China Defends Net Filtering Software Amid Outcry

as a fan of marxism and not a fan of maoism this is the original communist argument in short:

steal from the rich, give to the poor.

further explained: take over opressive land owners, and corporations and governments and give it back to the people (an argument often used to justify the invasion of serfdom Tibet).

is that what happened?

afterwords, they stole all objects of value from all people, temples and businesses, basically destroying the economy and way of life in tibet. then gave it back to the Han military and wealthy communist elites in China. that is not what marx had in mind.

steal from the poor and give to the rich, then oppress them for the next millienium is not what communism is, but is what has happened in the tibetan, muslim and mongololian regions of "modern day china". the "landlords" overthrown, do you think all the land was given to the people?

hahaah yea right, read some books. they were fed rations and told to grow rice in the snow, don't know how much rice they got... but i know thousands starved to death.

I don't know enough about the above to give you a comment on this one, so I surrender the point to you. A lot of the things done by the Communist party were probably heavy-handed and poor choices of actions, but I'm almost certain that "steal from the poor and give to the rich" is not the party line, with the exception of corrupt officials (which you have in every government).
 
You're qualifier, ...without good reason, is why your views are not and can not be justified. Without good reason is vague and open to myriads of interpretation that can be used to justify anything that the powers that be deem.

But this is the logic that China is using to justify their net filtering products. It may start with something that you deem necessary, but sooner rather than later history supports, governments then deem that the people need more oversight for their betterment and start taking away rights and privileges that you once had for the greater good of "their new powers".

Basically, its the old adage of putting a frog in water and slowly turning the heat up until it croaks due to the heat.

Yes, but, if you look at the United States Bill of Rights, are not many of the clauses there also highly subjective? They use the term "excessive" a lot such as "excessive bail" or "excessive fines imposed", or how about "unreasonable searches and seizures"? Can you truly look at this in a purely objective sense?
 
as long as I can keep posting on [H] my opinions, beliefs and random facts, then I'm a happy guy. I just think everyone should have the same rights as us, thats my belief. I know reality vs belief, but we as lazy americans cannot deny the plight of others, and as communists its a shame when they deny their own plights as well.
 
I know reality vs belief, but we as lazy americans cannot deny the plight of others, and as communists its a shame when they deny their own plights as well.
You're confusing communism and fascism.
 
Is there much difference?

Communism (minus cuba) and Fascism in practice have much more in common than they do differences.

Vietnam and Cuba are the only two examples who have made efforts in some ways to make things "Better"... China has improved things dramatically if you are han (and not one of the 175 minorities) and speak manderine or cantonise.

when maoists in cambodia killed 1 million plus people in a year or two... vietnam eventually said enough is enough and helped end their regime.

thats a whole nother bucket of oranges.

regardless of your political regime, you should not hide the truth, it only makes people question their beliefs. you have to be honest from the start. its what the communists in the 1800's fought for, and today try to hide themselves.

you cannot say "War is wrong" then go join a communist group and blow up a building in the name of mao (maoists in other countries) your just being a hyprocrite.

communism: hides the truth
democracy: people don't care

we need a better system.
 
Well, that's simply not a good way to think about things. I'm specifically referring to "if you support censoring others, censor your self first. install green dam". America and China are different. Where one principle may apply in one country does not mean that it applies in the other country. There are a lot of circumstantial reasons for this, but one of them is country size. You cannot all of a sudden just give freedoms to a billion people. You can only introduce freedom in very small quantities over time, and see where that lands you. This is not a "do unto others as you would like done to you" situation.

