China Postpones Controversial Web Filter

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
It looks as though all the media attention may have worked, China has postponed its plans to require all PCs to come with web-filtering software.

The rule would have required manufacturers to include filtering software known as Green Dam with every computer produced for sale in China starting Wednesday. A two-sentence announcement by the government's Xinhua News Agency said regulators "will delay" the plan but gave no indication whether it might take effect later. It gave no other details.
 
Just a small delay, probably a bug. Don't get your hopes up for a permanent stoppage. The government does not listen to the people, unless their is a revolution and an overthrow of the government.
 
Just a small delay, probably a bug. Don't get your hopes up for a permanent stoppage. The government does not listen to the people, unless their is a revolution and an overthrow of the government.

That 'delay' speak is a face-saving measure: the software will be put on the back-burner until people forget about it, then it'll be silently abandoned. That's how it works here.
 
That 'delay' speak is a face-saving measure: the software will be put on the back-burner until people forget about it, then it'll be silently abandoned. That's how it works here.
This is China we are talking about. Expect them to say its done while not caring about doing it in silence.
 
Haha, like it matters. I've heard that it's as easy as pie to bypass, mostly because it only works with IE. FF, Opera, and Chrome slip right through. :p
 
funny since its spyware and has lots of security issues... will the government use it on their own pcs.. and if not... are they better people?
 
I don't think that this would have really hinder people who actually have some knowledge of things...
 
I don't think that this would have really hinder people who actually have some knowledge of things...

Just so: there's some cat here that goes by the name of Tomato Lei. He pwns Microsoft OSes. Every time MS comes up with an IP hurdle, he vaults it in no time flat. He's kind of a hero. I expect his 'versions' of XP and Vista would include work-arounds for Green Dam.
 
What change? It's true. I appreciate the truth. China's not perfect, but it's not a bad place at all. Most Chinese have been great friends to me, and I just don't like people going after my friends. I think that's pretty understandable. Criticism I have no problem with, it's just when people start in with the whole 'piling on' thing, spewing trash that is nowhere near the truth, that I feel a need to set the record straight.

As for the Green Dam software (unless some idiot makes some big show about what a great haxor he is by posting pron on a government website or something) it's not going to be heard of much more. Like I said earlier, that's how it works here. They ran it up the flagpole and got the wrong kind of salute.
 
I think most, like me, when we deride "China" we are not talking about the people of China at all.... we are talking about the Government, which can stop getting tongue lashed any time they want, just surrender and free the people and implement a true representative democracy.

I agree with you, the software was a bad idea, from a non-technically savvy official, and reality landed on his/her plan like a ton of fortune cookies. So to save face, it is "postponed"... aka PONED. :p:eek::D:cool:
 
Most people in China are pretty indifferent. Americans are actually more outraged than the Chinese people are (which is sort of funny). As long as the government can continue to steadily improve quality of life, on the whole, you won't hear too many complaints about freedom or democracy or etc., from the vast majority of Chinese people. And that's the way I feel too.

By the way, I am a Chinese immigrant, and I would rather my government, wherever it is, focus on economic stability and economic issues, than (petty) activist rights groups. Survival is #1. Everything comes after that.
 
True, when generations on end have grown up in nothing but tyranny of one sort or another, it's hard to get motivated for what you don't even know. It is a cultural difference, where as a couple hundred years of British rule and we Irish had all we could take, and spent 600 years working to kick the Brits out of our country. Celtic people's have always had a thing about others telling them what to do... a very disagreeable lot. :D

But China has been under someone's thumb for thousands of years, so its a different culture.

The Chinese government... this one...is more than just a case of humanitarian violations that piss off all the earthy crunchies, they engage in other activities that are really very dangerous.

From artificially devaluing the currency, to cyber and real spying, to threatening our friend and ally Taiwan (whom we have pledged to fight to the death to protect... Ike), to a rather needless military build up that makes our Defense industries very happy.

It's like poking a stick in a hornets nest, eventually.... :eek:
 
True, when generations on end have grown up in nothing but tyranny of one sort or another, it's hard to get motivated for what you don't even know. It is a cultural difference, where as a couple hundred years of British rule and we Irish had all we could take, and spent 600 years working to kick the Brits out of our country. Celtic people's have always had a thing about others telling them what to do... a very disagreeable lot. :D

But China has been under someone's thumb for thousands of years, so its a different culture.

