Metals conduct well; materials like cardboard conduct poorly. Conduction tells you how well a current can move through a material, not how well it holds a charge.
Cardboard can hold a charge fairly well.
If you're looking for a non-static material, you have to get a material that conducts well and is grounded. Anti-static mats are usually a plastic treated to make it conductive and are attached to a wire that you then attach to a ground point.