British Hacker Spared Extradition to U.S

Can you please show me where I said he was innocent of rape? Didn't think so...good job taking things out of content. Your credibility now is 0.

Have a nice day!

Meh I fucked up. Thought it was you in support of JA in the other thread a few weeks back. It wasnt so I stand corrected. However, your still wrong suggesting someone who doesn't take necessary precautions in all scenarios deserves some blame. So I stand vindicated!!!:D
 
Essentially his main crime is embarrassing a lot of senior US Govt officials that had not been doing their job properly. Thanks to this guy a possibly far worse situation was avoided.

Yes he caused some damage and yes he should be punished. However, I do not think it warranted 60 years in the Pen. 200 hours community service and a fine would have been sufficient.

I would say 10 years of constant fear and worry will also have been more punishment than the civil courts would have dolled out.

However, I do not agree to a UK citizen being subjected to essentially a grandstanding showtrial to be given a ridiculously absurd sentence.

I'm sure a US hacker wouldn't have gotten anywhere near 6 years let alone 60, had he done that to MI5/MI6.

But the question that has to be asked is, had it been a US citizen that had walked into UK security servers, would he have been extradited from the US?

I doubt that very much indeed. What's good for the goose....
 
"I am SOLO. I will continue to disrupt at the highest levels …" -Gary McKinnon txt file left on one of the military servers. He admitted to this. This is not looking for UFO's.

Also, he didn't delete soup recipe's, the US authorities claim he deleted weapons logs and operating systems files. This would be intentionally disrupting the US military. I personally think he did this in the same way a jerkface might throw eggs at a police station. It's a juvenile attack that cost a lot of employee time to fix. $700,000 in US government time isn't all that much, and relative to copying a few MP3's the way we calculate things here now apparently.

Funny thing is I'm certain it's cost the UK government more than $700,000 to not extradite him so far, and he's served more house arrest then what I expect his prison time would have been if he was extradited. (See Chad Davis, 6 months, or other hackers who've been convicted of hacking military sites mischievously.) This is before they likely try him and sentence him in the UK.
 
Would the US extradite a US citizen to answer for crimes in the UK if it was the other way around?
 
Would the US extradite a US citizen to answer for crimes in the UK if it was the other way around?

No.

Extradition treaties with the US are invariably lopsided so that it is easier to extradite to the US than from the US.
 
Would the US extradite a US citizen to answer for crimes in the UK if it was the other way around?

Almost certainly ... the US might be a little cautious with extraditions to totalitarian countries but an ally like the UK he would have been on the next plane over there ... unless he was related to some very very powerful people ... all bets are off in that case ... anybody else better get used to kidney pie and tea and crumpets (or whatever they serve in the British penal system) ;)
 
No.

Extradition treaties with the US are invariably lopsided so that it is easier to extradite to the US than from the US.

Hardly ... we'll send you back to be executed unless you have very powerful relatives ... the US has no problems extraditing normal citizens ... the only exception would be if a person is charged in the US and another country and we think we will give them a harsher penalty ... in that case we would keep them here ... that is especially true if we can execute them and we think someone else won't ... this has come up several times in Texas with wussy countries who don't have the death penalty and try and protect immigrants to the US that we have sentenced to die
 
Hardly ... we'll send you back to be executed unless you have very powerful relatives ... the US has no problems extraditing normal citizens ... the only exception would be if a person is charged in the US and another country and we think we will give them a harsher penalty ... in that case we would keep them here ... that is especially true if we can execute them and we think someone else won't ... this has come up several times in Texas with wussy countries who don't have the death penalty and try and protect immigrants to the US that we have sentenced to die

Considering the propensity of Texas to execute (murder) innocent people, I don't blame them.

The extradition treaty has different "standards of evidence" of which the UK has a higher burden than the US. The US merely has to allege something, the UK has to have evidence.
 
Considering the propensity of Texas to execute (murder) innocent people, I don't blame them.

The extradition treaty has different "standards of evidence" of which the UK has a higher burden than the US. The US merely has to allege something, the UK has to have evidence.

The UK has a different standard ... only they can judge whether that is better or worse than the US standard ... in this case we met the burden of proof ... it was a disagreement over the penalty that caused the extradition delays ... the penalty the person might face should have no bearing on whether they will extradite to the US ... even the Brits don't deny he violated our laws ... they were just disputing the penalty ... as I have stated, I do not agree with the diminished capacity defense in this case or any other :cool:

and there has never been proof of an innocent person being executed in Texas or any other state that permits executions ... it probably will happen someday (it might possibly have happened already) ... but no one has proven that ... ironically the opponents of the death penalty have seen a reduction because of the shortage of the drugs for lethal injection ... apparently we don't want the criminals to suffer while they are being executed and we can't execute them without one of the required painkillers :rolleyes:
 
The UK has a different standard ... only they can judge whether that is better or worse than the US standard ... in this case we met the burden of proof ... it was a disagreement over the penalty that caused the extradition delays ... the penalty the person might face should have no bearing on whether they will extradite to the US ... even the Brits don't deny he violated our laws ... they were just disputing the penalty ... as I have stated, I do not agree with the diminished capacity defense in this case or any other :cool:

and there has never been proof of an innocent person being executed in Texas or any other state that permits executions ... it probably will happen someday (it might possibly have happened already) ... but no one has proven that ... ironically the opponents of the death penalty have seen a reduction because of the shortage of the drugs for lethal injection ... apparently we don't want the criminals to suffer while they are being executed and we can't execute them without one of the required painkillers :rolleyes:

Oh, really?
 
Back
Top