The Chinese government... this one...is more than just a case of humanitarian violations that piss off all the earthy crunchies, they engage in other activities that are really very dangerous.

From artificially devaluing the currency, to cyber and real spying, to threatening our friend and ally Taiwan (whom we have pledged to fight to the death to protect... Ike), to a rather needless military build up that makes our Defense industries very happy.

It's like poking a stick in a hornets nest, eventually.... :eek:

You've got some things right, but it sounds like you've been drinking too much of your government's kool aid. That doesn't surprise me though.
 
Most people in China are pretty indifferent. Americans are actually more outraged than the Chinese people are (which is sort of funny). As long as the government can continue to steadily improve quality of life, on the whole, you won't hear too many complaints about freedom or democracy or etc., from the vast majority of Chinese people. And that's the way I feel too.

By the way, I am a Chinese immigrant, and I would rather my government, wherever it is, focus on economic stability and economic issues, than (petty) activist rights groups. Survival is #1. Everything comes after that.

Just so! This is exactly how people here feel about the matter.

@ Jack_Carver: The Chinese people don't have any want or need for 'representative democracy' which, as it is usually understood in America, relies on an educated electorate who are capable of asessing the issues and choosing someone to represent their collective wish as a community. That's why the founding fathers gave the right of suffrage only to landowners: because at the time they were the only class that were educated and experienced enough to make those decisions.

Well, a similar scenario exists here in China. Even if there were a wish for suffrage (which there isn't), China hasn't yet overcome the legacies of foreign aggression and war to the point where the populace considered as a whole would be capable of making those necessary decisions.

I need to add that western-style 'representative democracy' would never work here in China. It is incompatible with Chinese culture and tradition, and the Chinese value their culture far above transitory political winds. And just like the Irish you spoke of earlier (whose blood we both share), they will never accept a system imposed upon them from abroad; whether that imposition is by force or coercion. Whatever change eventually manifests, it must be native-born and compatible with the Chinese spirit. Brow-beating the Chinese just causes them to dig-in their heels over whatever issue is under debate.

Lastly, if a citizen wishes to have a direct say in political matters, he can join the party and effect change from within. But here in China there is just one team, the home team. You either play on the team (as a party member), root for the team from the sidelines, or get out of Dodge because you're not welcome. The Chinese people established this order themselves, and have (as Cyrilix mentioned) a powerful sense of "If it ain't broke, don't fix it". And in Chines eyes it may not be the best but it sure as hell isn't broken.
 
@Pepsiennis: Yes, I agree. And like I mention in other threads, eventually, the Chinese will have more freedoms, but only when they're ready. It may be 100 years, 1000 years, or 10000 years, but if and when the rest of the world improves, China will improve with it. The people in China today have the responsibility of building a sustainable legacy for China in the future and the responsibility of ensuring that the next generation maintains the tradition, even if they can't savor the fruits of their labor. Unfair? Certainly. Life's unfair. You can only do what you can to make it better bit by bit.
 
By the way, on the topic of the Green Dam filter, I would like to say that I fully agree with their removal of this software as a requisite. This is simply a bad way of doing things, and does more harm than good. I'm glad that they realized this before it was too late.
 
And that legacy is what the government here is building. Famine used to be a perennial problem in China, but this government has wiped it out. Poverty? It was once every Chinese person's inheritence, but each year fewer and fewer live in poverty. Education? Each year a greater number of young men and women go to college. Significant progress has been made, is being made, towards guaranteeing a better quality of life for all Chinese.

I know it's not popular to admit that a socialist government succeeded (mostly because most socialist governments have failed miserably), but it is the case with modern China that a socialist government is succeeding. I can see how that threatens democracy's 'monopoly', but it is what's best for the Chinese people at this time, because it is what they want at this time. In America and many other countries, we see the government and the people as two separate entities, which they usually are. But in China the people, while often expecting more from the government, do see the government as an extension of themselves (at least in the international arena), so an attack on the government is felt to be an attack on the Chinese people and taken quite personally. So I just hope we can respect the Chinese people's wishes, butt out of their domestic affairs, so that they can represent their wishes themselves.

As to green Dam, I agree, it was a well-intentioned notion but thoroughly impossible to impliment. And the Chinese people themselves have spoken quietly but clearly on the matter: they don't want it. The government heard the people's wish and have tabled the idea. Everything done quietly, calmly, successfully in the Chinese way.
 
Back
Top