Exactly right, Cyrilix. To just throw open the flood gates would bring ruin to China... the place would fracture into many pieces and devolve into warlords and despots with no plan for people's good beyond what was good for the despot himself. And the trend over the last thirty years has been one of steadily increasing freedoms. To give them what some here advocate (in the way they advocate) is like opening the door they are leaning on... they'll all fall face down on the ground. How does that help them as 'men'? Bringing a whole nation lower never helps them, only others. China will never allow another country to trip it up again.

as a fan of marxism and not a fan of maoism this is the original communist argument in short:

steal from the rich, give to the poor.

further explained: take over opressive land owners, and corporations and governments and give it back to the people (an argument often used to justify the invasion of serfdom Tibet).

is that what happened?

afterwords, they stole all objects of value from all people, temples and businesses, basically destroying the economy and way of life in tibet. then gave it back to the Han military and wealthy communist elites in China. that is not what marx had in mind.

steal from the poor and give to the rich, then oppress them for the next millienium is not what communism is, but is what has happened in the tibetan, muslim and mongololian regions of "modern day china". the "landlords" overthrown, do you think all the land was given to the people?

hahaah yea right, read some books. they were fed rations and told to grow rice in the snow, don't know how much rice they got... but i know thousands starved to death.

Bullshit, they did no such thing, jroe! They took nothing from Xizang (what you call tibet), but did bring public health care, education, sanitation, and a thriving tourist trade to people who otherwise had nothing. And as of the early 90's, all the land WAS given to the people. Given outright to the peasant that was living on it OR working it. And now they are free to resell it or continue working it as they choose. And one last thing to all of you knocking Mao for 'starving' people. He did no such thing intentionally! In the 50's and 60's, due to failed economic reforms combined with floods along the Yangze River region (the agricultural heartland of China), there WAS famine, and millions did die. But the idea that Mao intentionally starved anyone, even opponents, is ridiculous in the extreme. By the early 70's the problem was solved thanks to Dr. Yuan Long Ping's research into rice hybridization. So crack a reputable book yourself, jroe, and present the whole story accurately.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Yuan_Longping
 
And grab a translator and view this article, and tell me if that's really what the people of Xizang Province (tibet) deserve. Because that's what they suffered from before the local Lama's and lanlord's autonomy was stripped away by the national government. I can't believe any accurately informed individual would say they should have been allowed to remain in such suffering.

http://news.xinhuanet.com/politics/2008-04/17/content_7994146.htm

This monstrous treatment and a piece of easily circumvented software are not in the same category of 'freedom'.
 
did you download it yet?

and dude, read some books not written by the chinese government. i don't want to argue with you any more but your closing your self from reality. its fine, i dont care.

1000+ TEMPLES destroyed by chinese invasion
1000's of tibetan houses and buildings destroyed, replaced by chinese concrete buildings.

each house was searched for artifacts, gold, items of value etc... and taken by the military. many items of brass, bronze and gold were taken in and recycled. most religious artifacts IMPORTANT MORE THAN LIFE to these people were taken and thrown into junk yards.

THERE ARE LESS THAN 50 TEMPLES from before the chinese invasion... which held tons of food and values for the community. they often used temples as surplus storage for when times were tough... the communists frowned upon this, emptied the surpluses and starved people to death.

surfdom is horrible and wrong, nobody is denying that... but they did want to reform and the dalai lama had planned reforms with westerners before invasion. 2 million people murdered, tortured or starved to death and your ok with that. i'm not...

i think big lebowski can sum it best: "well thats just like your opinion man".

i don't support suffering of any kind because i am buddhist regardless if its mao or bush or america or kings and queens of england. you can't SOLVE PROBLEMS THROUGH VIOLENCE, there wouldn't be an argument of tibet if it was a peaceful liberation. there would be no censorship if they were not hiding anything.

free your mind and your ass will follow.
 
Please raise your hand if you expected anything other than this reaction from China. Why anyone is “surprised” by the stuff they do over there is beyond me.

lmao @ China.:D:p

If you live in china and find a way around the filter and the commies find out they will probably kill you and your whole family :eek::rolleyes:
 
lol. hope not!

the chaos hackers group made a usb tool green onion last year for the olympics to get around it.

i believe it can be uninstalled and if not, just format and put pirated windows on it like every chinese student i know currently does... so i dont really see the point other than publicity student. people believe this crap.

if your american and support this crap, please sensor yourself first and install green dam, thanks!
 
did you download it yet?

and dude, read some books not written by the chinese government. i don't want to argue with you any more but your closing your self from reality. its fine, i dont care.

