a few months ago. It's not a flashy car by any means, but it still drives like a champ, is capable of 30mpg despite its size and older V6 motor (Outclassing my friend's '89 Camry V6, and another friend's '01 Dodge Stratus V6 in gas mileage), and provides a rather comfortable ride.

Thing is, every other Lumina I've seen on the road is piece of crap. I guess owner reposnibility is a large factor in vehicle reliability.

My point is, it's all anecdotal. I believe Hyundais are fine cars because I've seen it demonstrated. I believe Fords are crap because all the Fords I see driven by friends are pieces of crap. I believe my car to be a rare exception to the rule that mid-90s domestics are generally crap. I have a high opinion of German cars because every German car I've sat in is a work of art. But the owners of German cars tend to be fanatical about them as well. I also firmly believe the Prizm was just a crappier version of the Totyota Corrola because compared to the Corrolas I'd seen, the Prizm was a piece of crap.

As for the folks comparing I4s and V8s, let me give you a tidbit: The world does not revolve around you. 0-60 times and horsepower are not a good indicator of the capability of a motor. Not every vehicle is built to be light and fast or handle well. Big motors will not die because you're never going to do serious hauling of anything an an I4, no matter how much horsepower you think you can turbocharge out of it. At the same time, having a V8 just because it sounds manly is a pretty bad reason to have a V8. For one thing, you're average V8 doesn't even sound that great. Many I4's will sound better, and many 6-cylinders as well (I happen to believe that combined with the right exhaust setup, the VW VR6 is quite possibly one of the nicest sounding motors ever.). For small, light vehicles, a turbo-I4 will serve better than any V8. For slightly larger vehicles, NA 6-cylinders today offer the performance of large V8s of just a few years ago.

Of course, I'm also of the opinion that diesel really needs to be used more. Many people like to quote horsepower when talking motors, but what most people really care about (without knowing it) is torque. Diesels give you gobs and gobs of torque, with good fuel efficiency, with mechanical reliability that most gassers can only dream about. If you're buying a truck for hauling, or for even sounding cool, do it right and go diesel. It gives you the opportunity to convert to bio-diesel or WVO, gives you incredible towing ability, and goes longer on a gallon of fuel. Check out the VW 5.0 V10 TDI. It makes an everyday SUV capable of towing a jumbo jet.

It's an exciting time for automobiles. There are changes coming. A lot of what is being done is being done wrong, and blindly adhering to "party lines", whether it be by make or country of origin, is just as dumb with automobiles as it is with politics. A lot of what is being done is being done right. Ford is making huge strides in improvement and Chevy is doing what it can to wake up to the 21st century. Honda and Toyota are competing against each other with hybrid cars which means they will further improve the line. Cars will likely never be the same.
 
Back
Top