1000+ TEMPLES destroyed by chinese invasion
1000's of tibetan houses and buildings destroyed, replaced by chinese concrete buildings.

each house was searched for artifacts, gold, items of value etc... and taken by the military. many items of brass, bronze and gold were taken in and recycled. most religious artifacts IMPORTANT MORE THAN LIFE to these people were taken and thrown into junk yards.

THERE ARE LESS THAN 50 TEMPLES from before the chinese invasion... which held tons of food and values for the community. they often used temples as surplus storage for when times were tough... the communists frowned upon this, emptied the surpluses and starved people to death.

surfdom is horrible and wrong, nobody is denying that... but they did want to reform and the dalai lama had planned reforms with westerners before invasion. 2 million people murdered, tortured or starved to death and your ok with that. i'm not...

i think big lebowski can sum it best: "well thats just like your opinion man".

i don't support suffering of any kind because i am buddhist regardless if its mao or bush or america or kings and queens of england. you can't SOLVE PROBLEMS THROUGH VIOLENCE, there wouldn't be an argument of tibet if it was a peaceful liberation. there would be no censorship if they were not hiding anything.

free your mind and your ass will follow.

Yeah, yeah, yeah... and a Chinese dog ate their homework, too!

And, Dude, it's serf! And serfdom! get it right just once, OK? The law of averages should have hopped on your free ass about that already, but since it hasn't, just put down the tequila and focus... OK?
 
well i hope you never have to suffer the way tibetans have suffered, before or after the communist invasion of their homeland.

take care.
 
He did no such thing intentionally! In the 50's and 60's, due to failed economic reforms combined with floods along the Yangze River region (the agricultural heartland of China), there WAS famine, and millions did die. But the idea that Mao intentionally starved anyone, even opponents, is ridiculous in the extreme. By the early 70's the problem was solved thanks to Dr. Yuan Long Ping's research into rice hybridization. So crack a reputable book yourself, jroe, and present the whole story accurately.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Yuan_Longping


You are right, he didn't do it intentionally. He just allowed it to happen and indirectly caused it to happen by instilling fear in his subordinates.

Under the Great Leap Forward, Mao and other party leaders ordered the implementation of a variety of unproven and unscientific new agricultural techniques by the new communes. Combined with the diversion of labor to steel production and infrastructure projects and the reduced personal incentives under a commune system this led to an approximately 15% drop in grain production in 1959 followed by further 10% reduction in 1960 and no recovery in 1961. In an effort to win favor with their superiors and avoid being purged, each layer in the party hierarchy exaggerated the amount of grain produced under them and based on the fabricated success, party cadres were ordered to requisition a disproportionately high amount of the true harvest for state use primarily in the cities and urban areas but also for export.
--- Wiki


That goes along with his other crimes:

"Mao himself claimed that a total of 700,000 people were executed during the years 1949–53.[21] However, because there was a policy to select "at least one landlord, and usually several, in virtually every village for public execution",[22] the number of deaths range between 2 million and 5 million.[23][24] In addition, at least 1.5 million people were sent to "reform through labour" camps.[25] Mao’s personal role in ordering mass executions is undeniable.[26][27] He defended these killings as necessary for the securing of power.[28]" --- Wiki


There is a nice long article on him if you want to read it. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mao_Zedong


Lastly, why would China fall to pieces if its populace were allowed freedom of information and communication? Possibly because they aren't happy and would be willing to die for change if allowed the chance?
 
those are very low statistics, but most likely because its a small year range. between 1930-1970 is much higher i imagine.

however i read a funny quote once... if you took what the tibetans and other groups say (like democratic parties that were squished or christians etc)... added them all together lets say it totals to 60 million

and china says 1 million... its probably somewhere in the middle lets say 30 million.

either way 10 people is to much , 1 million is crazy
 
Back
Top